Steemians... I greet you. At times things happen and we continue to watch as though it's not our business. But in actual sense, it is our business — steem blockchain is a global business. @ned and @dan may have given us steem ecosystem but its chief means of sustenance is global investment. Hence, if anything happens to steem blockchain (God forbid) all of us — both Dick and Harry — would have our fingers to bite. Steem blockchain is a global project. All of us have a stake in it and as stakeholders and true lovers of steem blockchain, it behoves us to speak up when things are going wrong.
.png)
World's renown literary icon, Chinua Achebe, once said and I quote...
"When an adult is in the house, a she-goat is not left to suffer the pains of parturition on its tether."
Steemit, as we know it, is rapidly changing. Things are getting more frustrating by the day. Today, I have choosen not to remain silent anymore. Today, I have choosen to be the voice of thousands of minnows whose efforts are being frustrated daily by those at helm of affairs of utopian-io — a well thought out project — but who are afraid to speak up for fear of their future contributions being rejected, flagged or coming under permanent suspension from making utopian-io targeted posts.
As a Steem-Ambassador, I shouldn't shy away from lending my voice against obvious misdirection of what happens to be the biggest and most impactful project ever built on steem blockchain. I am aware that respected Steemians (most of who had delegated their SP to utopian-io) whose opinions are not taking with pinch of salt may not have been aware of the current happenings at utopian-io, neither do successful steemians; in fact, I believe, any Steemian who sees $5/post would not border himself with making utopian-io targeted posts.
That is to say that those who would have spoken up may not have been in the know. Utopian-io is flooded mostly with people who are in dire need to earn, people who are on the verge of abandoning their accounts, people who spend hours drafting a post and at the end of the day they earn less than $1. And I don't think steemit, as we see it, will be interesting without minnows and other low ranking members.
This post is not a call for people to withdraw their delegations nor for @ned to cancel his own but for utopian-io policy makers to have a rethink on the way they keep making unfavorable policy changes that seem to be against the tenets for which this project was created and massively supported. It is a call for respected and influential Steemians to call @elear and his team to order.
Why would @ned and team be busy working for successful adoption of Hardfork 0.20.0 while utopian-io leadership is busy churning out policies that seem to be antagonistic to the goals of the upcoming Hardfork?
Among the major issues Harfork 0.20.0 would take care of is fastening the process of account creation to attract millions of users to steem ecosystem...
...to support signup improvements on Steemit.com and other sites to bring more users into the Steem ecosystem.
We want to grow Steem to at least to size of Reddit, hopefully larger. Reddit currently has 234 million unique users a month...
Having read what to expect with successful adoption of Hardfork 0.20.0, I decided to speak up against what I consider obnoxious, stifling and unstable policies being churned out daily at utopian-io, which are obviously against the tenets of the proposed Hardfork 0.20.0. @ned and team are concerned with increasing the userbase of steemit.com while the process to achieve that is being unfairly hampered by those who should encourage it.
To be honest, I had wanted to write this post in January when there was a sudden change in requirements for Visibility Category, but an utopian.io Supervisor, having heard my views, said I had valid points and advised I communicate utopian-io team via their Suggestion-for-rule-change Channel. I did as advised and will upload the screenshots at appropriate paragraph in this article.
My case against utopian-io overseers and Why I am raising this issue at this time
I believe if there is any few Steemians who have given their time, energy and resources for success of steem blockchain, I, without sounding immodest, am among. Few weeks after I joined steemit and had realized the benefits of population to steem health, using whatsaap as a communication tool, I convinced 67 persons of my whatsaap contacts to join steemit. This post is not intended to write about my contributions in detail but I have to highlight some of my important achievements so that you appreciate my background and passion for the success of steem blockchain. You can go here, here and here to get a glimpse of what I have been able to do within the time I have been here. It was on the bases of my achievements that I was made a @sndbox fellow and then much later a Steem-Ambassador.
I am one of the Steemians genuinely concerned about the success of this program. I am wearing steemit shoe and can tell exactly where the needle is pinching me. @euronation, a newbie recruitment scheme I have the privilege of founding and leading, is built from the scratch. Over 90% of its 260+ members was recruited through my whatsaap based visibility effort. These are virgin Steemians that I recruited and inspired i
to become hyperactive Steemians.
utopian-io leadership banned whatsaap based visibility contributions
The fact that I had started my whatsaap based webinar on Steemit program long before utopian-io was founded, should tell you that utopian-io rewards wasn't the motivating factor. However, when utopian-io came onboard, I was happy that at least one would be getting some form of rewards for the difficult task of onboarding and guiding new people.
So I, in consultation with @euronation leadership, decided to create an account @euronation for #Euronation community. And the intention was to build its Steem power via earnings from utopian-io rewarded whatsaap based visibility campaigns and use it to curate posts of @euronation community members, who are earning less than $0.05/post. This was my grand plan and I was out to get it executed. Consequently, all my whatsaap based visibility efforts were being reported via @euronation account and submitted to utopian-io for curation.
Day in day out, I used to be all over the internet, joining forums and hundreds of whatsaap rooms to invite people to my webinar. I had had to change my line severally due to Whatsaap and Telegram bans all in determined effort to onboard more people and also build the community account. So you can imagine my frustration when I learnt, surprisingly, that utopian-io no longer accept whatsaap-based visibility posts.
For what reasons did utopian-io leadership ban whatsaap-based visibility posts
I wanted to know if utopian-io leadership have valid reasons for such action, so I went to find out why. And disappointedly, I was told it doesn't cost much to promote Steemit program via whatsaap. Secondly, there are a lot of contributions from that category, and so to them, it is ideal to discourage contributions in that category. Okay. Good and fine.Please read on to see why utopian-io team must be called to order.
I couldn't take it. I went to their Suggestion-for-rule-change Channel and left this complaint as shown by the screenshot image below...
My complaint was thrown into the waste bin, of course
And the new rule?
As part of the new conditions, any visibility effort must have proof of 1000 reach. Promoters responded by using sponsored ad placement on social media (Facebook, tweeter, etc) and were achieving the target. This didn't go down well with utopian-io leadership, and the threshold was raised to 5000 reach. The promoters was hitting that figure. The leadership responded yet again and raised the required reach to 10000. As if that's not enough, below is screenshot of additional conditions that must be met and those being considered, as responded by a member of my community who's in the know...
These stifling policies are not only targeted against visibility category. Any category where there seems to be increasing contributions automatically becomes a target. And one is tempted to ask if utopian-io policy makers are not happy when they see people get rewarded for their contributions. At first, I thought, maybe, they are running out of voting power but, lo and behold, that's not the case as a several checks on their voting power showed it sitting conformably at 100% almost always.
Conclusion: The proposed HF0.20.0 should start with utopian-io
I read in the news today about the dire state of cryptocurrencies and how 10 out of 11 major social media sites had banned cryptocurrency ad placement. And I ask; should we continue to look for where to place ad while we can encourage people to go on massive recruitment campaigns?
Utopian-io alone has the capacity to cause the influx of new members to steem ecosystem by rewarding those who are out in the field, working endlessly to onboard new people. The proposed Hardfork 0.20.0 risk not achieving its aims if the current happenings at utopian-io (with respect to visibility category) are not properly addressed. Let the proposed Hardfork 0.20.0 starts at utopian-io first!
Follow @eurogee, the Steemit's Witness Voting Advocate & Host, Show Us Your Witnesses Weekly Contest. Follow @euronation, An International Support Scheme For New And Struggling Steemians
Join us on Telegram and whatsaap through the below links:
Don't Exit Without Voting For Witnesses!
No Witnesses = No Steem Blockchain; If You Truly Love Here, Vote For Witnesses NOW!
Click This Link To Vote Now
Witnesses are equivalent to life and blood of steem blockchain. Without them, the blockchain will seize to function and we will all be stranded here. Click here to read more on why it is important to vote for witnesses
Hello @eurogee. I spent some time reading this post and the only thing I was able to catch is that you are against our rules, especially Visibility ones.
Let me explain you the following:
Rules are the result of continuous improvement based on community behaviours.
Rules are the results of legal issues that have to be handled.
There are laws which clearly say no promotion should happen without project owner's consensus. This we discovered lately and reacted accordingly.
Specifically for Whatsapp we have had too much of abuses and we believe whatsapp is not the right tool to promote Open Source projects.
but who are afraid to speak up for fear of their future contributions being rejected, flagged or coming under permanent suspension from making utopian-io targeted posts.
Looking at your rejected contributions https://utopian.io/@eurogee/contributions/flagged:
On each and every contributions that was rejected our Moderators gave you great details for the reasons. Here an example which you have not even replied to: https://utopian.io/utopian-io/@eurogee/towards-a-greater-visibility-for-utopian-io-platform-the-report-of-my-webinar-proceedings-with-members-of-euronation-1.
Here on another example: https://utopian.io/utopian-io/@eurogee/suggestion-for-busy-org-build-redeem-rewards-button-to-transfer-earned-rewards-to-appropriate-wallets
Utopian is for Open Source contributors who can provide valuable contributions, not for everyone. For that you have Steemit or Busy.org. We work constantly to improve quality in our platform and this is for the benefit of us all. I would suggest to look into community behaviour to understand where Utopian is going and the community behaviour so far has forced us to go stricter and stricter and we will keep doing it until the community can provide TOP quality contributions.
Last but not least we are on a full team restructure, which will see Supervisors going away and a new role, Community managers to show up, which will have more responsibilities, especially helping and supporting the community constantly.
Thanks for your feedback
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Hey @eurogee,
While it is definitely your right to share thoughts about any matter that concerns you, yet I believe you are unable to see the big picture, and this being because you are not involved in the daily moderation (curation) activities that our utopian team goes through on a daily basis - being a supervisor I have hands on experience with this, and most importantly the huge amount of abuse and "milking the system" activities that we see.
We are constantly faced with duplicate accounts, plagiarized content, stolen tutorials, pointless promotions, machine and incorrect translations,...to name a few, and those at times require drastic measures.
For visibility, and as a quick example, we have seen people promoting projects they have no clue about (2, 3, or 4 projects a day) nor that it would benefit neither the project nor the target audience, and hence causing more harm than usefulness to the project itself, and to steemit/utopian image (even legally this could backfire).
I am sure that is not what you would like to see happen, you know being a steemit-ambassador myself and a utopian supervisor, that's not the image I want to show or have about steemit and utopian :)
We are putting our utmost efforts into making the rules as fair to all, but also making sure to only reward the most valued, otherwise those who truly deserve will not get the reward they should be, and the vote power/reward pool will be abused. Have you seen something similar like this in steemit recently? :)
True, there will be times were good efforts will not be rewarded due to stricter rules, there is no such thing as a perfect system or rules, yet unfortunately that is a difficult situation were we hope won't happen too often.
Utopian rules are a continuous work in progress, and the team is in constant brainstorming about improving them, suggestions are always welcome.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Thanks you for such a detailed response my friend @mcfarhat. You are one of the few steemians I have great respect for. However, I do have some valid reasons to Disagree with you in this case, with all dues respect.
This is why I maintain that a standard should be out in place before any promoter is rewarded with say $60 worth of upvote. Utopian-io team can come up with something like...
Before a visibility post on steemit.com is accepted, the promoter must introduce 10 people and guide them to hit 30 reputation score
Now that above is a Reasonable target and anu one who wish to participate can go head and participate with a clear vision of what to deliver and amount to earn.
If 10 person do this in a day, that's 100 new persons introduced to steem ecosystem. With time, here will beehive of activities by people buying or selling steem. This whole thing will have positive impact on the price of steem cryptocurrency.
The current rules do not encourage the growth of this platform.
I am against it sire
@eurogee
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
@eurogee I never meet you before and have never visited your blog before, but I respect you from the way you address this.
I believe if @elear see to this rule and suggestion you bringing up..it will help the community along way..seriously with all the rules implemented in utopian-io contributors are withdrawing from contributing to open source projects.
I really buy the idea of bringing in 10 people and guide to reach a reputation of 30 and with that you will know how much you will be paid for it.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I had long suggested this but their unjust stance wouldn't let them see it. Steemit.com is a global project. How can a clique of people be preventing a way to make it more visible to potential investors and bloggers. This place stincks! Enough of these injustices!
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Thanks for your valuable feedback @mcfarhat!
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Hey bro @Eurogee,
thanks for speaking out. Are we going to be stoned for saying the truth?
Its appalling. Utopian used to be "the hope" now they have become "the toad" that croaks loud noises into our ears.
You know what they say,
We need to say much more about all these dapp with the help of data. They are seriously underusing the SP that has been given to them.
They end up voting on particular set of people.
Very soon we may need to campaign and boycott all those dapps. At least they won't be cutting part of our earnings after refusing to ever curate.
@NairaDaddy, Founder of @Air-Clinic, Sndbox-Fellow & Steem-Ambassador
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Utopian is not voting and has never voted a particular set of people. Our voting bot is Open Source and has always been like that. Latest version is here for everyone to review. https://github.com/utopian-io/api.utopian.io/blob/master/src/utopian-bot-new.ts
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Hey @Elear,
with all due respect, the Utopian moderators are not doing the job. Sometimes they just reject a project without due consideration. Humanity demands that when you look at the amount of effort a person put in, even if you feel its missing a few standards, you can point it out for the person to edit. But no, whether out of unfathomable bias or jealosy they outrightly rejected a well-crafted project of ours.
Just take a look at this: The Medical Utopian Project- Air-Clinic's Minified Whitepaper
Up till today, I still don't understand why it was rejected without an opportunity for fair hearing or at least to edit certain things. This is a project that began from scratch as an Open-source project. We built a website for it and placed it on github. So why the rejection @elear?
That wasn't the first time it was happening. I don't want to say more.
We all know that the bots follow what the moderators do, and your moderators and supervisors are biased as far as I can tell.
I'm going to pull data and prove to the entire steem community that the leaders of Utopian-io are biased towards steemians in the use of their powers.
One even insulted me inbox. I don't need to mention names but its appalling.
Its sad that these same people also make Utopian contributions and quickly get verified. So is Utopian now a community for only the mods?
Perhaps, mods and sups should be stopped from contributing to Utopian because they are going to be biased always.
Utopian is turning into a giant circle-jerk for mods & sups.
I just hope that @elear can intervene. I read your blog story of how you started from the bottom as a young boy without a father. Give others a chance to shine too through the Utopian project.
Humans make rules not the other way around.
Thank you!
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Oh @nairadaddy this is so awesome of you, i could remember same story and its appalling its the same Elear that was supposed to help others too, listen to the manipulations of his supervisors and mods... I see them coming out, its a shame the same Elear we know is no longer same person.
We all spend data, Money to run a post, all they do is reject it outrightly. I just hope the sponsors look into this..
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
if i am not mistaken the only Mod i know that normally defines users contributions as nonsense is ariestem, He has a ph degree with that insult embedded in him.
But we were told not to insult Mods but indirectly ☺ they keep insulting us.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
That's exactly what you and your team do.. And there are even evidence of this.. Where a post that did not even meet specifications was approved and Upvoted because the account was connected to one of your super MODs.. And it's shocking the speed with which you replied this post..
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
It is a very disheartening condition. Those who are passionate for this scheme are not being supported. How will steemit.com achieve its target of onboarding over 200 million people monthly with the current happenings? @ned and team need to look in to this!
@eurogee
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Well written @kekegist! It is amazing they still keep defending this obvious manipulation seen by many steemians. They can keep telling us what is not the case but we know these responses are games.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Hey @eurogee. I gave my time to read all what you said in here and i give you my point in such terms you had explained. Utopian hold his shield by its rules agains the abuse and that is not so good for minnows to grow. I see and i can understand your concern about that. The fact is, utopian never meant to be a minnow supporter. There is another platforms a single person can do anything with. For example, "d" series i am calling. Entertainment is something for all! Let's see what visibility is;
Marketing and visibility actions for a brand.
In a modern world, every company acting carefully to carry their brand to the top. Under these circumstances they make a roadmap in order to improve their brand exactly "where they want to carry". You or me or someone else can not just pop-up and say something what we want to say by the rules of many goverments. Complain ? yes for sure!
Thin line in between "bad intention" and "good will"
How can someone say my intention good or bad ? At the same time i am protecting human being but in another way i am giving a bad name to the steemit itself also this is coming out by support of @utopian-io.
I am working with utopian as Moderator and Supervisor. since the very beginning. Not anymore. Yes platform has changed its behaviour in so many stricter way. Can not just blame the community abusers but also the reward balance was going on irrelevant subjects. Instead of concerning about the newcomers, we all have to think over about the good "content" in steemit. How could we pull more "qualified" persons into steem ecosystem while there is a tons of posts even against several ethic and written rules?
I hope
Utopian working hard to find a balance in there, i saw that so far. Yet nothing is perfect for new and marginal idea especially in more marginal platform! Lets give more feedback and suggestions to the utopian to make it perfect all together!
Thanks for reading.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Bros, uncle, woss!!!
Utopian isn't democratic.
Making suggestions and airing our views goes no where beyond the timeline on the time of posting. Why waste valuable insufficient energy profering solutions and suggestions that wouldn't even have a rethink..
The more the rules become stricter, the more the platform creates enemies, not in a violent way though. But very soon utopian will realise they can't actually survive without the backing of people
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Hey hey @kodeblacc. I am a living witness that they are caring the suggestions by users. My suggestions was based on the "technical aspects" of utopian and they made some, they does not made some another. I do still believe as long as there is an @elear in charge, utopian will be more friendly with its users. Stricter rules are making damage to the wallets, that is why utopian creating an enemies in short and long term with stricter rules. Yes, platform was driven by community 2-3 months ago but the community could not take that chance for giving a decision to get a more quality. Lately, utopian started to make changes for "all". As far as i know there will be more changes to catch a frequency in utopian. The account of @utopian-io is also chronicle about its progress. Thus, can be analyzed easily where utopian came from and where utopian goes right now. I am wondering a future of utopian as like you do.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Your opinion is well noted. Thanks you.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I won't say much, but you are also guilty of this, starting a conversation with out proper explanation and defending what you started this has happened more than 7 scenario both from me and some other contributors, using us to live your frustrated life hun
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Well, i have no single clue what you are talking about but as far as i understood you kinda blame me about utopian's decisions. I have nothing to do with.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
thanks @eurogee. Well i love utopian but where my anger always gets to rage is seeing the contributors as suckers , fraud and money grabbers. I took my very time to check all accounts, details of all utopian administration but all i see are those that are nothing, that never made it in steemit, that never contributed positively in steem blockchain making the loudest noise while those brain ones are even taking it cool and Giving full respect to contributors.
Without sponsors there will be no utopian as for now (future always exist), without contributors there will be no utopian and without contributors there will be no sponsors even. All boils down to contributors drives utopian community at large. Why cant moderators and others stop looking down at contributors. The worst is, many of those contributors are not even your mate in all respect. They can feed utopian community atlarge just they love doing what they love to do best. Utopian stop calling your contributors gold diggers. The other time one mod called a contributors work NONSENSE. (what an insult to someone that pays you?)
Yes contributors pays you , without contributors you will never earn 0.5 steem.
I dont want to go into cases of mods abused by those that feel have utopian in their hand and controls it as they like. (an open source project but closed for some)
@elear , Atleast i cant forget on how my judgement was handled without allowing the person to speak. ( you know what? Those involved just show how primitive and undeveloped they are. Learn from you mistake and pray never to make the same mistake at first)
On rule issues, I always wonder on how contributors keep making rule for utopian, because that what it entails. Utopian never made a single rule, we all know, they rushed to rules with intention of blocking contributors from getting rewards. Pls no normal enlightend community behaves that way. It only exist in a tirant community.
Please utopian sponsors, i think its time utopian have fully independent contributors community as well. Its really urgent and so needed.
Those at the top of the affair, remember there exist no law of innertia in this steem blockchain.
Thanks.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
to be frank sire, you have been one of those , i remembered you rejecting numerous contributions for no reasons, justify you self if you can, i think that was the reason you got suspended kettle calling the pot black, don't be ridiculous.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
wow I am happy you said this on this open community because one of the reason was having much accepted contribution than rejected contributions. so i am surprise seeing this now.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Yeah of course, you shouldn't be happy much bout that, you used to reject much contributions and you were warned, you change tactics to approve so many contributions in order to get huge weekly rewards.
wooola it backfired
I may not be contributing often again like i do before but i been trolling utopian every contributions and reading a lot gathering more experience for something like this, i can say i know more acts of most moderators with this new methods of mine.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Smiles. I enjoyed your sermon, seems like true. Laugh hard. Im happy a vote to stay went in my favour but no need taking any of their exams again. I love contributing and i think i enjoyed it more because i get more time associating with my steemit family
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Well said Doctor Igwe
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Very well said.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Well what I will say is utopian lost its vision, it was meant to be a community driven witness but now it's a utopian supervisors driven witness community. It's a shame they never think of the other side(contributors) while making their do called rules, and @elear keep been tossed around like a coin by different utopian supervisors. Such a pity. Thanks @eurogee for speaking on behalf of all contributors.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
@Onos we have conferences every week where you can participate and share your feedbacks live. Supervisors are even going to be replaced by another role, the announcement will be released soon and was discussed several times.
utopian supervisors driven witness community
Making the above sentence completely irrelevant.
Thanks for your feedback. Wishing to see you during our conferences.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Actually @elear its sad to say, but utopian is company driven now, it should be a company but a community-driven platform, but whats happening is, utopian right now is getting decentralized and not a community-driven platform anymore. - @ruah
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Thank you for lending a voice!
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Hello @elear,,
I didn't want to say a word but I couldn't hold it anymore
I like your project and the idea behind it.
Initially, with the first 3months of inception of utopian, I can attest that you were doing good job. Though some of Utopian new strict, stringent rules and policies are due to abuse by various contributors, but the fact remains that @elear has attain a position that had put him out of reach. He can only be reached through grumps that gave him directives as feedbacks.
I could remember when @elear would listen to people, respond to suggestions and work with them. But now, it's all history. He even changed his display picture that left no difference with that his dev. Making me believe I was conversing with the right person while I was seeking a permission to go for a particular project.
I was misunderstood. He places my fate in the hands of the grumpy ones. And @elear ignored my cry even after several knock at his door. I quitted my job for utopian and all of my plans and ambitions was chattered. Utopian is being overtaken by illusions rather than the love it started with.
I was locked out like I had no face. No one listen to me. No fair hearing - treated like I came from another man's land. My earnings for the period was gone. It's all seemed to me like I was wasting my time working as a mod for utopian. I was treated like I had the intention to steal from utopian.
Working as a mod, takes away your fans and friends on steemit. You will have no time for your blog. I had to began to build from the scratch.
This is what utopian did to me. Was utopian fair about this?
I'm very sure they will have something to counter this but I don't think I will be happy with @elear if he doesn't realise this.
I have every evidence of my chats with you and the supposedly elear on discord.
This may not be proper to air but it is the right time. You will need to begin to endeavour to listen to people and not merely only what few supervisors chip in to you. This is because some of them actually give you directives to be the good boy and not how it should be.
Maybe this wouldn't have sprung up if you had attend to @eurogee's complain.
Do well to make things better.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I used to be a fan of utopian-io not cause of reward but also yea for the reward (Come for the reward, stay for the community)
I wanted to grow with it, the project. and be part of the success story, But in a twinkle of an eye everything changed, yea of course we know you can please anyone but its life don't deplease the majority, '' with great powers comes great responsibilities"
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Very unfortunate. I know the egghead of the many manipulations happening at utopian-io. I know his name and I will bring him to public court at appropriate time. @elear is a kindhearted man but needs to sit up and stand like a man he is! I know the happenings today isn't him intentions. A man must be a man and act like a man!
This is aberration of highest order. Dammit!
@eurogee
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
LOL°°
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
For those interested, this announcement should cover all of what discussed here https://steemit.com/utopian-io/@utopian-io/utopian-io-reborn-smarter-simpler-better
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Actuality I saw this coming right from the start, even when utopian came into existence. As the first utopian moderator before been removed without any reason but racist and decision of some mod who are into competition of meeting one another, they are really killing utopian bit by bit. @elear It is time for you to make the right decision and stop allow them to destroy what you build.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
@valchiz making such statements without any kind of provable scenario is kind of extreme. Our moderators come from the most disparate countries, religions, mindsets and political views. We are a community of international people which are being selected by simply their will and skills to help reviewing and improving the platform. No one ever has ever racist approach and in the rare few cases where different opinions caused issues, Utopian has always reacted proactively.
If you have had any of these serious issues, please get in touch with, reporting the moderator and a provable scenario. I will personally react accordingly.
Thanks for your feedback.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
There are proofs and I'm one of them.
I just replied to one of your comments.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Back then, Utopian-io used to be a community driven witness, but now its like everything is becoming centralized, wherea company shows its supremacy to workers, i have seen a lot of injustice from moderators but i just complain and forget, It hurts, but its Internet we smile and pretend everything is fine
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
You are a true ambassador.. Utopian is being manipulated even the coordinator @elear is being pushed to do things i never imagined. I hope they turn around good and favour people. Awesome post boss...
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Thank you for lending a voice.
@eurogee
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Las las utopian is racist.
Virtually almost all the rules are to spite Africans. If Africans aren't needed on the platform it should be said plainly.
When the recent visibility rule was implemented, I saw some posts made by a Nigerian and the mod said his promotion was useless and the guy met all the requirements of the rule. Same week another post was made, not so detailed with several typos and grammatical yet approved.
So what does this prove??
Some posts are acceptable and some are not?
It means there is no transparency and the utopian platform is just how the supervisors and mods want it to be.
Las las power doesn't belong to "The People" but specific people
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
It's a pain really...
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I tell you bruh..
What I don't get is the fact mods and supervisors say we are milking the platform.
Like they don't also make contributions after being paid weekly for moderating duties @scipio will make python tutorials and convert it to season film. Isn't that milking? No it's making tea sef
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
They fix the role of "opportunist" on us despite everything. Change and fairness ia what utopian needs right now.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Baba they don't care right now.
They will soon though..
They dunno how we can be when it comes to matters that affect us online.
1 small online rally
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Hahahahaahha.. Aboki, pour me tea, i wan do michai
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I know that if public opinion are consulted, apart from probably @elear and @mcfarhat and couple of other guys, a large chunk of them can't come clean. Dammit. @elear has allowed himself to be manipulated and tossed about like a suspended pendulum. Dammit!
People who have never tried bringing one person onboard and who don't know how difficult such task is! Dammit. Dammit!
Look at visibility category, the heart of Steemit, is being assaulted with unreasonable policies. Dammit!
. @eurogee
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
As much as I agree with your views, I frown at the word 'racism'. please don't use it here next time.
@eurogee
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Thanks bro.
Would try not to use the word although I'm 100percent sure of what I'm saying.
Experienced it first hand
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Thanks for your understanding
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Truth be told .. Utopian is currently been manipulated by its supervisors.. No longer a community driven witness. Thanks for speaking on our behalf..
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Exactly. I know the Brain behind all the manipulations
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Well @eurogee, thank you for this valiant act. Personally, i couldn't finish a campaign i had already borrowed money to start only Because the rules changed after i had started and it has been discouraging.
Amd I'm still receiving feedbacks from people who got jear of steemit for the first time through that.
The sp are delegated and i don't think the leadership is there to saveguard it but to use it wisely not obstruct every opportunity for it to be used.
Thanks. Re-steemed!
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Utopian is upvoting everyone who is capable to provide quality contributions. Decisions is made by a huge group of community people which react based on rules and guidelines we construct to protect us, you and the whole steem community from abusers.
No other community has been proved to provide such a good distribution as we did in the past few months. Data is public and accessible by everyone to review.
Thanks for your feedback
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Sir, with due respect, most of those contributions were made when utopian was accessible to the general steemit community. If the drastic changes in the rules which has made them unrealistic is your tool of protection, then you have succeeded in protecting us all from contributing to the project.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Their actions are tantamount to working against the ideals and lofty dreams of @ned and his team. I wonder how steemit can grow to the extent of Registrations over 200 million people monthly when one of the credible avenue to that is being suffocated. Dammit!
@eurogee
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
My boss, i always like your realness...when i met you in our Enugu Steem meet-up, i told you that you are so real and here again, its only a real person that can make up this very real post. Thanks a lot. Your boy @mrxplicit.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
My boss, i always like your realness...when i met you in our Enugu Steem meet-up, i told you that you are so real and here again, its only a real person that can make up this very real post. Thanks a lot. Your boy @mrxplicit.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Well said sir even the utopians world are not helping we the so called newbies promoting that dey support this should look up to for the betterment of so called steemit
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I gave up on the visibility category the day i made a well detailed post, followed all the rules to the last bit and achieved an excellent result.
Here's the link to the post.
I was shocked when the mod rejected the post just because they think i forced the project owner to give me permission... How do i even force someone that's so many KM away from me to give me permission or did i put a gun to his head or what... I know how many days and resources that was channelled to that contribution. Until they put their shit together, I am not going to waste my resources there again.
I just hope @elear puts utopian.io in order soon.
Thank you @eurogee for speaking up.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
One of the moderators rejected my post that it was not beneficial and i just wanted to make money (just an assumption, no prove)
He went on to say i should contact the project owner (there was no rule like that then)
So aggressive, he said his decision was final and there was nothing i could do about it.
I complained but no one responded.
The moderators behave like gods
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
You guys should be our voice and speak for us, steemit is becoming so discouraging and a lot of minnows efforts sidelined. Something need to be done and real fast.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
You are right.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Steem ambassador fots you perfectly sir @eurogee because of your big heart to the platform especially to us minnows and babay minnows, honestly i didn't exactly understand everything maybe a little but not all... but with the way you are saying it I can feel the need to take action about the issue.... thanj you sir @eurogee... May you be blessed with strength and good health so you can continue to be our Ambassador...😘😘😘❤️
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Thanks you my friend for your support
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I honestly wish I understand Al these terms. Utopian and Hardfork sound so foreign but if you are fighting this course, I believe you are doing the right thing because as far as steemit is concerned, you are one passionate fellow I know
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Thank you Zizy for taking your time to identify with this cause. I am pissed!
@eurogee
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
well said bro...
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Thanks
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
They call contributors gullible and gold diggers, lol, i just laugh at them...
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Thanks @eurogee for voicing out for all .....
Its really painful for one to have to work really hard on a post and it get rejected for no reason or reason not understood🤷🏼♀️......
We Nigerians are known to endure a lot , we don’t give up easily ....
That’s why with all the rejections people still strive to come up with something better...
But this continuous change of rules hasn’t been helping ....
My thoughts
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Thats exactly my point! Thanks
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I hope they all see this...
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I have taken time to read through the entire post and each commentary and replies made and one thing is clear, the utopian-io leadership have failed woefully in separating wheat from chaff.
Policies have indeed been made by the utopian-io leadership to checkmate fraudulent acts on the visibility category, but have failed to see genuine contributors amidst the fake ones due to what I would like to call " INCOMPETENT" and " LACKADAISICAL" attitude on the part of the utopian-io Mods and Sups that have failed to carry out proper investigation before approving anything, but preferred to tighten up the rules, thereby punishing goats and sheep alike.
However, I call on @elear to have a total reshuffle of the Mods and Sups in the category fore mentioned with high capacity and willingness to properly investigate all contributions before approval as a yardstick for appointment.
A big thanks to @eurogee for this post. I am a beneficiary if his WhatsApp campaign for the growth and promotion of the steem block chain and its disheartening to learn from this post that his tireless efforts are going unrewarded.
I sure wouldn't have known what steemit is all about if not for his #Euronation WhatsApp and telegram groups, need I to remind you that in NIGERIA, WhatsApp and telegram is a major platform for communication.
Thanks for reading, even as you consider my candid and sincere contribution.
I remain my humble self @desmoniac
Searching to know the limits in everything
RESTEEMED
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Not just the mods and sups, there is a particular overseer (not @elear) that's responsible for all these anomalies. He carries himself about as though he own utopian-io. He is the person responsible for all the unjust manipulations. I am waiting to him to speak and I know he will not speak because people will tackle him. Let's call a spade a spade!
@eurogee
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
@eurogee thanks for this great write up , first we have to credit @ned and other founder of this steem blockchain which most people have earn in 1 or 2 ways from this . I believe utopian is obviously meant for good contributors and they get reward for it and also it was tagged community driven , but it is sad when mods call contributors different names like they are only contributing because of reward , use words like 'nonsense' and other words to tag contributors post. This is disrespectful to we the contributors , remember without the contributors , utopian is nothing .And again as much as the rules is concerned , i guess utopian needs to put in mind consideration for contributors as well as for utopian too , the rule needs to be fair and not just thinking all contributors are doing this for the reward , we put in out time , money , brain , and such .@elaar you need to consider all this and not those mods that tag our contributions rubbish , nonsense , not making sense and such ,
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
This is very unfortunate. And the worst of it all is they happen before the eyes of @elear and he will come here to speak on their defense. Blame @elear if utopian-io experiment fails because all should start and end at his table.
He's suppose to sit up like a man and address injustices being perpetrated by the so called mods whom I bet would have long left this place without utopian-io.
Dammit. Damn all the supporters of unjust maltreatment of fellow humans. Damn all those who are quick to forget when they were earning less than $1 per post, damn them that are ready to inflict pains unjustly to their fellow humans
I am pained! Why would rules be made unfavorable to visibility category that's the pillar of steem ecosystem.? Do this people think at all?
I have concrete evidence, provable one to challenge them before anyone!
This place is stinking!
@eurogee
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I was trying learn and start this utopia.io stuff, seeing this post is disheartening...
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Very very
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Well said boss.
Hopefully they make amendments soonest.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Will they? A people beclouded by unreasonable ambition to the detriment of the majority and even the platform they are working for! Soon, utopian-io will become a scheme explicitly made to enrich her programmers. Rubbish!
@eurogee
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I don't know what more to contribute to this but I've resteemed. Hopefully one of my friends will have something to contribute.
I must commend your boldness to stand up for the truth boss. You are respected for that.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
One thing that even baffles me most time is that, when a post is rejected the moderator asks you contact him on Discord, you will contact him and he won't reply.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
That's why I brought this whole thing here
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I have known your passion and effort on steemit from way too long. Everyone can easily ascribe Euronation to you. I dont know why the utopian rules changed so drastically especially based on the fact that those social medias are the commonest means of messaging. I hope this is well addressed.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I hope they see reasons to address it
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
To be honest, since I joined steemit I've not seen the impact people always told me about in terms of upvotes as compared to the pay-less likes I get on facebook with great comments to urge me on. It's been frustrating; I've made so many poems (with and without images) and even stories but the highest I've gotten from a post has been $0.07 and that was even my introduceyourself post.
We need more people like you to join this course. We need your voice to also make it here on steemit. It's very discouraging!
As for the whatsapp link, I can't join please try and rectify it. Thanks!
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Join telegram and mention @smyle, i will add you to whatsapp. Thanks
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Not on telegram either. You can add me up on whatsapp with +2347061814294. Thanks
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Keep pushing. There is light at the end if the tunnel
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Yeah, I will. Thanks a lot
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
@eurogee this is very thoughtful of you to air the mind of the majority. Kudos.
For me, I saw "open source " contributions on Steemit as a welcomed idea, @utopian.io was my eye opener, to that effect, I went back to do my homework on how I could be useful to the community, visibility was the only way I could contribute.
Each time I made efforts to make a contribution, I discovered that the Bar was raised, from 5k,to 10k...so I gave up.
I wonder how many minnows like me have also given up.
The main aim of visibility is to reach a targeted audience, but what after the #reach-out nobody shows further interest? It's a fruitless effort!
I also think the standards set are too high for a common minnow! Majority of them are not geeks to make contributions into bug hunting, translations etc. So why make things difficult for them?
If the trend continues,people would have apathy for @utopia.io ,and utopia would loose it's essence as a community driven project.
For me, I don't think I would ever make a contribution there because I don't have what it takes and I am not a machine to reach out to over 10k audience. It's penny wise pound foolish to invest your resources to make a visibility post to a targeted audience when the post would eventually get rejected and become invisible to @utopia
Time is precious and should be channelled into more rewarding ventures.
@eurogee you just got a resteem from me.
@antigenx
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
This is what they don't know! Or they know but are being jealous for people's hard work. I will never keep quiet until this issue is addressed.
@eurogee
Thanks for the head up
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Baba you got the backing of almost all the communities reading this..
We just needed a voice all these while.
Thanks for being the voice.
Whatever it takes baba.
If dem like to flag, we go carry awa kaya port go another place
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Damn flags. Do you whip a child and expect him not to cry. Atrocities are becoming the order of the day at utopian-io. It's better my account is flagged into obscurity than being here and watch shit unfold before my eyes...
Unless they make changes with humane touch, I can never keep quiet!
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit