Even A Clanger Is An Offer

in art •  6 years ago 

Tuttle2Texas photos at C4CC

I chatted with my friend Al yesterday about y'know "what does it all mean?" And by that, I mean my work and the projects I've done. It's a recurring worry for me that I might not be able to define or represent what some things really meant, why they were done, what good came of them.

Al told me this story, which Herbie Hancock opens his autobiography with:

Screen Shot 2018-06-21 at 17.38.51.png

Herbie goes on to explain that what happened was that as he played the "bad" chord, he judged it, he decided it was awful, but Miles didn't judge it, he just took it and ran with it. In theatre improvisation people say "everything is an offer" meaning don't throw back stuff that you don't immediately get - Miles took the bad chord as an offer and built on it. And Herbie learned a valuable lesson.

OK.

But when it's my work, my stuff that goes out there and feels like a weighty clanger collection of bum notes, it's not so easy to remember that it only has meaning in connection with other people and through them taking the offer and running with it themselves in ways that I possibly will never see myself, or which might take a very very long time to come back. My job isn't to track (and judge) what happens to it, my job is to keep making offers.

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

When I'm in my flowing space @lloyddavis I see all of life as one big invitation, whether it's coming from me or someone else or life itself. 😍

:) no distinction between "me", "someone else" and "life itself" heh!

  ·  6 years ago (edited)

That's the sign of an amazing musician. I'm sure actors do similar things when dealing with mishaps and hecklers. You can make it into something interesting and new.

yes, good old Miles! It's all too rare though, more often "mistakes" are something to cover up, forget about and hope nobody noticed.

This is how I feel about Art exactly. One makes the offer, makes what you feel, desire, like, hate whatever, you create it and the viewer, listener, reader, what have you, puts Their story in it. This is also why I love art with 'story' but even an abstraction or a random noise poem can have story, it's really up to us as the receiver of the thing.

Keep making offers, even if there are no takers, you can know you made it, none the less :)