The right one is definitely great- the boldness and simplicity of it lend to it ability to convey the story, plus it's all self contained by the border kind of like a comic box, so it's good to stand alone or with others. But I prefer the one on the left, pretty much just because I like surreal art. Because of the confusion of it, it makes the eye linger a bit longer in order to take everything in. Something like that would be really cool in paint. Do you paint?