The total value of the hundreds of tracked cryptocurrencies has fallen by more than 18% since last week’s high of $177bn.
The total value of the hundreds of tracked cryptocurrencies has fallen by more than 18% since last week’s high of $177bn. Photograph: Thomas White/Reuters
View more sharing options
Shares
62
Alex Hern
@alexhern
Tuesday 5 September 2017 12.21 BST Last modified on Wednesday 13 September 2017 07.47 BST
The latest cryptocurrency boom is beginning to stall as regulators worldwide turn their attention to the “initial coin offerings”, which have driven a precipitous rise in the sector’s market value reaching a high of $177bn (£136bn).
The total value of the hundreds of tracked cryptocurrencies has fallen by more than 18% to $145bn since Friday’s high, according to analytics site CoinMarketCap. The collapse seems to have been triggered by a ruling from the Chinese central bank that declared it illegal to raise money through launching new cryptocurrencies.
An initial coin offering (ICO) is a relatively recent innovation for cryptocurrency developers, and involves selling a number of cryptographic tokens to investors at the launch of the project. These tokens can represent almost anything, from another attempt to make a Bitcoin analogue to exclusive access to an app or service. They have been responsible for some big funding rounds: adblocking browser Braveraised $35m for its ICO, while an ICO for service designed to help ICOs raised more than $150m.
ICOs have even become popular enough for celebrities including Floyd Mayweather and Paris Hilton to jump on board. The hotel heiress has actually been involved in the area for more than a year, having met with the COO of prominent blockchain firm Ethereum in 2016.
Paris Hilton
(@ParisHilton)
Looking forward to participating in the new @LydianCoinLtd Token! #ThisIsNotAnAd #CryptoCurrency #BitCoin #ETH #BlockChain pic.twitter.com/a8kT9eHEko
September 3, 2017
Since the concept was first mooted, however, there have been concerns over its legality, with experts warning that selling a cryptographic token which entitles the holder to a share of profits in a business could be a violation of financial regulations.
Advertisement
Now, the People’s Bank of China has confirmed just that. Individuals and organisations that have completed ICO fund raising should make arrangements to return funds, according to a joint statement from the bank, China’s securities and banking regulators, and several other government departments.
Some experts still think the sector has hope. Zennon Kapron, director of the Shanghai-based financial technology consultancy Kapronasia, said he suspected regulators were putting the brakes on ICOs in order to better understand the phenomenon, but could ease off in the future.
“Regulators globally are struggling to understand what ICOs are, what the risks are, and how to ring-fence and regulate them,” he said. “China, in many ways, is no different than the US or Singapore in saying: ‘OK, we need to push back on these for now until we figure out how to deal with them’. I think it will be slightly a temporary measure.”
The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) issued its own ruling in July. While not as wide-ranging as the Chinese statement, it leaned in the same direction. The agency said: “Depending on the facts and circumstances, the offering may involve the offer and sale of securities.
“If that is the case, the offer and sale of virtual coins or tokens must itself be registered with the SEC, or be performed pursuant to an exemption from registration.
The SEC’s statement was prompted by the conclusion of its investigation into the biggest ICO failure to date, a 2016 experiment called the DAO which ended up losing millions of dollars worth of cryptocurrencies due to a bug in its software.
The SEC’s stance has also had a chilling effect on the creation of new ICOs in the US. At least two planned offerings have been put on hold as a result of the document. One, Harbour, said it was a pre-emptive action based on the project’s conclusion “that there is just too much uncertainty within our current model to forge ahead without some careful assessment and perhaps revision”. Another, Protostarr, was cancelled after its chief executive was investigated by the SEC.
Those in the cryptocurrency sector believe a short period of overregulation will eventually be reversed as the merits of the technology become clear.
“The initial coin offering is a new business model leveraging blockchain technology and it will remain,said Oliver Bussman, of the Switzerland-based Crypto Valley Association.This is not the end of the ICO – absolutely not.”
While some ICOs are unambiguously analogous to stocks and shares, many, such as those which offer resellable access to an application to the holders, are more novel, and may survive regulation unscathed.
Initial coin offerings: cryptocurrency’s next high-risk big money maker
Since you’re here …
… we have a small favour to ask. More people are reading the Guardian than ever but advertising revenues across the media are falling fast. And unlike many news organisations, we haven’t put up a paywall – we want to keep our journalism as open as we can. So you can see why we need to ask for your help. The Guardian’s independent, investigative journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce. But we do it because we believe our perspective matters – because it might well be your perspective, too.
I appreciate there not being a paywall: it is more democratic for the media to be available for all and not a commodity to be purchased by a few. I’m happy to make a contribution so others with less means still have access to information.
Thomasine F-R.
If everyone who reads our reporting, who likes it, helps to support it, our future would be much more secure.
Become a supporter
Make a contribution
Topics
E-commerce
Internet
China
Asia Pacific
Securities and Exchange Commission
Regulators
news
Share on LinkedIn Share on Pinterest Share on Google+
Reuse this content
Advertisement
Most popular
Deloitte hit by cyber-attack revealing clients’ secret emails
North Korea's foreign minister: Trump has declared war on our country
Chelsea Manning says she has been barred from entering Canada
Republican plan to defeat Obamacare looks doomed as Susan Collins says no to bill
Alexandre Lacazette double earns Arsenal nervy win against West Bromwich Albion
more on this story
Bitcoin is a fraud that will blow up, says JP Morgan boss
13 Sep 2017 712Bitcoin is a fraud that will blow up, says JP Morgan boss
From Silk Road to ATMs: the history of bitcoin
13 Sep 2017From Silk Road to ATMs: the history of bitcoin
Bitcoin investors could lose all their money, FCA warns
12 Sep 2017 107Bitcoin investors could lose all their moneyFCA warns
Why bitcoin and its digital cousins are under increasing scrutiny
31 Jul 2017 141Why bitcoin and its digital cousins are under increasing scrutiny
Initial coin offerings: cryptocurrency's next high-risk big money maker
Alex Hern
9 Jul 2017Initial coin offerings: cryptocurrency's next high-risk big money maker
Are cryptocurrencies about to go mainstream?
1 Jul 2017 223Are cryptocurrencies about to go mainstream?
London developer to allow rental tenants to pay deposits in bitcoin
4 Sep 2017 169London developer to allow rental tenants to pay deposits in bitcoin
Value of bitcoins in circulation hits record high of $14bn
22 Dec 2016 70Value of bitcoins in circulation hits record high of $14bn
promoted links
from around the web
Recommended by Outbrain
About this Content
Triplets Take D.N.A Test But Drs Reveal Surprising News [Gallery]
Triplets Take D.N.A Test But Drs Reveal Surprising News [Gallery]
OMG!
6 Pet Medication Storage Tips to Avoid Danger
6 Pet Medication Storage Tips to Avoid Danger
PET MD
Two Adjacent Apartments at 995 Fifth Ave. Available for a Combined $29.75M
Two Adjacent Apartments at 995 Fifth Ave. Available for a Combined $29.75M
MANSION GLOBAL
Hotel Prices You're Not Allowed to See!
Hotel Prices You're Not Allowed to See!
TRIPSINSIDER
5 Common Behaviors That Prove Your Dog Is Still Wild at Heart
PET MD
After 34 Years Together Goldie Hawn & Kurt Russell Make An Announcement [Gallery]
OMG!
The Reading Habits Of Highly Successful People
BLINKIST MAGAZINE
Can Your Dog Actually Understand Time?
PET MD
most viewed
1
iPhone 8: glass back 'very difficult' to repair and costs more than screen to replace
2
Uber faces serious charges – why is Khan offering an olive branch?
3
What makes a gamer? Sally McManus, Jordan Raskopoulos and more on why they play
4
iPhone 8: muted reaction and small queues lead to questions over demand
5
Tech's push to teach coding isn't about kids' success – it's about cutting wages
6
Marvel vs Capcom Infinite review: too much power, no responsibility
7
Mark Zuckerberg loves cheesesteak and he really wants you to know it
8
Flying to US to get an iPhone X is cheaper than buying in Europe. It's also illegal
9
Uber stripped of London licence due to lack of corporate responsibility
10
Uber is not as popular as you might think
Advertisement
Homes Sales in Canada Plunge, With Greater Toronto Seeing Steep Drops
But prices seem to be increasing across the country
BY V.L. HENDRICKSON