I don't understand why there is so much negativity about pump and dumps. It's a game. Like on market someone need to loose that other would win. As i said it is a game and your success depends of how/if you follow the rules of the player, or you break the rules and try to use the opportunity. Obviously only players have guaranteed income from the game, but using specific tools you can be a shadow player not a pumper. I am using pump bot which brought me lots of profit. As i'm saying as long as you don't let the player force rules on you, there are really good money waiting.