To an extent, it's understandable why people try to justify fighting brown shirts with brown shirt tactics. This isn't a partisan thing. I've had this argument with people on the right and the left. There is some validity to the argument that fascists use dirty tactics and we need to fight them by using dirty tactics.
The key that people are missing is that a large part of fascism are the tactics. Fascism is a minor annoyance and a small group of assholes without the tactics. If you embrace the fascist tactics of silencing the opposition through violence and intimidation and evoking mob violence against people with unpopular views, what are you? Maybe you're an anti-fascist who looks like a fascist who doesn't hate Jews? Only, that's probably too generous because most woke people do hate Jews.
No, you have to oppose the ideology and the tactics if you're gonna be serious about this.