Testing AI detection tools, which one is the most accurate?

Source

Hello Steemit friends, on this occasion let's try some of the capabilities of AI detection tools, which one is the most accurate?

Generally, a number of moderators in the community often use these three tools to verify a post, including, ZeroGPT, GPT Zero, Smallseotools.

I tested to see the extent of the ability of these tools to detect AI content, in this case I used ChatGPT and wrote three commands using English text, I also copied the resulting text created by ChatGPT and directly pasted it into the three AI detection tools I mentioned above, let's see which one is the most accurate?

Please note that I wrote three commands on ChatGPT using English, this is so that the AI detection engine can capture more accurate results, because it is known that AI detection tools are not yet fully capable of reading other language texts.

💁‍♂️ I wrote the first command to write a story, with the following command "Write a story about an orphan who survives by begging on the streets, make it a sad story."

first command

Smallseotools shows that 1.01% text is detected as AI.
ZeroGPT shows that 61.14% text is detected as AI.
GPT Zero shows that 100% text is detected as AI.

Analyzed results: From the first AI content detection results, it can be concluded that GPT Zero shows better results than the other tools, while the Zero GPT tool is only able to detect part of the AI content. In contrast, Smallseotools has not been able to detect AI content properly.

💁‍♂️ The second command asks you to summarize the story, with the following command text "summarize it into a few simple paragraphs."

Second commandment

Smallseotools shows that 0.02% text is detected as AI.
ZeroGPT shows that 0% text is detected as AI.
GPT Zero shows that 100% text is detected as AI.

Analyzed results: The second trial of AI-generated text is less than the first trial, from the results of this second AI content detection it can be concluded that GPT Zero still shows better results compared to other tools, while the ZeroGPT and Smallseotools tools cannot recognize that this is AI-generated content.

💁‍♂️ The third command I write the following command language, "explain some life values that can be taken away."

Third commandment

Smallseotools shows that 78% text is detected as AI.
ZeroGPT shows that 96.1% text is detected as AI.
GPT Zero shows that 100% text is detected as AI.

Analyzed results: The third experiment resulted in several passages of bullet points generated from AI content, from this experiment all three tools were able to detect it well, but only the GPT Zero tool believed that this text was fully AI-generated content.

Conclusion

• GPT Zero shows more accurate results than other tools in detecting AI content.

20% of prizes are distributed to support charity programs @wox-helpfund
cc. @sultan-aceh