Fighting Abuse on Steem: Mass Art Fraud: @ellla. The role of country curators to prevent it.

in hive-185836 •  3 years ago 

Unbenannt-1.jpg

 

*

 

Hello my dear Steemians and Art Fans,

 

After relatively long period of quite time there is again the case of Deception that we have noticed as user herself posted in „World of Xpilar“ community.

It is a routine for us to verify the users who posting Visual Art posts, because we would like to reward creativity and originality and as we all know Art was always a field that people try to duplicate and sell as “original” because original was valued.

This time we start with this user @ellla, she is Nigerian

 


@ellla


 

image.png

here is the Introduction post

 

Unbenannt-1.jpg

 

Sounds really good and seems like the user knows that it is important to respect the intellectual property of others and also not to lie. Also notice that she says that she got know Steemit via her brother @alandchi, later on we will return to that user too.

 

Now look at the blog

 

Trenner groß.png

 

Deception case 1: @ellla

 

This is the first post that I have seen yesterday, what made me suspicious this is typical

 

image.png

 

After a short search we have found an original source that is the web site tutorial:

 

image.png

 


Deception case2: @ellla


 

image.png

 

The original found in many sources including

 

image.png

 


Deception case 3: @ellla


 

image.png

 

That is Original Drawing and there is the same signature but then of author:

 

image.png

 


Deception case 4: @ellla


 

image.png

 

Here is the original source from CanStock Photo:

 

image.png

 


Deception case 5: @ellla


 

Unbenannt-1.jpg

 

Here is the original source:

 

image.png

 


Deception case 6: @ellla


 

This time the user even put her name on the Original work that was stolen from other author

 

image.png

 

Here is the original work of Emil Gilfanow, that even was cropped a bit too:

 

image.png

 


Deception case 7: @ellla


 

Unbenannt-1.jpg

 

It is pure lie and the original drawing is easy to find, the user even did not bother to delete the name of original user

 

image.png

 

Trenner groß.png

 

 


Attention to Community Curators and Newcommer Community


 

Here I would like to ask @steemcurator01 the opinion. We all know about Steemcurator accounts such as @steemcurator03 till @steemcurator08 they are under the control of Community curators belonging to different countries and also Greeters, Newcomer communities and Steem POD.

 

image.png

She has been verified by @ngoenyi, has been welcomed by @ghostfacer99, @arrowgate and

 

Unbenannt-1.jpg

 


Role of Country Curators behind @steemcurators03 to 08


 

But this is what we have observed in this particular case:

The user posting Mass Art Fraud since beginning of the account September 2021, received twice upvote from Community curator and SC03.

  • The user posted 4 times the same Introductory posts: first at very beginning and
  • Other 3 posts with the same content word in word 17 and 18 days ago those two received support from Community Leader and SC03.

@steemcurator01 is it allowed to curate recycled posts with the same value of @steemcurator03 in my opinion that is misusing the intention of Country Curator accounts.

The accounts SC03 to 06 have been given to countries and communities but meanwhile maybe it is a time to circulate them too to avoid such situation and give the opportunity other communities to reward their users.

It would be good to hear the opinion of other users, please feel free and we can open the discussion

 


 

If you like what we do, please support our Initiative, it takes a lot of time and research to collect the evidence and we are working hard on keeping Steem blockchain free of Plagiarism and Abuse.

 

*


 

As always, faithfully yours we are Guardians of steem,

@stef1 and @myskye

 

*

 


@stef1 Power Up snapshot


 

2021-10-17_114819.jpg

 

Trenner groß.png

 

*


CURATION TRAIL @worldofxpilar


 

YaFx5Xh8dcRE2tjviA.jpg

 

Trenner groß.png

 

XTest-1ab.jpg

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

Thank you for finding this one @stef1.

Interesting to look at the posts of this connected person as well - @alandchi


@ngoenyi @cryptokannon - can you look to improve your plagiarism checking in Newcomers Community.


#club5050 😀

Yes, there is similarity and I was going to look closer at the behavior of that user too.
Thank you for sharing our opinion, the community leaders should be more cautious about their members especially if they invited the people.

  ·  3 years ago (edited)

Noted sir, thank you for alerting me to this.

It is quiet unfortunate that I was the one that verified the said @ellla.

I have taken note of that and I will be more careful. More and more impostors are creeping in.

I verified because she needed to be verified and I didn't know she is an imposter.

I do check for plagiarism before verification. But all the same, I will be more careful.

Thank you so much dear boss @steemcurator01 for the mention.

Loading...

Moreover you can check my account posts I am working as a private investigator I have highlighted many times to my seniors that about plagiarism every thing is getting down I have also emailed in September 21 at jovel2000 you here I am giving the screenshot.
Screenshot_2021-10-17-16-29-27-279_com.google.android.gm.jpg
I do believe that if this section isn't improved it will affect this whole system as now many users are practicing plagiarism as well as account/vote forming by creating multiple IDs.
And from the day Endingplagiarism stepped down there is no one else who may listen our reports on Plagiarism and scam cases !
It's pretty nice that today you mentioned me here and I got opportunity to tell you all these matter.
I am hopeful that you will make some good steps.
Yes I want to work for the betterment I know how much it hurts when original content creator get nothing but others with copy paste gets support !
I am waiting for your kind words if i spoken something wrong I am sorry for that !
Thanks for reading out my opinion :)
Respected @stef1 !

Hi @arrowgate, you are a member of Steem POD and Mosquito Squishers communities therefore, I think it is better if you discuss with the members of those teams. I have never come across yourself, only during this case.

I belong to World of Xpilar community and we are checking those users who do fraud and appear in our community. As you might know we have more than 14 thousand members and also more than 600 active users. Therefore, there is no time for me to check other cases throughout Steemit platform only if they revealed themselves publishing in our Community.

I do not think I am a person you should write if you found a plagiarism. I am sorry for that. The email is a filter that let through emails that is of the interests set up there.

Firstly thank you wholeheartedly that you have listened, yes I know and also in world of xpilar I have also caught many Plagiarism cases and I have reported in mosquito squshiers but as I earlier mentioned that now no one checks my reports and my only purpose was to highlight again this matter.
Yes I know the workload you are facing and doing great job but as i didn't got replied in those communities where i highlighted all these matters and therefore i also mentioned @steemcurator01 in this regard two times but didn't got any kind of response.
Anyways thanks again for your kind words.

Thank you @stef1 for finding things that are not fair to do in steemit, I feel more plagiarism is found in steemit and then more original content that is not appreciated is seen. there are some plagiarism that get very high votes and hopefully things like this should be tightened to eradicate plagiarism.

Hopefully the steemit team will further tighten the bad habits of people who abuse the steemit platform.

There will be always people who will try to go the easy way and present the stuff of others as their own. But we, ordinary users need to be more cautious about that and if any suspicion then avoid supporting such users.

Yes, this will be very good for steemit and for steemit users who always work hard to publish their original content. I hope this will be a lesson.

Thank you for taking time to fish all these out. It must have taken you a great deal.

I will try and fish the said person out since she is residing in my city of residence

Thank you @ngoenyi for taking action.

Nice articles keep it up

Thank you.

This really helps, thank you @stef1 because it is unfair for the writers who do efforts , thank for giving value to original works ,

It is nice to see you around and I am glad that you are supporting our way of thinking, we all need to strive to be honest and to make sure that there is no deception tolerated.

Yes sir it is not just a rule, but a good discipline and it protects each one of us. Thank you
again ,😊🙏

Admirable, la habilidad para la búsqueda de plagio, muy buen trabajo. Dios permita a ustedes la sabiduría de seguir encontrando personas que abusan tomando lo ajeno y haciendolo pasar por suyo, obteniendo recompensas que no deben tener. 👍Sigan adelante que se que van a mejorar

Thank you for supporting our work:)

hello dear friend @ stef1 good afternoon
It's a shame that this continues to happen; Luckily there are people like you who do not allow it; You're doing a great job. Congratulations
I take this opportunity to wish you a happy start to the week

Thank you @jlufer it is like never ending story, but we are happy to be able to catch those users :)

really support the originality and originality of every post

Thank you for your supportive words :)

I am a village boy who is far from the city, and still unfamiliar with the world, virtual and digital technology, as well as a beginner in steemit, really looking forward to direction, guidance, and support, from people who have been successful, in steemit, like you, thank you many.

Thank you for pointing it out but let me tell you that as a Greeter helper I have been asked by @cryptokannon to only verify achivement task from 2 to 6 ,and on Achievement 1 task I have to welcome that user and have to give him some rules and regulations about Steemit and guidelines about plagiarism.. !

I believe every of us if we have such tasks to verify anyone we need to look through blog and make sure that the users deserved verification otherwise that mislead other people, as we tend to trust such communities as Steem POD and Newcomer communities.

This is disappointing that someone would lie with her full chest. Thank you for alerting us to this user and thank you for emphasising the need to be original.

Thank you @unyimeetuk for reading this post and I was glad to hear your opinion :)

again great job @stef1 but I am sure you still have to go a long way.

If I can help you in any way then please let me know.
@crafter

Thank you @crafter for such supportive words :)

@stef1 she thought steemit was like other platform not knowing we can get the source of the images she posted through Google lens. Please forgive her because as human being we are bound to go astray and do wrong things, so please I beg you to give her a last warning, if she's caught next time then you can ban her or whatsoever. Thanks for reading ♥️

It is not that I need to forgive someone and it is not you who should apologize. The user should apologize for the whole multiple deception posts when she presented property of others as her own. Just imagine that it is your work and your property and someone is taking it and telling that it is hers. What will be your reaction. I believe you did not come across such situation but it was couple of time when my Artworks were copied and presented by another user and that made me very angry because of Internet we can't fight those cases except openly show the rest of community and downvote those people.

Peace my dear steem friends.
It is very disheartening to see this kind of misconduct.
I felt sorry seeing she was a Nigerian.
I fear the bad name and ordeal it poses on other users from my country.
I encourage the country curators to work more carefully to fish out those involved in plagiarism.
We can only move steemit forward together
Thank you @stef1 for this well articulated discovery.
I must say you are a man of high intellectual faculty.
We love the good work you are doing sir
More grace and peace to you I pray.

Wisdom

Thank you @chibuzorwisdom for reading and for your feedback. I absolutely agree with you such users just spoil the reputation of their landsmen, they just do not think about that.

I hope that country curators will ready work hard before rewarding new users,as they need verification and probably some guidance too.

You are welcome sir
I am hopeful that our country curators will modify their verification strategy following your discovery sir

Thanks for writing this post and bringing this plagiarism to our attention. I will resteem it. 👍

Thank you Dave for sharing our point of view and appreciate for resteem so that more people can read it :)

Thank you @stef1 for taking your time to go through so many things that have been happening here which many is very bad and many who writes lacks votes while others go ahead with plagiarism you really need to look into it

Thank you for reading and glad that you are supporting our point of view, we need to fight any abuse on Steemit, it is bad for the reputation of the whole blockchain.

🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

Wow 🥺😳 what a legendary work sir you have done :) I hope you impartially done your stupendous work to trace plagiarism done in steemit new cmmers

Thanksgiving for your good work.
@stef1
With best wishes
By @layersinn

Thank you :)

Well done @stef1! This one is actually so blatant it's almost disgusting... there seems to be almost no ends to how far people will go to try to cheat the system.

Actually it was a nice break of such posts in our Community I was glad to see that but as it is always happen those people come back and try to pretend to be an original authors. In our community it is a good group of people who checking for plagiarism and we try to reveal such cases on early stage. Glad to have you here and thank you for your feedback :)

Excelente trabajo y arduo trabajo de investigación para el aporte en la intención de evitar el plagio de nuestra comunidad.

Thank you for your supportive words :)

Gracias a ti por tan arduo labor cumplida

inspiratonal..

Thank you :)