Kenneth Branagh's film “Murder on the Orient Express” is the film version of the Agatha Christie novel of the same name, in which the director himself played the role of the great detective Hercule Poirot. In addition to Branagh, a dozen more actors of the first magnitude played in the film - Michelle Pfeiffer, Penélope Cruz, Johnny Depp, Judi Dench and others. In my opinion, “Murder on the Orient Express” is a large-scale fairy tale that is undoubtedly worth watching.
The main problem of any critic is over-sophistication. What we stigmatize as banal can be a revelation for an ordinary viewer, and he will immediately call the position of the critic in this situation arrogant. However, how fortunate it is to be on the other side of the barricades and feel like ordinary Homo sapiens, who bought a ticket for a film about which you do not know anything. Alternatively, at least, you do not know the most important.
Extensive entry - an attempt to justify. I am the rare person who did not read Agatha Christie's “Murder on the Orient Express” and did not see any of his screen versions. Of course, it would not be worth anything to prepare and fill the gap (everyone has them, isn't it) before being acquainted with the new film. However, how to miss a rare chance to see a detective, frozen with impatience and waiting for a denouement? Therefore, now, when colleagues contemptuously - and, for sure, legally - to compare the new picture with the old ones and compare them with the original source, I will ingenuously and honestly write: the film Kenneth Branagh is a great entertainment, a great example of a smart genre film.
It is clear that for Christie, the genius of plot constructions, the train stuck in a snowfall, is not so much a metaphor as a convenient enclosed space - necessary to ask the Hercule Poirot (and the reader / viewer) another puzzle and elegantly solve it. However, Kenneth Branagh is still a cinematographer, and for him “Orient Express” is one of the full participants in the action, its main characters. The movie once began with the Lumières "The Arrival of the Mail Train". Since then, the locomotive has become a symbol of new art and progress as such. Here, this train instead of rushing forward at full speed, scaring and admiring the public, stops at full speed. Stop, progress, welcome to the cozy British tradition, in a kind of Narnia, where time flows differently. When it is snowing outside the window, everyone will want to get comfortable in the dining car and listen to the old-old story. Even if you know it by heart.
How can you resent the theatrical exaggeration of the behavior of the masked characters played by folk artists? Each of them is just a gift, and some are especially valuable. For the first time after the endless Captain Jack Sparrow, Johnny Depp (the demonic businessman of Ratchett), who was desperately grimacing and very funny Willem Dafoe (Gerhard Hardman), who caught Michelle Pfeiffer's second wind (Mrs Hubbard), played such a juicy role. Thinning and vampire charming Sergei Polunin as the Hungarian Count Andrenyi and Grand Dame Judi Dench, who did not refuse the pleasure to play in the English film adaptation of the English book Princess Dragomiroff. In addition, Penélope Cruz, Josh Gad, Daisy Ridley, Derek Jacobi. Well, Kenneth Branagh's mustache, of course, is not by chance so huge and comical. Here everything is grotesque, as it should be in a fictional story; all the more, stories where everything is constantly invented (to put it more simply, they lie). The style of the painting is demonstratively far from the psychological realism that most interpreters for some reason consider mandatory for a detective genre. That is why “Murder on the Orient Express” is a luxurious movie, a joy for the eyes and ears. In essence, a large-scale tale.
The locomotive sniffing the snow reminds of the Christmas “The Polar Express” by Robert Zemeckis, and even more about the “Hogwarts Express” from the Joanne Rowling novel series (the second most famous English writer after Agatha Christie) and their screen versions. It is not without reason that many of the actors, starting with Branagh himself, took part in films about the Harry Potter universe, and one of the heroines of the novel is also called Hermione. In other words, “Orient Express” is not just a means of transportation, but also a magical transport, transporting characters and spectators from the ordinary world to the magic, conditional. Only in it such scenes are possible (in the hope of the same ignorant, we will not elaborate on the details of intrigue) - not about crime and punishment, as in most detectives, but about reward and mercy.
From the detective you expect increased attention to trifles, but Branagh's “Murder on the Orient Express”, on the contrary, turned out to be sweeping. In the film, a huge number of common plans, the director himself admires his picturesque even more than the viewer does. The plans from above are repeated more often than others - as if the sight of an all-seeing God, with whom Poirot is closer to the final, compares himself directly. By the way, Branagh’s Belgian detective is not a small, pot-bellied and ridiculous outsider, as in many film adaptations, but a real Hero with a capital letter, not in the mockery called Heracles. His Olympic calmness contrasts spectacularly with the eccentric behavior of the rest of the train’s passengers, each of whom has reason to be nervous. It is hard not to appreciate the beauty of the colorful characters' seating in the climax scene - frontally, at a long table, just like in “Last Supper”, against the background of a bottomless black tunnel, they listen to the verdict of Poirot.
Of course, “Murder on the Orient Express” Branagh does not claim to be innovative and appeals to tradition and the canon no less than the recent “Cinderella” by the same author appeals. What from that? In both cases, a rich and inventive spectacle is no more than a way to tell again (and new listeners) one of the great stories, but no less.
Just like you, I haven't read the book and I haven't seen the original movie. In other words, the story was brand new to me as I watched it a month ago. I got to say that I enjoyed the movie, and I already look forward to the follow-up which should be released in 2019 if I remember correctly!
I believe it is harder for hard-core Poirot fans to like it as they do all sorts of comparisons with the book and earlier movies, but for those brand new to Hercule Poirot, this is great!
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I am also waiting for the continuation of the story, it is not in vain in the final Poirot goes to Nile, where there was some another murder. If Branagh is going to make a film adaptation of "Death on the Nile", then personally I wish him only good luck. Although I am more than confident that Kenneth Branagh will present us a beautiful and very elegant spectacle in the best traditions of Hercule Poirot style, making each character to see a possible killer and enjoy the long-awaited denouement.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I have to say I didn't like it very much. It didn't compare at all to the 1974 version by Sydney Lumet. Branagh isn't the Poirot of the books, and the plot was changed too much.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Comparisons with the 1974 Sidney Lumet film are inevitable and, of course, they will not be in favor of the new film adaptation, but this does not mean that the 21st century "Murder on the Orient Express" does not have its charms. Dipping into detectives Christie is like going into a cozy professorial study with a lamp under a green shade. This very comfort is successfully conveyed in the luxurious interiors of the train, in the very combination of confined space and immobility - it is clear that as soon as the paths are cleared and the express is ready for shipment, the secret of ticking nerves will be unraveled.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit