The Lying PresssteemCreated with Sketch.

in news •  6 years ago 

Just recently it was revealed that one of the highest decorated journalists at the Spiegel in Germany has been faking and even outright inventing stories for years. link

4000.jpg

In 2017, he became a staff journalist for Der Spiegel, which has published almost 60 articles by Relotius since 2011.[6][7] For his detailed reporting, Relotius received several awards, including the Deutscher Reporterpreis on four occasions and as recent as 2018.[8] Relotius' Reporterpreis 2018 award was for "Best Reportage", delivered in Berlin in early December,[9][10][11] for a story of "of unprecedented lightness, density and relevance, which never leaves open the sources on which it is based."[12] He was the CNN "Journalist of the Year" in 2014,[5] and won the European Press Prize in 2017.[13]

from wikipedia

Conspiracies

Earlier this year when I was very doubtful about honest reporting by the mainstream media people called me a conspiracy theorist. They were wrong twice! The told me there would be no big fakes, at best some small details. (And if there were fakes these would be in the dishonest web by right-wing nuts) Yet some of the highest decorated journalists write entire fake articles. Furthermore it does not need a conspiracy to make this happen.

There is no need for shady meetings, all that needs to be done is set the right (or wrong?) incentives and the system will equilibrate itself to delivering the fake news. We now know about the case of Relotius, and this will not just be an isolated case. The case shows a much deeper systematic failure of the news.

Yet people seems all to happy to dismiss real criticism of the press. They do not like what they see, they do not want to know. They defend themselves by labelling critics right-wing extremists. Many still believe everything the press writes. But when something is broken, only the truth can help and no matter if we like the outcome, we will have to face the consequences on one way or another.

The Faking of News

I am not a press insider. Therefore what I will construct here is just trying to make sense of the facts from the outside. It is one interpretation, the one I find most realistic. But there are others. One of those is that Relotius was just an isolated lunatic. Another is that there is a deep hidden conspiracy.

fake-1903774_1280 (2).png
source

Corruption is one of the strongest forces in our world. Power always gets corrupted. And the press still has a huge power to shape opinions. To think that private companies could remain entirely dedicated to the truth is almost naive. Game theoretically it is very hard to construct faithful oracles in much simpler scenarios. There are many interest groups that try to influence the press and certainly some of the people working in the agencies will be corrupted and trying to put their spin on the news into print.

But all of the new people that become journalists enter the system free from corruption and idealistic in spirit. They want to report the truth and bring light. From this setup the question is how to best deliver the corruption. They key strategies are:

Education
Journalists schools teach one particular view of the world. Reporters that are rooted in this set of beliefs and values will subconsciously interpret what they perceive in that light. Then their report will already be biased. Most schools of journalism receive money and support from special interest groups and have their agenda represented in the education.
Hiring
When hiring new personal, people are more likely to hire employees that have a similar world view. This creates bubbles where the entire team has a shared view, making it much easier to quench opposing voices by a culture of consent. Even though the population is usually about 50% left and 50% right, a clear majority of working journalists in mainstream media have a closed left wing world view.
Funding
Publishing houses do no longer make most of their money from selling their content to consumers. Instead adds and third party 'support' make up most of their income. This changes the game theory quite a bit. The people on the top have a much larger interest to print stories that these special interests like. Who wants to put adds in a magazine that trashes the product? This desire runs downwards to the writers who fell the pressure to satisfy their bosses and thus the special interests.
Easy job or working hard for a lot of trouble
Journalists understand which stories get published quickly and bring them a secure well paying job. On the other hand when they try to publish a more balanced story that does not follow the unofficial narrative, they will get much more resistance. Nobody will tell them that this is not allowed. Instead the story is more thoroughly vetted and in the end declined for lack of quality. No conspiracy needed. The people on top just know that they themselves may get trouble and try to find the smallest flaw to reject undesired content. We are all just humans and most will follow the path of least resistance while rationalising a lot. Especially when their job is in danger.
Journalism prices
Relotius won many of them. Prices are paid by external money. And they always serve a purpose. That is to please the people that fund them. Prices are a way to show others which stories are good and welcome stories. By chasing these prices journalists are encouraged to write fake news. In the case of Relotius, the anti-trump pro-immigrant narrative was a winning point and each journalist understands that imitating him at least a bit is a key to success.
Centralised networks
Media corporations are concentrated into few giant networks that are well connected to government and industry think tanks. Here general narratives are set and deals are made. This is the conspiracy part and these connection are well documented. But they only involve few people at the very top. The Relotius case happened on its own after these people have set the stage for it.

tournament-3529744_1280.jpeg
source

In summary, Relotius knew very well which kind of narrative brings promotions, recognition and fame. He then simply tried to deliver these stories. When reality was to boring, he added a few details. When there was nothing to find he invited the whole story. And he was good at it! But doing this on his own, covering his tracks, he was not just adding noise to the system, he was reporting as the people on the top wanted it. Without a direct exchange of plans. Just another greedy and corrupt pawn for the system.

Non-reporting

While this case of direct faking of news can be uncovered and is probably still a rarity, the real problem lies in the dark. Much less dangerous are the little changes. And to be honest, we should expect some overstatements in almost every article.

secret-2725302_1280.jpeg
source

And even worse is what is not being reported at all. Printing a lie is a risk. It may come to light one day. But not printing anything is very very safe. In todays world instead of lying there is a huge trend to only report fractions of the truth making it appear out of context, or simple not reporting facts at all if they do not fit the planned narrative.

And this will never create a public outcry as the Relotius case. But in fact it is much much worse and leads to the same propaganda machinery. Just try to find out about the chemical attacks in Syria. All of the news is filled with the alleged attack in Douma in April. While you certainly heard about those, you likely did not know there were more chemical attacks in Syria, one just recently link. These simply did not fit the narrative and were left out from the news. A chemical attack somehow is not equal to a chemical attack.

Or look at more distant events, the 1988 Halabdscha gas attack. The western news did strangely almost not report on it and only years later when Hussein was no longer a US ally these stories resurfaced. Nowadays we luckily know the details and can reconstruct how the news failed. Just since 1988 it has not gotten any better, rather much much worse. link

When it happens to the best ...

The case that came to light now, due to an honest reporter that suspected fake reporting and did not stop until he had proof is just the tip of the iceberg. It happened in one of the most prestigious journals of Germany. Each articles goes through layers of editing and checking before it is printed. Yet nobody found the blatant fakes for many years. Instead these stories won prices, again without checking sources or anything. If it can happen there it can happen anywhere.

Every article we read could be faked, but much more likely are small edits, fixed formulations and deliberate holes in the stories. Then finally there is a lot of news that is simply not reported at all. In the end what we consume is a very biased picture of reality, produced to manipulate us. Keep us stupid and misinformed so we keep voting and surrendering to our masters. And all of this without needing massive conspiracies, just some people with a lot of power creating a system with many little incentives to report as they want it.

If you still believe all of the news, please realise there are many fakes. Of course we cannot find them all ourselves, but the simplest fix is to consume the fakes from all sides. Consume news from different interest groups. See where they differ and then decide for yourself.

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

Very well put together article. I didn't know about this journalist, I will have to delve in it deeper to see how this all came to light and how it was played out. Because to be honest, if a journalist is ever 'outed' it is usually because he was picked to be the black sheep to cover up even more dishonesty. I don't see you as a conspiracy theorist or nutcase...Or I would be one too. I will even go as far as to say that hardly anything is 'real' news in the mainstream media. Maybe the odd cat rescue by the fire department, or a lotto win...
I say this, because first of all: I was once one of them. The mainstream media are either all bought or owned by people other than those who want to provide real news. Then, once you know this, everything starts to make sense, and you can 'see' what is fake and what isn't.

  ·  6 years ago (edited)

When they use prime air time for a kitty rescue story it makes you wonder what other story are they purposedly not reporting.

Exactly @hueso... What the media is doing at the moment ( have been for a while) is bomb us with useless information and A LOT of negative news... This is done on purpose. There is so much news that people can't keep up. It confuses and that way most people don't question it. Every now and then, they throw in something major that has people go: WTF? And then you never hear about it again... That confuses even more. I'll give you an example: A couple of years ago, one of the mainstream media channels in my country (Holland) reported of structures found on the bottom of the ocean just off the coast of Cuba. The structures were supposedly made with some kind of metal... I heard this clearly on the radio. When I told people and asked them if they heard it, no one had and some even thought I must have dreamed it. Until later, a friend told me he heard it too. Now, you'd say this is major news right? Wrong. I never heard about it again, and never even found anything about it online, on their site or elsewhere... They do these kinds of things to confuse people.
Then, when they throw in some 'terrorist attacks' (I could write a book about those) and people believe it because they're too confused to even question it or do their own research about it. I'm sure there are other reasons, but this is one of the main ones...

When they use prime air time for a kitty rescue story it makes you wonder what other story are they purposedly not reporting.

Posted using Partiko Android

Loading...

This post is promoted by @reversed-bidbot as an upvote lottery with a jackpot of 0.496 steem!

Sorry, all tickets have already been claimed.

Excluded from participation are: bidbots, autovoters.

The jackpot is paid in redfish_shares by @curatorbot, giving you lifetime upvotes while supporting the redfish community. Find more information here.

Follow me to also earn steem on my other promoted posts; or use @reversed-bidbot to hold your own raffles. For more details please visit my discord server or read my introduction post

Congratulations! This post has been upvoted from the communal account, @minnowsupport, by frdem3dot0 from the Minnow Support Project. It's a witness project run by aggroed, ausbitbank, teamsteem, someguy123, neoxian, followbtcnews, and netuoso. The goal is to help Steemit grow by supporting Minnows. Please find us at the Peace, Abundance, and Liberty Network (PALnet) Discord Channel. It's a completely public and open space to all members of the Steemit community who voluntarily choose to be there.

If you would like to delegate to the Minnow Support Project you can do so by clicking on the following links: 50SP, 100SP, 250SP, 500SP, 1000SP, 5000SP.
Be sure to leave at least 50SP undelegated on your account.

Hi @frdem3dot0!

Your post was upvoted by @steem-ua, new Steem dApp, using UserAuthority for algorithmic post curation!
Your UA account score is currently 3.487 which ranks you at #6509 across all Steem accounts.
Your rank has improved 107 places in the last three days (old rank 6616).

In our last Algorithmic Curation Round, consisting of 163 contributions, your post is ranked at #79.

Evaluation of your UA score:
  • You're on the right track, try to gather more followers.
  • The readers appreciate your great work!
  • You have already shown user engagement, try to improve it further.

Feel free to join our @steem-ua Discord server

Curated for #informationwar (by @openparadigm)

Ways you can help the @informationwar!

  • Upvote this comment or Delegate Steem Power. 25 SP 50 SP 100 SP or Join the curation trail here.
  • Tutorials on all ways to support us and useful resources here

FreezePeach

If you feel you've been wrongly flagged, check out @freezepeach, the flag abuse neutralizer. See the intro post for more details, or join the discord server.