Opposites Attract: A Romantic Reality or Just a Romantic Idea?

in psychology •  7 years ago  (edited)

The classic relationship belief that opposites attract is prevalent to this day. Even if relationship experts say it works, and most of us believe we want a complementary (opposite) partner not a similar one, is it true that opposite personalities are best suited for relationships? Do opposites really attract in the long term?



Source, Source

This saying that opposites attract in relationships, specifically romantic relationships, is due to an oversimplified blind analogy with how magnets function. Just because opposites strongly attract for magnets, the conclusion is that the ideal relationship is the one with the strongest attraction because it's based on two people being opposites.

Studies have previously been conducted to see what makes a better partner: similar (homogamy), different (heterogamy) or opposite (complementarity). A meta-analysis was done for the more than 240 studies in the past 60 years, which found that the winner is homogamy, which is when a relationship is founded on similarities. Being similar to someone and being interested in them go hand-in-hand, and this even found across cultures.

Similarity being associated with attraction makes homogamy the most successful. This is also found in assortative mating where people match up based on physical appearance, finance, and education levels. This doesn't mean that opposites don't attract.

People sometimes find partners who have traits that they lack, so they appear to complement one another. This can apply as the joining of: good girl vs. bad boy, ongoing vs. shy, funny vs. serious. Partners can view the other as an ideal where their weaknesses are counterbalanced by another's strengths. But there is no evidence in scientific studies about differences like religion, politics, education or personality leading to greater attraction or satisfaction.

Preferring an ideal partner has been studied, but this is about ideals that are similar and match an ideal version of ourselves that we are looking for. Similar personality traits are found to be more attractive, while opposite traits do not prove to have more attraction, as introverts are not more attracted to extroverts compared to others, for example.

The idea that finding opposite complementary partners more attractive might lead people to be together at first, but as contrasts stand out more and more, the small differences can become larger over time and cause arguments about the ways each partner is different from the other.

In general, despite partners being similar in many ways, they can shift into complementary roles as they recognize the differences in each other. Even if one person is only slightly more funny, outgoing or whatever other trait, they can take on the characterization as being the funny, outgoing, etc. one in the relationship while the other one becomes described as serious, shy, etc. even though they are only slightly less of that particular quality.

It seems opposites can attract because we want a complementary partner, but not because they form the strongest bonds. Over time issues can manifest that often create cracks in a relationship.


What do you think? Have your say.

  • Do you prefer a partner who is similar, opposite or different than you?
  • Have you found that opposites attract in relationships?
  • Have you found that opposite partners in relationships end up failing?

Thank you for your time and attention. Peace.


References:


If you appreciate and value the content, please consider: Upvoting, Sharing or Reblogging below.
Follow me for more content to come!


My goal is to share knowledge, truth and moral understanding in order to help change the world for the better. If you appreciate and value what I do, please consider supporting me as a Steem Witness by voting for me at the bottom of the Witness page; or just click on the upvote button if I am in the top 50.

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

well i think it is both ways...opposite attracts in some respect and homogamy also attracts as well.i will like to think that homogamy is the primary determinant of acceptance in any relationship. you have to be similar at first to a person before the idea of having a relationship pop up.such similarity may be in colour,religion,tribe, social class etc...the list may be endless. after this comes the secondary determinant which is the difference which will complement the couple...i think a balance between this 2 large force may be responsible for attraction

Yeah it works in many ways, complex :)

human beings right....we complex !

Perhaps it is a combination of factors. For example that opposite features may be attractive (genetic diversity) but if preferences are too far out of alignment it may cause problems.

It is certainly easier to have someone with similar interests and likes but at the same time there is also something to be said about the exploration of different introduced. As time goes on though, will the differences be a unifying factor or a separating? That would depend on other attributes again.

combination of factors..i totally agree. the dynamic equillibrium between whuch ultimately determines attraction. i have to be similar to u to a certain degree and also be different from you to a certain degree

As time goes on though, will the differences be a unifying factor or a separating?

Yeah, how to determine that ahead of time? Is there a special test to take? :P hehe

no test can determine that....human beings change with time due to complex interplay of interpersonal relationships and environmental factors...its just to trust on luck and trust

Self-awareness would help a great deal I think. Know who you are, better see other people.

yea that will help too....self awareness can help our relationship with others

I think the problem with opposites attract is activities. It's not often the other person wants to change their lifestyle for the other because of opposing interests.

So, while in some ways a relationship with your opposite is advantageous, it's only if you can make a lifestyle that shows you working as a team. That means either doing things together and using your opposite skills to succeed in the ventures, or setting aside plenty of alone time to do you own things, then coming together and finding common ground in the relationship.

Yup, pretty accurate. Gotta find time together and when not then keep doing things on your own since they aren't interested in everything you do ;)

I'd rather have some one to sit quietly with than some one who's talking while I'm trying to think. But if they are talking about what I'm thinking in more articulated manner then that's a great help too, thanks. Then they'd want me to listen what they have to say, which is cool but, not when I am thinking.

I think I will disagree with you a little. Most Ladies if not all love talking and having someone to listen to them. And it's their partners duty to listen to them at all times even if it's a distraction to them at that moment. A good listening ear is one great quality every woman demands from her partner. So if your partner is talking and you are thinking just simply nod and agree to whatever she says because every silence you give her produces more talk and questions. So the faster you attend to her, the faster you go back to your thinking. This is just my opinion anyway.

Disagree away. Conversation is very important element in any relationship. But have you talked to people recently? it's like a sitcom out there. Just because the room is quiet and and I am thinking doesn't mean it is a turn to talk or change conversation topic. It just means I am thinking. I am not bored in fact I am highly stimulated just stop the standup comedy please. right?

LOL, interesting way to go about it ;)

There is time for talking about things, and time for thinking;) No need to always be talking :)

I totally agree with you that partners can shift into complementary roles when they recognize the difference between each other no matter how small the difference may be. Awesome post @krnel

When it comes to relationships, I think the theory of unlike poles attracting does not hold. It is the only exception. In all scientific laws, we always have exceptions, remember?

The concept of twin souls is very crazy because to people acting the same way is boring.
There are no opposite personalities but complementary like a Sadic will always find a good Masoch to play with.:)
The kind of persona that is born between two people engaging results in a interexperience of each other, that's what matter in a relationship.

  ·  7 years ago (edited)

There are degrees of similarity and difference. No one is exactly the same ;) Having similar qualities is beneficial for bonding on the same page/level ;)

I prefer the big abyss of polarized differences because of the interrelation(the real only person of a relationship), can create more energy flows between people. It's a risk factor but if both people have a strong ontological(self) security to keep both personalities intact there is a richer relationship.
But in the eye of an observer is a waste of time discussing the qualities of each partner that we can't see, so I stick to watching the resulting interrelated persona, that is observable.
If you want to change a relationship, never try to change any qualities of the peers, but try to see and discuss what's wrong in the middle, otherwise you will finish playing the Guilt game of the jewish-christian(or puritane) culture and the relation is already lost.

i agree with you....

Come to think of it. It's not really boring having someone that thinks like you. Imagine your partner thinking like you, liking what you like, doing what you do, behaving like you. I think it eliminates quarrels and arguements because you guys tend to agree on a matter easily. All the same I still prefer a complementing partner.

i dont really agree total with your opening statements.you see if we were so comfortable with ourselves we wouldnt need companionship in the firat place.companionship is born out of the want for a complement we cant give ourselves.similarities will just make it easier for you to access the comolement! both are so important!

my opinion in particular is that it is better to have a partner with more similarities than opposed, that contributes better in communication, it is easier to share more time together, the same happens with friends and partners.
Excellent post dear friend @krnel thank you very much for spreading this news
I wish you a beautiful weekend

@jlufer i actually points to the fact that no one criteria is enough to determine attraction..nice thought.

Indeed, friends share time based on common similar likes... it would seem better for romance to work the same way ;)

i think i'd prefer a partner who is similar... that way we will have more in common, similar hobbies and can talk about things that interest us :)

how about some characters you love in people that you dont have yourself? wouldnt you wanna be with someone that has that character in addition to the similarities you both share?

@jazicothyrus Yes a bit of both is always good as long as you have things in common :)

Yes, it seems logical for spending more time together ;)

That is well put.

I will never understand people's need to quantize human relationships just so it can be easier to grasp. If the code for that was lying around than we would all be conquering the world right about now.

World keeps telling us that every relationship needs work. But what I see is that Every relationship needs sacrifice and not just some 2 hour daily work plan. Either you sacrifice something or you don't. In the end to each his own.

I always find the older generation very interesting. most of them never probably even knew of marriage Councillors let alone be in a session with them. Yet they had a successfully been in relationship with somebody for life (and lets not disparage them by singing the fewer choices thus less distraction song )

well i will say time changes and so does people and processes.the old folks had their moments,their peculiarities and their own problems and so does the folks of now a days.sacrifice is a totally different factor from what we were discussing about. its a whole topic by itself

amazing guys i like it

lets hear the part u like @mukhtarefandi