Psychology of movies: Split and the multiple personalities

in psychology •  7 years ago 

Split

How well does Hollywood portray mental disorders and other psychological problems? In this series of posts, we will analyze some films and see how cinema takes advantage to entertain and at the same time try to generate box office with the problems of the human mind. Some disorders are so strange that they seem to be a product of the screenwriter's imagination and others are shown in a very fanciful way, which makes the public doubt their existence or misconceptions are created.

Split is an American 2016 film, directed and written by M. Night Shyamalan and starring by James McAvoy. The argument is that Kevin (McAvoy) lives with 23 other personalities in his body and is waiting for the number 24, which the others call "The Beast" and who kidnap young women who will be the food of this personality, the which finally reveals itself as a very powerful being, with an overwhelming force, capable of doing impossible stuff like growing up and gaining muscles in seconds (a kind Hulk).

Split_PosterArt.jpg
Split movie page www.uphe.com

Disorder

The disorder sufferer by Kevin, is popularly known as multiple personality disorder, but its scientific name is dissociative personality disorder and consists precisely in this: in one person does not reside one personality, as is normal, but live at least two and even an indeterminate number of personalities, and may go over 100. Each of these personalities has its own tastes, interests, ages, sex, way of walking, talking, etc., as if it were someone else's; they may even be unaware of the existence of the rest of the personalities.

What causes it?

The explanation far surpasses the scope of this post, I will only tell you that the most accepted theory is that it is a mechanism of evasion before trauma or very severe abuse in childhood. Actually it´s suffered by Kevin, who is shown in some flashbacks as her mother physically abused frequently. This theory says that the mind is invented alternate personalities, who are not going through the mistreatment and thus be able to survive this. Thus, the one mistreated and traumatized is only Kevin and not the rest of the alter ego, who can be successful and happy people.
Around this disorder there is much controversy, in fact many psychologists and psychiatrists even deny its existence and say that the few documented cases are simply fraud: patients fake the symptoms, but that is another matter and theme for a possible future post.

Review

Is the treatment of the disorder accurate in the film? No. I cannot give an intermediate answer. Although it is correct in some things, as the possible origin of the disorder due to the infantile abuse suffered and the presentation of the different personalities of Kevin is very good, the fact that they were preparing the way for the arrival of another, kidnapping girls to offer them in sacrifice to someone who did not yet exist, in addition to the completely fanciful characteristics of "The Beast", make the approach to the disorder not the most appropriate. Look out! I'm not evaluating the film in any other aspect, in fact I liked it a lot, it manages to keep the suspense from beginning to end and the main performances are simply masterful. My analysis is strictly of the use made of the psychological disorder of the main character.

What about you, did you see it? What do you think? I will be presenting more posts like this with other films dealing with various psychological issues, see you!

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

@psicomar thanks for such a great post. Hollywood as you say tends to portrail things in a box office money generating way...whether are mental deseases, history, etc.
It´s a shame that people with no interest in finding facts on their own will go about topics on what they see in the moviesll

Good post friend follow me to follow you and be in touch (;

I just did!

Thanks for your comment, Im very glad you like it! Youre right and that`s why I wanted to post these kind of topics, althouh I don´t deny I like hollywood movies, but with a critical eye. Follow me!

John Grinder, the formost authority on NLP (Neuro Linquistic Programming) in at least a couple of his books speaks of encountering very many split personality cases in his career. He also goes on to say that after all of the cases that he's encountered he has yet to find one case of split personality that was not created inadvertently by a psychiatrist. Nice post!

nice comment! Indeed, like I said, it´s a controversial subject

I imagine it is.

Un actor fascinante para un papel fascinante, todos esperando el final para saber cómo sería "the beast".

tienes razón, el actor no pudo haberlo hecho mejor, se la come. En cuanto a la bestia, es la parte de la película que menos me gustó, por las razones q expuse en el post. Gracias por comentar!