The Minnesota Starvation Experiment - The Other Ancel Keys

in science •  7 years ago  (edited)

Untitled.png


This is my personal review of the Minnesota starvation experiment conducted by Ancel Keys in the 1940s.

For those who don't know, Ancel Keys and his colleagues began doing experiments of starvation during the 1940s in an effort to understand how starvation and semi-starvation were affecting the physiology and psychology of war victims. His studies ended up in two volumes of 1,400+ pages.

His experiment was divided in four parts:

  • phase 1 - 3 months - 3,500 kcals food intake + exercise (control diet)
  • phase 2 - 6 months - semi-starvation diet of 1,570 kcals
  • phase 3 - 3 months - rehabilitation phase - between 2,500 and 3,500 kcals
  • phase 4 - uncontrolled rehabilitation - eat as much as you want.

First, I wouldn't call 1,570 kcals semi-starvation, but I may be wrong. If you look at pictures of these subjects (you can find them via search engine), they were like walking skeletons.

Second, in the uncontrolled rehab phase, some of them were eating north of 10,000 kcals consistently, marking the psychological effects the study left on them. These psychological effects have been described in detail in a couple of papers written about the study.

Alright, I discuss all of these aspects, and much more in the video below.



▶️ DTube
▶️ IPFS


To stay in touch with me, follow @cristi


Cristi Vlad Self-Experimenter and Author

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

It is so unbelievable to me that insulin raising, low calorie diets are still pushed and used by so many in the USA as a way to 'lose weight'. The science seems so clear and has been around for far longer than I had been aware. I happened across a book in a thrift store titled 'Why We Get Fat' by Gary Taubes. It changed my life after so many years of trying every 'starvation' diet. Thanks for what you do and share @Cristi. Much gratitude :)

Jeez, this was done on war victims? Poor guys...

Resteemed for visibility! Keep up the great content!

It was for a good cause.

I agree that the calorie starvation phase seemed on the particularly safe side... I eat barely more than that a day and I still gain weight, and I'm a tall person. I suppose if they were controlled for an active lifestyle that would make all the difference.

Either way, interesting results and agree with your commentary!

I guess technically they can call it semi-starvation, since starvation diets generally are 800 kcals per day.

Oh... good point haha

Very good