Bitcoin, Bullion or Bucks: What is Money?

in silver •  6 years ago  (edited)

In today's video we discuss the question "what is money?" What are the intrinsic characteristics that define its appearance, use and capability, and how do those qualities apply or not apply to Bitcoin, Bullion and Bucks.

What is Money?

Money is a store of value which can be spent in the future, and it is a medium of exchange, a tool which enables mankind to get around the limitations within barter systems, such as "coincidence of wants".

431824041_257731-2.jpg

Limitations to Barter and the Need for Money:

Coincidence of wants is a hurdle to trade, wherein you can only trade your objects with those who happen to want them simultaneously.

If you trade fish, and I don't want fish, you are out of luck. Worse still, if you trade fish, and fishing season is over, you have nothing today to trade, and you starve and die.

Enter money, a store of value, a medium of exchange. Once we have money the fisherman can trade his fish, during fishing season, for money, which will not spoil a month later, enabling him to trade during the rest of the year, dispensing it slowly, as he needs goods and services.

Again the money, stores value into the future, and acts as a medium of exchange, which circumvents the limitations of barter.

dollarbill.jpg

Good vs. Bad Money:

Ok, if money is simply a store of value, and a medium of exchange, why can't we just use feathers, shells from the sea, or old Weimar German marks?

First, we did use those at one time. Second, we no longer use those because we can distinguish between good and bad forms of money, and we do so on the following criterion:

  1. Good money is PORTABLE.
  2. Good money is DIVISIBLE.
  3. Good money is DURABLE.
  4. Good money is FUNGIBLE.
  5. Good money is RESISTANT TO COUNTERFEIT.

Feathers, shells, and Weimar German marks all failed to some degree on one or more of these criterion, making them unsuccessful, and resulting in their death.

Bitcoin, Bullion & Bucks: What is the BEST money?

Cryptocurrency, bullion and fiat dollars all to some degree meet these criterion for assessing money, but spoilers, money is NOT good money, it falls short, particularly when measured against the utility and functionality of cryptocurrency and/or bullion.

1_a_UJgbQfGI0pEnP0BOxcNg.png

Crypto as Money:

Crypto is a store of value, and a medium of exchange, add to that it is portable, divisible, durable and fungible, while being resistant to counterfeit, so yes crypto is excellent "money", probably the best money humanity has ever seen. Better even than bullion, because it is even more easily portable, divisible, durable, and resistant to counterfeiting.

Silver-bullion-gold-Scales.jpg

Bullion as Money:

Bullion is also a store of value, medium of exchange, and portable, divisible, durable and fungible, while being resistant to counterfeit, and YES, it is real money. What's more, it has one thing crypto lacks, thousands of years of history proving it as great money. Silver and gold have been money for nearly as long as mankind has been trading, and it will always be a trusted medium of exchange because of the trust and confidence born out of that history.

wheelbarrow-wallet.png

Bucks: Terrible as Money

As I explain in the video, currency printed by your government, or the federal bank in your area is not quality money and for the same reasons the Weimar mark is no longer used, USD, CDN, Yen, Euro, or pick your favour fiat, will all die too. They fall short on the measurements of quality money described above.

Fiat dollars are portable, divisible, and relatively durable, but so are sea shells, but fiat dollars fall short as compared to bullion and bitcoin, when you assess the degree of fungibility and resistance to counterfeiting.

quote-paper-is-poverty-it-is-only-the-ghost-of-money-and-not-money-itself-thomas-jefferson-65-8-0805.jpg

Fiat dollars are printed into existance daily, and there is no end in sight. The federal reserve banks all play the same Keynesian inflation is good game, and so they all print and debase their local currency in the hopes of sparking economic growth. In so doing, the nation's fiat dollar is actively counterfeited, and made less fungible. How? The mass production of USD today is weakening the dollars earned yesterday, and so USD loses value across time due to inflation, and that means a dollar yesterday is not directly comparable to a dollar today. This is an economic principle called the "time value of money", and suffice it to say, a bird in the hand is worth more than two in the bush.

At the same time, as fiat printing continues, at some point the "value" inherent to the dollar are lost, and you are printing worthless copies, which in my understanding is exactly the definition of "counterfeiting".

So your fiat dollar is regularly counterfeited, by the local federal reserve, and it is not deeply fungible because a dollar today is less than a dollar next year, meaning they are not all equal, and therefore not strictly fungible.

Conclusion:

Fiat dollars have and will always fail and go to zero, because they inevitably fall victim to government manipulation, and deficit spending always leads to hyperinflation, meaning fiat is NOT good money.

On the other hand, gold and silver have proven themselves as great money for millennia now, and will prove their strength as excellent money well into our future.

And lastly cryptocurrency, specifically Bitcoin, also meets all the criteria for sound money, and so is great money, perhaps the best money we have ever seen.

final comments.png

Comments & Questions?

What do you guys think? Is Crypto the best money, or is Bullion better? I hope we can all agree fiat is not money, it is garbage, and the writing is on the wall that it will end in disaster.

As always, thank you for your time and attention, have an awesome day and God bless.

1111111.png

Buy Cryptocurrency:
Coinbase:
https://www.coinbase.com/join/59bbe24dd0e8a800f12e7b93
Coinsquare:
coinsquare.com/register?r=E4EB3832E

Buy Bullion:
https://silvergoldbull.ca/

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

The topic of "money" has been coming up a lot recently. I saw this post yesterday about "demonetizing money." https://steemit.com/@taskmaster4450/demonetizing-money

I commented about some of the differences in currency and money as the author had used them interchangeably. If you scroll to the comments, you'll see an interesting exchange where someone else responded (in very long sentences) as he tried to refute what I was saying. At this point, I've decided not to respond as we're getting further away from understanding each other. I thought you might find it interesting though.

I read your exchange with that other user, I see what you mean. I think he spoke in needlessly large sentences and with unnecessarily big words.

In short it seems he didnt agree with your, and my, opinion that money and currency are different. P.S. I love Mike Maloney, Hidden Secrets of Money, and I saw you link that.

He also seemed to want to debate that money could be a store of value, but of course it can.

He seemed to be suggesting that a "store of value" meant something different than it does to me, like that if the stored value varies overtime at all, then the term "store of value" can no longer apply, but that's silly.

If I buy a bitcoin, and its price was $20,000 USD, and now is $6,500 its still a store of value, but the value has fluxuated, same with Gold, Silver, or any money.

I guess I should mention, I disagree with your point that crypto (particularly bitcoin) is not "money" i think it is. It is portable, divisible, durable, fungible and resistant to counterfeit, as well as being a medium of exchange and store of value.

Again, what do we mean by "store of value"? I mean, that you can place liquid wealth into it, by buying bitcoin, and then hold that bitcoin into the future, where you may spend it. Certainly my BTC may fall in price, and if it does my purchase has lost some of its "value", but the BTC is nevertheless a store of value, maybe not as good of a store as gold, or land, but nevertheless it is a store.

He seemed to be saying that crypto was somehow good money, and gold was not, and I think that's silly. And last point, that whole part, where he was saying, how money cant be both a store of value and a currency is just plain wrong IMO.

Good debate, and I dont blame you for not replying again. :)

Loading...

88F19778-7133-45DB-95D3-1327F58C870C.jpeg

Sea shells were money, gold is money, what about 24 karat gold sea shells!

Haha best of both worlds! ;)

Seriously tho, I prefer rounds to unusual molds like this. Its just easier to store and I imagine exchange, if and when bullion is used daily as a medium of exchange again.

I hear ya! Nothing wrong with owning some regular rounds and stuff, I certainly do. But you probably know a lot of people that own diluted overpriced 14 karat gold jewelry right? Wouldn’t it be better \easier to explain to them why they would want to own 24k pure gold jewelry as an alternative to their 1000% mark up tiffanies ? :)

Spread your risks, Crypto is worthless if networks are down. Gold is handy to take with you running in the desert…...

COMPLETELY agreed.
I stack silver. I am on a journey to 1,000 oz of Silver. I post about that sometimes, check it out.

https://steemit.com/silver/@infidel1258/silver-stacking-journey-to-1-000-oz

this is very true. there is also tremendous benefit in owning physical metals over paper stuff.
https://goldsilvermart.ca/physical-gold-vs-paper-gold-why-going-physical-is-a-must/

This post has received a 4.01 % upvote from @boomerang.

Hi @infidel1258!

Your post was upvoted by @steem-ua, new Steem dApp, using UserAuthority for algorithmic post curation!
Your UA account score is currently 2.355 which ranks you at #18906 across all Steem accounts.
Your rank has improved 225 places in the last three days (old rank 19131).

In our last Algorithmic Curation Round, consisting of 248 contributions, your post is ranked at #144.

Evaluation of your UA score:
  • Only a few people are following you, try to convince more people with good work.
  • Your contribution has not gone unnoticed, keep up the good work!
  • Good user engagement!

Feel free to join our @steem-ua Discord server