transparency request coming from a guy who's obviously hiding his identity
Irony at its finest. And it's almost as if I want to bring up a controversial topic, anonymously.
some question I have as to whether this research was "funded" by a whale
Ludicrous and unfounded.
the concept that a straight vote count isn't generally subject to sybil attack is just ludicrous and trying to promote that this might be a reasonable view of people's opinion just ticks me off,
It IS subject to one, but my argument is that currently no one has bothered due to the fact that there is no need; people use voting proxies. Like I said in the post, take that data entry with a grain of salt.
not recognizing that the current voting is not a static thing, and therefore suggesting that if dan or val's votes were changed, no one else might change their votes as well.
You miss the point of the post.
While I have you here, let's talk about you, blocktrades. Of course you would downvote this post.
Blocktrades would want to hide any controversy or discussion about the witness list, as I believe he does not care about steemit, but simply wants to cash out as much money as possible.
Blocktrades is powering down and selling as fast as he can, on all his accounts. Here's some of them, there are lots:
{'maximo', 'braxton', 'yaretzi', 'tobias', 'benita', 'kevphanis', 'graavor', 'yadiel', 'abdul', 'tanner', 'gifthana', 'ashleigh', 'walter', 'foscarota', 'erihn', 'aguilar', 'anastacia', 'lessys', 'darah', 'augusta', 'bavihm', 'abbigail', 'bavak', 'analisa', 'weston', 'chana', 'sterling', 'adrian', 'brayan', 'killian', 'vincent', 'trinity', 'blocktrades', 'aftergut', 'bendixen', 'arroyo', 'cleta', 'sergio', 'danea', 'jamgotin', 'arsahk', 'tratorin', 'walter', 'brick', 'jamie', 'zachary'}
Am I missing any accounts? You tell me.
So how much money are you taking out of steemit?
All your accounts powering down and selling. Example..
You operate an exchange, taking a large haircut on every transaction.
You are the most influential curator, but constantly upvote random things simply for curation rewards.
You are a top witness, getting massive witness funding. (1370 SP a day).
Does this level of cashing out of the Steemit community sound like an action a top witness should take? What does the community think about this behavior?
So, blocktrades, what are you using all your funding for?
I said: "not recognizing that the current voting is not a static thing, and therefore suggesting that if dan or val's votes were changed, no one else might change their votes as well."
and you replied: "You miss the point of the post."
I'm pretty sure I didn't miss any point in your analysis (but feel free to clarify the point you think I missed), but you manage to quote my point about your response and then somehow ignore the argument entirely in your "rebuttal", before launching your attempt to side-track the discussion by attacking me. Great argument technique, btw.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Your response pretty much confirms my opinions on your post. As to your comments about my accounts, I've never made any secret of the fact I have lots of accounts or that some are for sale. Like many whales, I gained a lot of accounts during the early mining days, and didn't realize the benefit of consolidating them. As to my voting, it's not random, in fact, it consumes quite a bit of time. As to "hiding" controversy, I could have easily buried this post completely if that was my intent. I just don't think you should get rewards for a poorly thought out post (or maybe I should say intentional distortion of what's going on in the voting for witnesses) that really only seems aimed at damaging steemit (and maybe collecting some rewards from your supporter along the way).
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Freedom. There's no should. There is nothing wrong in powering down, there is nothing wrong in taking profit from own investment and there is nothing wrong in running operating exchange service (Seriously? I need to defend that? Let's get back on to the right track.)
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit