Steemit idea #??: Digital watermarking of Steemit contentsteemCreated with Sketch.

in steemit •  7 years ago  (edited)

I have heard about and witnessed a fair bit of plagiarism at Steemit. There may be little we can do about the external instances where people steal photos, text and videos from off-site and post them here as their own work, so @steemcleaners and @cheetah as well as a few others are hard at work each day.

Yesterday I came across a strange case where someone had stolen a signature. It was a personalised animated .gif made for @suesa and someone was using it as their own. It was brought to her attention and she flagged and asked the user to remove it.

I am unsure what has happened since but this is the blockchain, her work is searchable and time-stamped. The problem is that Steemit is growing into a large space and finding the instances of plagiarism and theft requires someone to manually see it and recognise it as stolen, which is increasingly becoming difficult.

What I was wondering however is if there can be a line of hidden code that can be applied to content created within Steemit. Perhaps it can be somewhat automatic through a check box and preset field.

For example: >>> original content @tarazkp <<<

This code could be automatically hidden in each paragraph of text or as often as needs be which means if cut and paste into a new document, the user will get a mention and if 20 mentions suddenly pop up, it is likely plagiarism.

The same could be applied to the images of photographers etc so that at least on the Steem blockchain, it is safe from plagiarism. it could even be different code for different rights, like copyright or creative commons.I know this doesn't solve problems with theft from other platforms. Yet.

However in some distant future, images uploaded here are automatically scanned for authenticity. It may be possible that for content like photos, the photographer can register them on the blockchain without having to post. This could mean that at some point, if work appears on other platforms, it can be traced back to the original owners.

For text, it may be useful if Steemit had a draft function that allows users to create drafts on the blockchain making their work undeniably theirs. I use WordPress a lot for my drafts and have hundreds of unfinished or unpublished work. These are like my canvases if I was a painter. If they were on the blockchain, even after my death they are creditable to me.

There are more and more 'pay for content' sites popping up and the problem is going to come when people are stealing work from authors at Steemit and mirroring them on other platforms as their own. This may be happening already, I do not know. after all, they steal content from other sources and bring them in here. It would be interesting if stolen content generated revenue for the original creator instead of the thief.

With blockchain tech we must be able to at least protect the work and rights of our own content providers, even if in the beginning it is just be raising the height of the hurdle. Having s digital water mark on text means that to plagiarise and reducing the risk of getting caught, extra steps are required such as typing it out or breaking it apart to remove the hidden code.

Again, I am not a technical person and don't know if this is possible yet or ever but increasing the difficulty or stopping theft internally could be a testing ground for a whole range of off-site solutions. Perhaps there is something in here that developers could find interesting to build upon.

Yes/No/Maybe/gtfo?

Taraz
[ a Steemit original ]

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

I don't think there is a good or even a realistic way to implement this. Pure text can't really hide anything and what we are writing here is really pure text with all the code bare.

And even if we were using visual editors, as long as you know there is some hidden meta information or formating with a piece of text you want to plagarise, you just paste it into a piece of editing software that doesn't support nothing but text like notepad and then copy what you have there which would be just the text you see and nothing hidden.

If protecting your content like that was somehow possible, all websites would be implementing it, not just steemit.

  ·  7 years ago (edited)

The problem with blockchains is that they are censorship resistant. Also the good thing. You can't write privacy without piracy.

Invisible Digital watermarks are useful post hoc, like watermark factory or plain old photoshop, and works once the burglar is found.

How to signal the person their content has been stolen is a much harder problem.

This is what i am wondering about. If the account is somehow mentioned in the watermark, it could create a notification of use. I understand that when there is money, there is incentive but increasing the work required to plagiarise may at least lower the amount of people willing. I don't know if it is possible in the long run as technology itself will make plagiarism easier also.

  ·  7 years ago (edited)

(even if you trace the material, others could snip it) Well, you could use an add-on for image view. Since the content is in the blockchain anyone can watch it. But if you encrypt it before uploading and only decode it with the add-on then that's your stuff . For everyone not in the know, they could see the image but 1 pixel distorted, enough to discourage copying. Problem is that it would require you signing personally your followers,

  ·  7 years ago Reveal Comment

lol

I very much agree with you Sir @tarazkp, but I wanted to ask is the one thing that is when we take a reference to strengthen our opinions and the source we already put in the article we will share but still be considered as plagiarism, this happened to me personally, I usually use Wikipedia as a reference for me because the explanation there is very detailed and complete. But it turns out that Wikipedia else take some references from other sources. When I give a posting is considered plagiarism. How do you feel about this Sir. I also really appreciate the hard work of the cheetah and steemcleaners, their absence may be an awful lot of plagiarism that occurred in this stemit. Please Sir, the response was perhaps a little help for me. Thank you.

  ·  7 years ago Reveal Comment

Thank you very much Sir @tarazkp, your opinion is very helpful for me, sometimes I also thought like that, but I do not know to whom to ask how the solution. Kareana coincidence you give the posting about it so I was immediately asked to you Sir. Maybe in the future I should be more careful in taking the quote. As you say the quote that's just sentence rather than the page. Thank you so much for your response Sir.

In text you could do the following: There usually is an empty line between paragraps. Steem could insert a line of text there which is white colored. This way it is not obtrusive. What the line of text be, I don't know. Maybe a link to the original article?

NOPE! That would trigger the search engines to flag your posts as SPAM and NOT index your work. Hidden text using the same color text as background has been a no no for quite a long time.

Yeah !
Its great concept .
It will help to reduce copy-paste .

Fighting content theft is not easy

Gtfo... lol
Jk. I think at the end of the day ignore it will absolutely boil back down to the human side, human spirit to practice integrity. Technology can only help us so much I guess.

  ·  7 years ago (edited)Reveal Comment

People like you should stay far far away from the Internet, or at least from Steemit. You're bringing no good for the community.

So much anger here...

  ·  7 years ago Reveal Comment