REBELLION IN THE FARM AND Venezuela: the same beginning. The same end?
Hello, Steem friends. These days, as I was reading one of the last @dedicatedguy posts for @adsactly, I was remembering how the whole problem we live in today in my country, Venezuela, had begun. Inevitably, as it happens when we watch many movies, the one who has read some books cannot help but associate some realities with some stories they have read. I remembered Animal Farm by George Orwell.
This novel published in 1945 is about a group of farm animals who, dissatisfied by the treatment they had and by the manipulation of some, decide to expel human tyrants and create a system of self-government, which ends up becoming another brutal tyranny. In my country, Venezuela, it more or less happened in the same way: one day a group of people came and talked about what they did to us or had done to us, how we had been enslaved, and that we had to get out of the yoke to which they were subjecting us. The problem was never that they sowed the seed, the detail was that they got fertile land. The problem was never that they told us that we had been discriminated against or marginalized, but that we had really felt that way. The problem was not what they eliminated, but what they started with that revolution.
In the case of Animal Farm we see how at the beginning El Viejo Mayor, an old pig that had been rewarded, from a dream that he had had, calls for the rebelión of the animals. He tells him that man has been the sole cause of his ills and that they must get rid of him:
Everything is explained in one word: man. Man is the only real enemy we have. Make Man disappear from the scene and the motivating cause of our habre and overwork will be abolished forever.
In Venezuela more or less the same thing happened. One day Hugo Rafael Chávez Frías appeared, talking about a dream of freedom, where supposedly Simón Bolívar, hero of Venezuela, helped him to take the people out of the supposed slavery where they were. This gentleman, until that unknown moment and leader of one of the best-known attacks in democratic history against an incumbent president, raised his flag of rebellion against all those who had governed the country up to that moment. After that, he launches himself as president, the people elect him and he begins to govern the country.
One of the things Hugo Rafael Chávez says when he comes to power is that having money is bad, enjoying some comforts is bad, that we should all be equal. The chavista revolution was a revolution of the poor, shirtless, and therefore they had to sacrifice themselves for the revolution. In Animal Farm we see how one of the first premises they hold when they come to power is equality and the rejection of human customs:
No animal should live in a house, sleep in a bed, wear clothes, drink alcohol, smoke tobacco, handle money or engage in commerce. All the customs of Man are bad. And, above all, no animal should tyrannize such. Weak or strong, clever or naive, we are all brothers. No animal should kill another animal. All animals are equal.
As we can see, some luxuries were considered harmful and not only respect for each other, but also equality was called for.
When in Orwell's novel the animals assume power, they start the changes on the farm, from the name of the farm, the construction of a new flag, to making a sign with the new commandments that will be the laws that the animals will have to follow. The same thing happened in Venezuela when Chávez took power: the name of the country was changed, the flag, the shield and even a new constitution was made that would govern the laws of the country. In fact, ministries were built without any sense just for the simple pleasure of changing the old ones for new ones and that in the end failed because they had no sense of being. In Rebellion on the Farm this also happens:
Snowball was also busy organizing others, in what he called Animal Committees. For this, he was tireless. He formed the Committee for the Production of Eggs for Chickens, the League of Clean Tails for Cows, the Committee for the Re-education of Wild Comrades (whose purpose was to domesticate rats and rabbits), the Whiter Wool Movement for Sheep, and many others, as well as organizing reading and writing classes. In general, these projects proved to be a failure.
Well, another of the slogans of the Venezuelan government is loyalty to the revolution: the people owe obedience to the Venezuelan government; something contrary to this can be considered treason to the homeland. In Orwell's history they also employ this mandate of fidelity to the animal revolution:
Courage is not enough," said Squealer. Loyalty and obedience are more important... Discipline, comrades, iron discipline! That is the slogan for today. One false step, and our enemies would fall upon us.
In terms of enemies, that is another of the similarities between the history of Venezuelans and the history of Orwell. When Hugo Chávez came to power, he not only saw the opportunity to create imaginary battles with other countries, such as the United States and Colombia, but also created distrust and enmity among Venezuelans themselves. In Animal Farm we read how Snowball, after being an ally of the revolution, becomes a politically persecuted person:
Comrades," he said in a quiet voice, "do you know who is responsible for all this? Do you know who is the enemy who came during the night and knocked down our mill? Snowball! -Snowball has done this! Out of pure evil, believing he was going to ruin our plans and avenge himself for his ignominious expulsion.
From that moment on, as in Venezuela, every problem on the farm was the fault of the enemy, of the traitor, never of the government's mismanagement:
When something went wrong, it was customary to attribute it to Snowball. If a window was broken or a drain was blocked, it was a sure thing that someone would say that Snowball had done it during the night.
And the chase between them began. Knowing who the enemy's ally was, who supported him became the next step. In Venezuela, government opponents have been persecuted, humiliated and massacred. The same is true of Orwell's novel:
And so the series of confessions and executions continued until a pile of corpses lay at Napoleon's feet and the air was permeated with the smell of blood... They were shaken and dismayed. They did not know what was more frightening; whether the betrayal of the animals that were combined with Snowball or the cruel repression they had just witnessed. In the past there were many times scenes of equally terrible killings, but to all of them it seemed much worse than now, because it had happened among themselves.
What until then had been a united and prosperous farm began to suffer the consequences of an improvised revolution under the command of inefficient people, much like what has happened in our country where the economy is frankly deteriorating, inflation is unstoppable and despite being an oil country, we are a country with hunger. Let's take as an example a passage from the novel:
In January, food was scarce. The corn ration was drastically reduced and it was announced that, in compensation, an additional ration of potatoes would be granted. But then it was discovered that most of the potato crop had been frozen because it had not been sufficiently protected. The tubers had softened and discolored, and very few were edible. For days the animals had nothing to feed on except straw and beets. The spectre of hunger seemed to look at them face to face.
In the previous paragraph, we noted the inefficient governance of the farm and the bad food policies assumed by those in power. If before they had a flourishing farm, now they were faced with neglect for not having worked the land properly. But immediately Napoleon, who was the leader, asked for the hunger and unproductiveness of the land to be hidden: the rest of the world had no reason to know that they had failed in their revolution. This led to all animals being required to speak well of the farm government and whoever spoke ill was imprisoned and annihilated. Then it was not uncommon to hear the praises that other animals did to the great leader:
It had become customary to attribute to Napoleon every fortunate feat and every stroke of luck. It was often heard that one hen would say to another: "Under the leadership of our Leader, Comrade Napoleon, I have laid five eggs in six days," or two cows, as they tasted the water from the drinking fountain, used to exclaim: "Thanks to our Leader, Comrade Napoleon, what a rich taste this water has!
And so the years passed, and no animal, because of its ignorance and fear of being punished, turned against Napoleon and his government. Eventually oblivion came and no one did anything to remember how the tragedy they were living had begun. In fact, as the years had passed and many of the old men had died, no one knew what the farm had been like before the rebellion. They only accepted their fate:
Generally they were hungry, they slept on straw, drank from the pond, worked in the fields; in winter they suffered the effects of the cold and in summer from the flies. Sometimes the oldest among them searched their murky memories and tried to determine whether in the early days of the rebellion, when Jones' expulsion was still recent, things had been better or worse than they are now. They couldn't remember.
It is known that many of the cultural impositions that countries have suffered in recent years are a sign of the weak respect that citizens may have for their history and the lack of memory of their inhabitants. The same can be said of the political errors that have led, in recent years, countries to live through evils that they had supposedly overcome and left in the past. For example, Venezuela was a prosperous country with a growing economy. However, we forgot the evils of military governments and their tragic consequences, and we fell into a trap called the Bolivarian Revolution. We are still paying for our mistakes.
I hope you enjoyed reading. Remember to vote for @adsactly as a witness and visit us on our discord channel. See you next time with a smile.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
George Orwell (2000). Animal Farm. Skla Publishing House
Written by @nancybriti
Click on the coin to join our Discord Chat
Witness proposal is here:
Go To Steem Witness Page
In the bottom of the page type: adsactly-witness and press vote.
Use small letters and no "@" sign. Or, click here to vote directly!
Thank you!
This post has received a 20.00% upvote from @jmiller05!
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
... and there is a long debt ahead to pay.
People have become so oblivious to recent history that criminals such as Luisa Ortega are now getting an audience and are considered allies.
Every animal, from Baduel on, who contributed to the destruction of the Venezuelan farm, deserves nothing but punishment, and yet, in the name of strategy, humanity, goodness and forgiveness we will shortly see a lot of former chavistas ruling the country under the assumption that the original plan (Chavez’s) was a good one, but was distorted by usurpers.
This tale, like Orwell’s story is not going to end well.
Soon, people will see from chavistas to maduristas to opositores and from opositores to chavistas and won’t be able to tell the difference.
I want to be wrong so badly.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
How nice to read you here, @hlezama! Certainly, now those who once offended, robbed and even killed are innocent and even considered friends, just for the sake of repenting. The Venezuelan lacks memory, pride, shame not to forget so soon. I don't want to be as pessimistic as you are, but life is taking me to a point where I will inevitably have to open my eyes and tear out my heart. I embrace you, my friend.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Big hug, my dear. I have tried every possible scenario in my head, but the evidence around us does not give much to any optimistic option.
The revolution fucked us hasta la madre.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
so sad
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Great article @nancybriti, indeed we must all pay for each and every action we take here on earth as a human being. We should learn to think before we act, most times we're been carried away by what we see and what we here. This leaders are well trained men when it comes to deceiving and making you believe in all there actions and once you eventually give the that opportunity which they seek, then you get to see the real person in them.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
So, @lilkeszi. I think politicians are all the same in all parts of the world. I imagine that a person who lies can aspire to be a politician. Thank you for your comment.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
This is a bitter story it applies to almost all the countries, we often have people who preach change and are all about the people, selfless service to humanity and they start by creating that picture in the minds of people who will believe in their dreams then when they eventually get into power they forget all what they preached about before getting into power, because power is intoxicating to human.
Here in Nigeria the current president had contested elections for four times on which he lost 3 and won at the fourth time. The reason he won was becuase Nigerians needed to change, they needed another party to take control. So they believed his change agenda without knowing it was a scam, they spent the whole of their administration blaming the previous Government that handed power to them, they ended crumbling the little we had hope on, today a lot of people are suffering here in Nigeria as a result of the President inefficiency to govern his people.
I could go on and on, but i just want to sympathize with you and also draw your attention that Nigeria is no better than Venezuela we are almost in the same train. Corrupt government officials embezzling what is made for the common man.
May God save us.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I like this historical post.And
This is an unpleasant story it applies to every one of the nations, we regularly have individuals who lecture change and are about the general population, benevolent administration to humankind and they begin by making that image in the psyches of individuals who will have confidence in their fantasies then when they in the end get into power they overlook all what they lectured about before getting into power, since power is inebriating to human.so go ahead and Carry on your activities..
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Very complete, relevant and effective your post, @nancybriti. You do an accurate literary-political comparative work in which you manage to highlight the similarities between fiction and (sad) reality. Orwell was, without a doubt, a writer with a very up-to-date political lucidity, but with a vision of the future. Of course, he had a broad humanistic background, had participated in politics, was a man aware of what was happening in the world, had traveled to places in conflict (Spanish Civil War), and, above all, was an intelligent man and good writer. All that came together in those two great works of his 1984 and Rebelión en la granja. It never ceases to amaze us how he had studied the phenomena of authoritarianism and totalitarianism - we would say to use an easy resource - from right and left: German Nazism, Italian fascism, Soviet regime (Leninist and Stalinist). He extracted the keys that allowed him to unveil (and denounce) in fiction the authoritarian-populist-totalitarian paradigm, which has been fulfilled in almost all the countries where regimes of this type have been imposed. It is the painful, dramatic case of Venezuela, which you well describe and which we who live in this country devastated by "chavomadurismo" suffer so much. Thank you for sharing your text, @nancybriti, and @adsactly for letting us know.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
This is a very interesting publication, @nancybriti. The comparison you have made between the novel and the Venezuelan case leaves us a bitter taste when we discover that reality surpasses fiction. It is regrettable how we fell into the clutches of communism, how we are victims of a group of populist politicians who have done so much damage to our country and have deteriorated it in its most important resource as is the Venezuelan, the majority without dignity and without aspirations, contenting themselves with what a corrupt government gives them. And the worst thing about our situation is that I don't think there is a way out in the immediate future and we will continue with the uncertainty of every day: Until when will this be. Thanks to @adsactly for this space and for spreading quality content.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
"Some of them are more equal than others" is the line from the book that will stay with me forever. Long after I remember whether things were better under Jones or not.
That is a truly great article, Nancy. Very nicely done.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Sad to see what is going on there. Hope some good will come out of it in the long run.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I hope so, too, @intrepidphotos. This darkness is leaving us blind and hopeless. Thank you for your good wishes.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
I could go on and on, but i just want to sympathize with you and also draw your attention that Nigeria is no better than Venezuela we are almost in the same train. Corrupt government officials embezzling what is made for the common man.r every single move we make here on earth as a person. We should figure out how to think before we act, most occasions we're been diverted by what we see and what we here. This pioneers are all around prepared men with regards to misleading and influencing you to have confidence in all there activities and once you in the end give the that open door which they look for, at that point you get the chance to see the genuine individual in them.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Historical post so I like it cause history learn to new one and gather knowledge from this it's..
Actually history always gain and learn about old think..
I think that your post just very valuable and I appreciate your post and Carry on your activities and I will support always your every post..
So I will wait your next post..
Keep it up .
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Thank you for your words and support, @shucona
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
That's a great post to provide in this platform..without a doubt we should all compensation foThis is a bitter story it applies to almost all the countries, we often have people who preach change and are all about the people, selfless service to humanity and they start by creating that picture in the minds of people who will believe in their dreams then when they eventually get into power they forget all what they preached about before getting into power, because power is intoxicating to human.Here in Nigeria the current president had contested elections for four times on which he lost 3 and won at the fourth time. The reason he won was becuase Nigerians needed to change, they needed another party to take control.just it..
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit
Hi, @adsactly!
You just got a 1.29% upvote from SteemPlus!
To get higher upvotes, earn more SteemPlus Points (SPP). On your Steemit wallet, check your SPP balance and click on "How to earn SPP?" to find out all the ways to earn.
If you're not using SteemPlus yet, please check our last posts in here to see the many ways in which SteemPlus can improve your Steem experience on Steemit and Busy.
Downvoting a post can decrease pending rewards and make it less visible. Common reasons:
Submit