История стимит
Before, something to look for, it is necessary to understand what we are looking for, where and when.
It is certainly not clear that we are looking for Asgard on the ground and are looking for now, maybe yesterday we were looking and will continue tomorrow to look for. But that's not what I meant. Now I will explain. An example is fictitious but to understand the essence of the problem is appropriate.
At the heart of the collage is a photograph of the 19th century with a view of the Omsk fortress.
In a certain chronicle we come across the mention of the city of Ashburg ... do not give it to Uzhgorod, it's more fun. And it is written that it was founded by the khan Kitap-Agash on the river Eptik, the circle of the Sun was then 28, the moon is 4 indices of the 9th. Here nafig us this city, but let's try to understand about what the chronicler was saying, WHERE it could happen and WHEN. And I wonder who this is Kitap-Agash ...
It should be borne in mind that the manuscript clearly corresponded, but it is a half of trouble for the names. A mistake in one two letters is not a problem. Worse if the mistake the scribe made in the date, for example, wrote not 9 but 6 indict, it can dig up that it's a trifle, but this error entails a mistake in dating more than a thousand years. If it is accurate, the error will be 3x19x28 = 1596 years. 16 centuries!
One and a half millennia!
I could not write one number by stupidity. (someday I will tell you more about the dating dates), And for now we were lucky and the date is quite understandable and corresponds to 1716 AD, and in fact could write that there was the 17th year of Vasi Pupkin's reign ... With WHEN we decided a little and the date may well interest us as the year of the founding of Omsk, this is an occasion to poke deeper. Let's return to the names. If the manuscript was not copied but recorded from the voice, then the distortions in the names may be more significant.
They are caused by the specifics of pronunciation and reading in different languages. Even more problems can cause a repeated translation of the manuscript. And now imagine that the rewritten manuscript was translated from the voice. From the source text and names, there can be no trace left. But more on this later. In the meantime, Uzhgorod. Two components are clearly visible. Already a city. Oh, and Ush are almost identical by ear. In this case, Us and Ash and As in reading are the same (analogue of Russia Rush, and in writing by Arabs and Ashur can happen).
As a result, we get the As-City. From which AsGuard, Gard-City, we get without problems. I will focus attention on such transformations. First of all, they do not prove anything by themselves, so, as with fools, any word can be altered into anything. Secondly, all such transformations must be confirmed by real repetitive examples of their application. Third, if all the same, a logical transformation is unambiguously obtained, but it is not related to the accompanying facts, it can be ignored as a coincidence.
In our case, we get an interesting coincidence of 1716-Asgard, which contradicts history. But for me personally history does not exist, it is more incomprehensible what contradicts what, our guess of history or the history of our guess))) WHAT - we found out ... What do we have next? The Eptic River? I do not know how many hands the manuscript went through and how it was copied, so let's look at this name written in the Latin script Eptic. And about the miracle ... No, of course for the Kazakhs this is not a miracle, they normally read in their own language this word like the Irtysh ... So in 1716 on the river Irtysh the city of Asgard was founded.
You can also calm down because there are no miracles and such coincidences. But I wonder who there founded this city. Khan Kitap-Agash ... Once there was already involved Kazakh, then we'll see what it means in this language ... We translate and get Book-Tree, Wooden book some ... But something strange here in this translation .
I learned German at school and lived in Germany for a long time, so the book and buch are associated quickly, and the combination of 1716-Irtysh-Omsk, the founder and Buch directly draw me to translate the name Buchholz from German into Russian. I understand that the result of the translation of the Book-Tree is quite expected ... As a result, the interesting and delirious foundation of Buchholz Asgard appears before us in all its glory. If only one or two of the 1716-Asgard-Irtysh-Buchholz ligament were received, it could be explained by either a coincidence or a good fantasy, but 4 correspondences to Omsk indicate that we correctly determined WHAT, WHERE, WHEN and WHO.
There remains one question, and here Asgard and everything else found. Well, to vskidku this option. According to rumors Asgard was destroyed in 1530. And if the manuscript was written literally at the base of Omsk, they could call the old name Asgard in the old manner. We call the street. Lenin not only that the old, and never existed name of the Lyubinsky Prospekt ... Here we found Asgard in an unremarkable at first glance manuscript. Why did I invent this example?
And in order to show how easy it is to distort information and how easy it is to find what you want. An example is simple in the sense that everything is concentrated in one sentence, in one manuscript, and in reality copies of this manuscript in which one speaks of Omsk, Asgard, Uzhgorod, Ashburg and Usopolis can be many. And all these cities historians should be placed in space and time, and also deal with the defense of Omsk from the Khan Kitap-Agash ...
So it turns out a big and long world official history, and not one specific event in a very specific place.
We will consider everything written above foreword, which indicated the main problems in the "search Asgard", which I will try to disassemble in detail later.
Оригинал: В поисках Асгарда... Что? Где? Когда?
—-
Disclaimer: I wanted to make a translation of my posts on history, but I realized that I can not translate it. Difficulties and peculiarities of translations make themselves felt, Nevertheless the text will be in English and the guarantee that it will be understood or understood will not be true, but there will be a link to the Russian version, for those who still want to understand the meaning of the text.
—-
Posts from the HBC (HistoryBlockChain)
HBC: How to find Asgard?
HBC - I wanted to write about Asgard ...