@veralynn A public apology is clearly required!

in personal •  8 years ago  (edited)

This is my belated reply to @veralynn

Dear veralynn,

Recently you wrote about a topic we both clearly felt passionately about.
Racism, oppression and sexism

I've been following you for awhile.
Unfortunately I have a severe illness.

I wanted to hear you out. So I followed the link in my feed and I read what you wrote.

I say I read it, but considering my reply it's obvious that I did not understand it.
My wife did though and as she was examining my replies, she explained to me why we were both wrong.

You were wrong to try and redefine certain terms without giving a strong reason as to why. This setup the tone for the rest of the post and caused your actual message to become lost, because those such as myself, could only focus on that one part.

That was your only mistake!

I posted a few heated and angry replies. I used ad-hominems and I attacked you as a person instead of your ideas and your message. This had the effect of weakening my position, to the point of shining a bright light on my own ignorance.

It turned me into an ogre.
I must be right and therefore you cannot possibly be correct!

I know better than this. Ideas and beliefs exist within a spectrum.
We were both correct and we were both inaccurate.

You are not a bigot. I had no right to call you that.

The moment I attacked your character I lost the debate, when all I wanted to do was disagree with the message you were sending.

I don't like messages that tell people it's ok to have this internal dialog of I'm ok being a victim.
It's dis-empowering to those that hear it because it convinces them that someone other than themselves is responsible for their options and choices in life.
In other words, it confirms people's fears that they are powerless

To my mind a better message would have been, that any ism is a disease with roots in ignorance, regardless of your status, position or conditions in life.

The way I said it though, I ended up calling you ignorant.
You are not a bigot, you are not ignorant!

I'm the one who was ignorant. I had a plethora of evidence to the contrary in front of me and yet I refused to pull back and even look. I choose not to pull my head out of my ass and look around.

The truth is you have a powerful platform. This gives you an opportunity that very few people have.

You can send these incredible messages to men and women and inspire them to realize that they too have great power. That they can literally be anything they want to be. All they have to do is exercise their own "will to power" and find the strength to act on their convictions.

Everything I said about you before was simply wrong and I have no excuse to offer.

But here is truth...
You are this vibrant, incredibly intelligent woman who has strong convictions and powerful beliefs. This is true regardless of their source or what others (including myself), may think about the correctness of those beliefs.

The question then is what message will you choose to send to your audience both young and old? One which confirms their fears of being powerless, or one which slaps them in the face and wakes them up to the fact that only they can speak for them; That only they have the power to tap the power within themselves and that with that knowledge they can be as powerful as they choose to be. Just like you have been.

I ask you...
Which message is more powerful?
One which divides?
Or one which unites?

Either way, you have my apology and you have my friendship, I only hope that you will accept both.

p.s. I umm borrowed the top image from you, hope you don't mind! :D

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

Thank you for taking the time to formally apologize.

I must be right and therefore you cannot possibly be correct!

We see this all too much. Other Steemians ought to take note. We should think before we speak and be constructive with our criticisms.

It takes a lot of guts to admit you're wrong. I'm glad we can laugh this off!

Again, thank you for saying this. The feeling is mutual. :)

@veralynn You're very welcome. And I'm glad I didn't ruin a great friendship with someone who has such a formidable mind before it had the chance to really grow.
You're a passionate debater, so am I.

I think this sums it up for both of us.

Great apology!

I did read the original exchange in @veralynn's blog, and I was a bit - erm- shocked at the heat of your reply. I think the issue arose from the fact you two were speaking different languages. You each had different definitions of "racism" and until you could agree on a definition, neither had an ability to understand. So glad you two took a step back, turned on Google Translate (as it were) and came to an understanding :

Judging another person or thinking less of them, or taking power over anyone for any reason is just plain wrong.

I think most of the wars, religious arguments, and fighting could be done away, if we just take a step back and figure out what is the other person or group really trying to say?

And then rejoice in their ability to have a unique opinion in this day and age.

Your wife is a wise woman (yes, I know her in real life). She had the ability to help you see the light and you actually listened to her! (This is a good reminder to all those men and women out there... Life is best not handled alone, but should be a partnership.)

I look forward to your next blog!

  ·  8 years ago (edited)

Its great that you two were able to find common ground. Thing is some of the things in your comments were quite insightful.
There is another thing about the meaning of words. Thing is some shades of meaning change when you move from culture to culture, since those cultures were shaped by their individual cirumstance.
Here in Russia for example the word Racist is mostly understood the way you put it in your comments.
There is a lot of it happening too, because a lot of discrimination is actually against majority here (and Russia is definitely a multi cultural and multi ethnic country). Is it racism? Or what? By which definition?
It is based on how the USSR was set up economically. Usually the money flows from the colonies to the metropoly, right? In case of USSR it happened the other way around. Ethnic culture was supported and finances were pumped into the peripheral republics. Nothing wrong with that, it is just how it was. And during the breakup of USSR there was even systematic genocide of the Russian population in the new states. In baltic ex-USSR stated they are faced with systematic discrimination even today, aas 2nd class citizens.

And I am sure if one goes around the globe they'll see, that depending on where they are different words have different meanings.

What in good is not the content but your intention. I feel great towards a person who admitted mistakes and ask apology. You can choose to send her a message directly but you choose to show it to the public. Just amazing, nothing is lost in doing so, instead you gain more, and that is respect and admiration.

@juvyjabian Thanks! I really appreciate that! Glad to know others feel the same way I do. It's ok to make mistakes. It's not ok to become the mistake, to wallow in the mistake, or to let it define you. That's why I usually apologize in private. But this is one of those times I realize I made a colossal mistake. So it required more than a simple "I'm sorry".

The master has failed more times than the noob has even tried.
You've clearly got a gem in your corner, even knowing what an ad hominem is and why its not an argument, makes your wife an invaluable asset. cheers to your team!

@paul-labossiere Thank you! I've always believed that we have no enemies and there are no strangers. Just friends we haven't met and colleagues we don't yet understand.
I really appreciate your commentary.

We all turn into ogres from time to time. As I've said before it takes balls to admit to it and apologise. Well done.

@williambanks - it takes strong character and esteem to admit when you're wrong. I did not read the original post or your reaction to it. I don't think I need to. Publicly humbling one's self is pretty amazing in a day and age where it's so easy to delete or ignore one's wrong and go on their merry way. You've got two thumbs up from me for owning it.

@merej99 That's amazing. I never really thought of it that way before. I just felt a need to explain that I was wrong. How and why I was wrong. And apologize sincerely for being a something I'm normally not... a giant jerkwad :D