Why much of our schooling is oppressive - a must-read for anyone who cares about our schooling

in philosophy •  8 years ago  (edited)

The biggest problem of our education is not the way it is financed or the training of capable teachers or the standards of our curriculum. I admit that these are problems. The biggest problem, however, is our school paradigm. If we would like to fundamentally improve our education, we should first reflect on the core characteristics of our schooling.

Our current school paradigm looks as follows:

  1. Brainless routine. The acceptance that children from the tender age of 4-5 years old should be submitted to the oppressive routine of 12 long years, 9 months a year, 5 days a week and 7 hours of schooling every day.
  2. Isolation. Children learn in this schooling period that they live in a falsified reality that is entirely isolated from the real world.
  3. Class position. Children are classified by age and class number. Sometimes they are also classified by student number.
  4. Obedience. The bathroom can only be used with permission from the teacher. Their speech is regulated and must coincide with the interests of the teacher. Every pupil must sit still like a meek little sheep while listening to the teacher.
  5. Loss of freedom. Children lose their freedom to think on their own and to focus on their own ideas and interests. In addition, they are not allowed to walk out of the classroom without permission from the teacher.
  6. Enthusiasm and passion are tempered. Children that are enthusiastic about a subject have to put their enthusiasm aside if the teacher decides it is time to move to another subject. Under the guise of learning ‘discipline’, they are encouraged to engage in activities of repetition and boredom. Those who are defiant will become stigmatized as rebels and receive behavioral disorder etiquettes.
  7. Emotional dependency. Children are taught to chase prizes, stickers and other forms of compliments and privileges that can be given or taken away by the teacher. They also learn to feel personal pride from the compliments they receive from the teacher. In cases when the teacher allows the student to talk in class or to slip out of the classroom, the student becomes thankful for the privileges that he or she is granted by the teacher.
  8. Intellectual dependency. Children are taught to wait for their teacher for instructions. They are not encouraged to act by themselves in class. The consequence is that we, the pupils of our school paradigm, become dependent on advertisements and news reports that tell us how we should dress, live, consume and think. In other words, children are taught to act in ways that are expected of them without self-reflection.
  9. Loss of self-respect. Their self-respect becomes dependent on opinions of ‘experts’. Monthly reports, grades and PTA days teach children that they should not trust their own self-evaluations.
  10. Stimulation of snitching and acceptance of constant surveillance. Children are rewarded to report bad behavior of other children.

If you consider the school paradigm from this perspective, it is actually a wonder that there are still people whose curiosity has survived their formal schooling. I believe like H.L. Mencken that the goal of public education or compulsory schooling had never been to enlighten the citizenry. The goal is to pull as many individuals toward the same level – a level in which obedience and conformity are central.

If our society is truly concerned with the development of her children, then our society should start asking critical questions about the school paradigm.

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

It might be somewhat radical is what you're saying, but I do not think is wrong.
However, is not it should be added below.

  1. You will learn that their opinion is not all right at school
    This means that you learn to listen to the opinions of others.
  2. You will learn the basics of the population living in the school.
    This means that you learn to be necessary as long as the limit of what you can do with individuals from out in society, the organization that the company continues to exist.

Hi @asim, thank you for taking time to comment on my post. I'm not so sure about 1. I think that in schools you learn that there is a person (the teacher) who is always right and that there are good and wrong answers, whereas many questions don't have black-and-white clear answers.
About 2, can we not learn it outside of schooling as well? Maybe even more efficiently?

Hi! @chhayli.
About 2 ,I think that it is possible even outside of school education.

Great post @chhaylin! Pretty much the story behind Pink Floyd's Another Brick in the Wall (part 2). :)

Thank you @dori97, :). Next to the important issues raised by Pink Floyd, Another Brick in the Wall is also a great song.

As a high school student I can't agree more. I'm tired of that, and in addition I avail myself with less than half hour of class (I study 8 hours a day)

  ·  8 years ago (edited)

To study, we don't have to be in class. As a matter of fact, if self-motivated we can learn much more by ourselves than through formal class settings. :)

Loading...

Excellent post, @chhaylin! I fully agree with you that we should rethink our shop paradigm.

Thank you, @nicku! I appreciate your comment. :) *btw, I think you have a typo. Shouldn't it be "school paradigm" instead of "shop paradigm"? ;)

schools are there to indoctrinate us into the controlled society in which we live. A way of enforcing the lies that are regarded as fact in society today . Instead of setting our minds free we are firmly placed within a box that most of us will never escape and who most dont even realise thats there.

I fully agree with you here, @willbeonceagain8 :)

They when they leave school and the struct guidelines have gone a lot of them can't handle the freedom and end up down the wrong path

Every person, I think, has to learn to deal with freedom indeed. Many people have lost how to handle freedom indeed. That's why it's so necessary to rethink our schooling, because it affects everyone from a young age :)

  ·  8 years ago (edited)

I totally agree, our children aren't allowed to be children with all the tests and pressure the schools put on them

This is why education in America is having problems with keeping up with more progressive governments on education

I've seen first hand the school system stifle many bright & creative children. Hell, I was one of them myself when I was in school... somethings gotta change!

That's how I feel as well. I think that no one goes through schooling unscathed. We should change it! :)

Never thought I would see the day when some sharp person would put this issue on the front burner

  ·  8 years ago (edited)

Haha, thank you for your kind words @cannabisclub :)

Very nice post, and spot on regarding the general goal of American compulsory education. One thing we need to be mindful of, I believe, when asking these questions, is the level of desire in the audience to actually have those questions answered. I am constantly reminded of the level of rhetorical concern these days, and I've noticed if the messengers expectations are too high, there can be some disappointment and energy draining push back. Just thought I would throw that out there, as I've dealt with this subject on a few fronts. Thanks for this post and motivation. Cheers

Thank you for your kind comment, @voxpop! Yes, I've noticed that I have had too high expectations when convincing other people on on educational/political topics that it has left me disappointed most of the times.

You're welcome chhaylin. One thing i've found that helps a little is props lol. In this case if you can get your hands on an older copy of "Towards World Understanding". It's the 1948 education manual put out by UNESCO, the education & science arm of the UN. Distributed to educators throughout the US, warned about on the house floor by a congressman in 1954, and very clear as to the goals of our public education system. It's a real eye opener & clears a lot of things up.

Hi @voxpop, I just downloaded a copy of the book. Thank you for suggesting it to me as I am not familiar with the book yet. I have read another book about UNESCO though. It's called "Unesco: Its Purpose And Philosophy", written by its first president Julian Huxley. A shocking book to say the least.

Thanks. I will check it out.

I agree completely with ALL the statements. Our educational system is flawed. It took me quite a lot of years to un-learn all the creativity-sucking habits they teach.

Yes, I feel the same, @menta :). It's hard to unlearn being obedient and conformistic. It's like our schooling system has sucked the life out of our bodies.

  ·  8 years ago (edited)

While I agree with your critique, I also think that your take on the issue of education addresses only the institutional half of the argument. The other half is the problem of the child itself. Believe it or not but most children as in 90% of children find school to be annoying no matter the background, type of school or even what pedagogical method is practiced. the root of this problem lands not only in the institution but also in the family or rather the social environment of the child. The ultimate challenge of every pedagogical method is focused on nurturing the child no matter the origin and resources that support them. If you are interested in matters of education Pierre Bourdiex's paper The Forms of Capital is an excellent introduction into the challenges inherent in education.

Thank you for suggesting this book for me (again). I remember you told me about the book in one of our many philosophical discussions. :)

My biggest problem with education is that you separate from your children and rely on total strangers to help instill the values you want your children to grow up with. A lot of times I will say something to my kids only to be told that their teacher lets them do it.

  ·  8 years ago Reveal Comment