RE: There Is No Such Thing As Free Will

You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

There Is No Such Thing As Free Will

in philosophy •  7 years ago 

if something causes everything all the time then everything Neo did was predetermined.

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  
  ·  7 years ago (edited)

Ahh. But my point is every little thing we do must have some sort of predetermined outcome, depending on the choices that we make. I look at it like a tree with branches. The branches represent paths based on choices. Each path leads to a "pre-programmed" outcome via an event or it could be a series of events, and each of those series of events have their own branches and each of those branches have branches, and so on. So there are literally an infinite amount of outcomes for each path, branch, and sub-branches, to infinity. But, my theory is that each path leads to some sort of pre-determined outcome. For example, if someone chooses to walk out into the street in front of a moving truck, then the outcome of that chosen path will be being hit by the truck, but branches of that include death, paralysis, being missed by the truck, etc. Or one could choose not to walk in front of the truck, which would lead to an alternate path, but there is still something waiting on that path as well. We can choose because of free will, which includes the ability of knowing right from wrong, etc., but choices have outcomes, which are predetermined or pre-programmed, like with a computer. This stuff is deep. This is the kind of stuff I spend time studying. It's all so fascinating!

Again, how can you be certain that your choices are yours and not influenced by an external factor?

EVERYTHING is influenced in some way by some external factor, but the will involves how we choose to respond, like playing the hand we are dealt. Free will has to do with choice but just because there are some things outside of our control doesn't negate the fact that we can make choices of our own will.

How do you know that your will to respond is not influence from yet another factor? If Life has you on a planet with no way to go outside then your "choices" are limited to the things around you. In the same way a prisoner in a cell has a choice to pee in each of the 4 corners of the cells but nowhere else. Our decisions are not are own. They are the aftermath of our interaction with our environment.

Yes. But the point is, we still have choices within whatever realm of limitation there is. Choice is still choice. The fact that the universe has boundaries does not negate that choice exists.

choice does exists. the question is; is it yours?