Study Shows Right Wingers in a Particularly Extreme Insular Bubble

in propaganda •  6 years ago  (edited)

Professor Yochai Benkler and colleagues have published detailed accounts of news media producer and consumer network analysis studies proving that the political right wing is in an extreme bubble of unreality and conspiracy mongering, while almost the entire rest of the world forms a diverse diffuse network of relatively moderate fact-based (generally) civil discourse. (Although one has to say the "fact-based" discourse is still dominated by propagandists, so it is "fact-based" only to the extent that the centrists and leftists seek out confirmation of claimed facts, rather than wholly giving in to insane conspiracies --- Chomsky's manufactured consent is still thriving, continuing to veil the real world from the sight of most people).

For deep background reading (which apparently only the left-wing and centrists engage in) see the excellent book: The Wealth of Networks: How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom"
http://benkler.org/Benkler_Wealth_Of_Networks.pdf
and
"Network Propanganda: Manipulation, Disinformation, and Radicalization in American Politics"
https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/network-propaganda-yochai-benkler/1129078833

It is a bummer Benkler's network study cannot do the same analysis back in time, to trace the history and progression of the right wing insularity. (Although using other archives a weaker network study might be possible somehow? e.g., like at least tracing subscriptions.) My suspicion is that the insularity on the political right has been growing over time and has exploded with first the appearance of the Fox News network and then with the crazy radio hosts who were inspired by Limbaugh (although I think it can be traced back further with many predecessors going back many decades) and now Jones and the online media. And I also suspect this is ultimately going to collapse. Honestly, I think such an insular network based on an evident false diet of hateful propaganda and biased stories and downright lies cannot self-subsist for too long before reality exposes them and they collapse under their own lies. At some point even the nutcases will realize it is better for one's health (both financially and psychologically) to be well-informed than misinformed. Especially if the right wing network demographics is ageing, which I also suspect to be the case, they are bound to diminish into irrelevance. They are likely shrinking not only in diversity but in population as well. The question is, will they survive long enough to have their cherished full-on fascist moment in history?

The lesson I have drawn from the likes of Benkler and analysts like Allan Nairn and Yanis Varoufakis, is that the Alex Jones wingnuts and Bannon--Boltan--Bolsanaro fascists are not our biggest problem, they are merely the proximate threat. The real threat to us all in the longer term are the mild mannered politicians who know nothing about the real economy, these are your well-educated but profoundly ignorant privileged centrists and moderate liberals ad democrats. They are not in touch with real working people, and they have for decades misdiagnosed the real ills of the economy. These arrogant elites who are over-educated in knowledge and profoundly under-educated in morals are the true threat precisely because their politics are what currently run the world, and they are the ones directly responsible for fanning the flames of fascism. The more their policy agenda (essentially a sour blancmange of market driven austerity politics known as "neoliberalism") funnels profits from the workers up to the weathly rentiers and fancialists the more the seeds of fascism are sown.

What sustains these right wing lunatics is, however, not their own network, but the equally insane and far more destructive forces of neoliberalism, which have both right wing and centrist champions. They (the neoliberal collective) have been the historic cause of all the economic austerity and suffering in the world, not the ultra-right. So unless neoliberals are crushed and vanquished once and for all, these violent fascist right wingnuts will continue to survive on their diet of hatred for the neolibs (who they would consider "Normies"). The tragedy is that these right wingers do not see that the Tea Party and Freedom Caucus idiots are just another corrupt wing of neoliberalism: see Mirowski's "Never Let a Serious Crisis Go to Waste" --- neoliberalism is truly a vast collective covering centre left and centre right think tanks, lobbyists and politics, and the likes of Pelosi, Schumer, Perez and Nadler are part of this global neoliberal collective, as are Macron, Theresa May, Scott Morrison, Trudeau, and yes, even Trump. All are neoliberals, all favouring big money interests of various stripes, all favouring market driven "solutions" to every problem, just with slightly different biases.

BTW: this is not conspiracy theory, the neoliberals are not a global conspiracy, read Mirowski's book --- the neoliberals are in fact split into many viciously warring factions, but they are all unitedly deluded by their own rhetoric and misreading of economic reality, and this unified misreading of economics (basically neoclassical market economics) is what characterizes global neoliberalism. Neoliberals conspire not by design, but by simple banal common miss-education of each other. Prime example: consider Obama... how he moaned and bitched about not being able to do what he wanted in 2008 and how he said he had no other option but to bail out Wall Street... that was prime grade A neoliberal bullshit. He sure as hell had other options, by executive order, e.g., he could have fired all the bankers but bailed out the bank institutions, and nationalized the banks for a short term, or turned over the banks to cooperative ownership to truly ensure an end to fraudulent loan practices. Obama had so many weaker options open too, but he failed to even do even the weakest to stand up to Wall Street. He did not deploy progressive responses to the 2008 crisis because he was blinded by listening to the snake oil salesmen of neoliberalism, Tim Geitner and Larry Summers, Ben Bernanke, et al. In summary: these are the f**kers we need to get rid of in order to starve the right wingnut machine of it's oxygen.

The tragedy of the sincere neoliberal is that they cannot see how they are the ultimate fuel that flames the hatred of fascism.

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!