The Mysterious Death of Elisa Lam

in psychology •  7 years ago 

Image of Elisa Lam

Elisa Lam - Image Source


Introduction


ThinkstockPhotos-498805260.jpg

Many mental health related deaths could be prevented.

Life is strange. With over 7 billion people on the planet it is not surprising that odd things happen to some people.

Many people meet unfortunate ends and it is sad that in many cases these deaths could have been prevented.

This is particularly true of mental illness related deaths where the signs and symptoms are often missed and a particular situation only comes to light after a person's death.

The Elisa Lam case appears to be one of these situations. What I find particularly troubling here is that despite the outward appearances here some people have tried to sensationalise this story as some kind of supernatural mystery.


Who Was Elisa Lam?


ThinkstockPhotos-639736408 (1).jpg

Lam was travelling in Los Angeles.

Lam was a young Canadian tourist who was on holiday in the United States in early 2013.

Like many young people she shared her life and her travels on social media.

As part of her journey she had been staying at a famous hotel in Los Angeles known as The Cecil Hotel (it is now known as "Stay on Main").

This hotel is famous for being the historical haunt of at least two serial killers.

It also seems to be in a historically impoverished area of town and has been associated (like many low cost hotels) with all sorts of crime, misfortune and suicides.


Lam Disappears


Hotel_Cecil_LA.jpg

The Hotel Cecil - now known as "Stay on Main".

On the day she was due to check out of the Hotel, Lam did not phone her family - something which was unusual for her.

Further she did not check out of her hotel room and had left her belongings there.

Due to the uncharacteristic behaviour and their inability to find her, Lam's family contacted the authorities and a missing person's case was launched.

There was particular concern as she had a history of bipolar disorder (manic depression) for which she had been on medication.

There had been no outwards signs of her being depressed but it is natural that it would be a worry.

A search of her room did not really suggest any clues.

Police could find no signs of foul play or indeed anything to suggest where she could have gone.


Body Found in Water Tank


Lam just seemed to have disappeared - at least until some strange problems emerged with the hotel water supply a couple of weeks later.

People in the hotel were complaining of low water pressure and a strange taste/discolouration of the drinking water.

When investigating the issue hotel employees discovered the decomposing body of Elisa Lam in one of the water towers on the hotel roof.

There is some debate made about how accessible this water tower was. Some people have suggested that it was impossible to access the water tower due to various security measures.

However these claims have been refuted as it appears it could have been accessed using the fire escape:

This Youtube video shows how a fit, young person could easily get there - it is in Chinese (I think) but you don't need to understand to see.

If the video maker could get there (after Lam's death) it was certainly not impossible for Lam to get there.

Indeed it may have been even easier then since nobody had died in one of the water tanks previously and one would presume security would have been more lax.


The Autopsy


Autopsy Pg1.jpeg

The Autopsy Report - Source

The autopsy which is available on-line in various places (including here) concludes that this was an accidental death with bipolar disorder as a contributory cause.

"The decedent died as a result of drowning. A complete autopsy examination showed no evidence of trauma and toxicology studies did not show acute drug or alcohol intoxication. Decedent had a history of bipolar disorder for which she was prescribed medication. Toxicology studies were performed for the presence of these drugs. However, quantitation in the blood was not performed due to the limited sample availability. Therefore interpretation is limited. Police investigation did not show evidence of foul play. A full review of the circumstances of the case do not support intent to harm oneself. The manner of death is classified as accident."

Some important things to note are the fact that the body was quite decomposed on recovery. There were insufficient samples for full blood testing and this is not unusual in such cases.

It should also be noted that although she tested negative on a drug screen this would only have tested for the most common drugs of abuse.

It would not be able to test for everything, including newer "legal highs" which will be too new to have specific tests for them.

So although it is thought she was not under the influence of any drugs this cannot be said with 100% certainty.

That said given her previous medical history it makes sense to suspect that her previous bipolar disorder may at least have been related to her death.

It is also possible that she might have an unusual response to certain chemical agents or drugs as a result of her existing psychiatric medication.


The Elevator Video


Following the discovery of Elisa Lam's body a video emerged which appears to have been taken from the Hotel elevator.

The video seems to show Lam behaving in an odd and erratic manner.

At times it appears she is looking for someone, other times it looks like she is hiding. She also seems to pressing a lot of buttons on the elevator in a manner which seems illogical.

There are also segments of the footage where she makes some unusual hand gestures.

It appears that this video is one of the main reasons for people suggesting some kind of supernatural explanation for what happened to her.

People have suggested that she was taking part in some sort of ritual known as "the elevator game".

From what I have been able to ascertain this is some kind of urban legend based game that teenagers play (like Bloody Mary).

The aim seems to be to access an alternative reality as a result of playing around with the elevator (wikipedia has a summary here).

They also point to the fact that she appears to be seeing someone who is not there and contorting in physically impossible ways.

I don't see any of that.


My Opinion of the Elevator Video


To be honest I find these assertions quite ridiculous.

Firstly it should be made clear that the video is short and of relatively poor quality so the amount of information we can infer from it is limited.

That said, on watching the video her behaviour may seem strange but it is entirely consistent with someone who is suffering from some sort of psychotic episode.

Screenshot 2017-06-24 17.03.23.png

The video is short and of poor quality.

This would include seeing or perceiving things that are not there.

Basically psychosis can be translated to "losing touch with reality" in laymen's language.

The person suffering psychosis may experience hallucinations and delusions which may account for unusual behaviour.

There are all sorts of causes of psychosis the two most commons ones would be drugs (legal or illegal) and schizophrenia.

There is also an overlap in terms of some of the signs and symptoms between delirium (clouding of consciousness/confusion as a result of conventional physical illness) and psychosis. Indeed you could even see a combination of these causes resulting in bizarre behaviour.

Further I see no evidence of impossible contortions - that is clearly an exaggeration or misrepresentation of the footage.

This video is strong evidence to me that this is a person who was suffering from some form of psychosis or confusion and as a result (in this vulnerable state) climbed into a water tower and drowned.

Although there is no evidence of anyone else being involved we cannot be sure of that or rule it out completely. That does not mean there is anything supernatural or magical going on here.

It may be tragic and sad but these sorts of things happen more frequently than most people would presume. Just because something appears unusual or odd doesn't mean we should jump to a magical explanation.

Accidents happen, and mental illness can increase the probability of them occurring.


Conclusion


ThinkstockPhotos-495948590.jpg

Tragedies and accidents happen. Could this have been prevented?

This is a very sad case where it appears a young woman died in a bizarre set of circumstances.

While it is bizarre there is no reason to assume it is supernatural and I think these kind of theories illustrate just how ignorant most people are of mental health problems.

I also think it distracts from some of the more obvious points that relate to whether this death could have been presented.

There are some obvious safety issues that need to be examined here. -The Lam family did try to sue the hotel but the case was dismissed in 2015.

The fact that someone visiting after Lam's death was still able to easily access the water tanks does seem to be a cause for concern.

If access to the water tanks had been more restricted perhaps this tragedy would not have happened.

Even if we put aside the risk of drowning (which is improbable to happen again) it would seem strange that unauthorised people should be able to access (and hence interfere) with the hotel water supply.

That just seems to be rather risky for public health and safety reasons.


Thank you for reading


ThinkstockPhotos-480219054.jpg




Steemithelp.net

Are you new to Steemit and Looking for Answers?

Please visit:

Steemithelp.net

A collection of guides and tutorials that cover the basics of Steem and Steemit.


Follow me Steemit & Twitter.

All uncredited images are taken from my personal Thinkstock Photography account. More information can be provided on request.


Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

Such a sad story. But I also have to spare a thought for all those who used/drank (!) water at that hotel during the period Lam was missing.

Yes I can only imagine how they felt it is like a kind of accidental cannibalism.

this is a departure from your usual posts in one sense since it almost verges on investigative reporting, but in an other sense, it's very consistent with your style and your interest in medical/psychological subjects.

You approached the story with compassion and sensitivity and I think your analysis and conclusions are sane and plausible.

One needn't venture further than psychosis as a probable cause for the woman's unfortunate death.

Not to detract from the impact of your other excellent posts, but I liked this one especially because you utilized all your gifts in this article and I look forward to others of the same type.

Excellent work!

Thank you so much you are too kind:)

honestly, Ricardo, everything you do is professional and of excellent quality - I just happened to like this post for the reasons I mentioned and also, I gave some thought to this when I saw the newspaper accounts, but your mentioning the mood disorder and probable psychosis put my questions to rest. Thank you.

Very good inet detective work

Thanks!

Great write up man. I saw the video when it was going wild online and heard all the conspiracy theories. At first watch it really does seem to be something strange going on. I never thought it was some sort of supernatural thing but the idea did cross my mind that maybe someone off camera was speaking to her. I never heard about her bi polar though, which adds a whole new dimension to the story and makes a lot of sense in hindsight. Great post!

Thanks mate. Nice to hear from you again:)

Thanks for sharing this and my condolence to the family. May her gentle soul rest in peace.
As you indicated, her health issue might be the cause and should be well adressed when others show such behavior. I only wish that this our dear steemit forum will help send out the message. Thanks for sharing, you earned my upvote and follow.

Yes definitely RIP Elisa and may her family find peace. In many ways it is the ones who are left behind who suffer the most. Thank you for your kind words.

Welcome and lets stay in touch

It top news previously.. what I think is she talk to a demon.. 👿👹

I don't think so but she may have believed that she was talking to a demon or a ghost or something else.

Yes.. something like that.

I've only been on Steemit a few short says and this was the most interesting piece I read. I'm a very spiritual person and I have experienced and witnessed bizarre phenomena, so at first I felt this was entirely one of those cases. Yes, still weird nonetheless, but the way you laid this out made me consider a multitude of things. You broke this down. Great job! I look forward to more of your posts. This noobie (yours truly) can learn a lot from you.

I'm glad I'm not going to bed yet, this gave me the creeps, what ever the real cause for her death was.

Real life is creepy and mental illness - particularly psychosis can be terrifying.

I always feel for her family when I see some of the nonsense that has surrounded her death.

Yes definitely!

Thank you for sharing ❤️❤️❤️

You're welcome!

This gave me the creeps, what ever the real cause for her death was. :(

Thank you:)

Very sad story...Investigation needs ...Just to say this is supernatural not reality...

Thank you!

Welcome....I agree with you about your valuable post...

So many troubled people are left wondering this planet. Some of them are lucky enough to leave early.

Very true. Not sure if it is lucky or not though. Depends on your situation I suppose!

Yeah, I am kinda grim

The guy I take care of takes bipolar meds, something called Latuda. I don't know if it's from this or all the other psychotropics he's on that cause it or not- but he staggers around falling constantly. He also behaves erratically, doing things he doesn't know he's doing or remember afterward.

Now, obviously I can't speak to what happened to Ms Lam, but I can say without equivocation that those psychotropic drugs cause far more harm than good. That I can attest to first hand... I've seen what they've done to a useful intelligent man.

It depends. In the case of the elderly they can cause problems but they can be a life saver too. It is a case of using them with caution and adjusting dosage if there are side effects. Sometimes people end up on a particular dose and it never gets reviewed.

This guy is under the care of several doctors for depression, bipolar, etc. and they're all prescribing tons of meds (without contacting one another, I believe) plus- he's 65, so the results are predictable! I hope something like that didn't happen to Ms. Lam. If her case is anything like his (and I don't think it is) she could have easily have fallen in without realizing. Great post... I love ones that raise more questions than they answer... makes you think!

That sounds typical. Often elderly people are on so many medications that the interactions become crazy. We used to admit people to hospital sometimes when I was working in Stroke medicine and we sometimes had people on like 20 different meds. The reason was that every specialist was prescribing them something different and nobody was overseeing everything in totality. We often found they improved because we had to stop all their medication in the acute situation.

That's what I wish would happen to him. In 2003 he got Graves Disease and had his thyroid irradiated effectively killing it. He dropped to under 100 lbs. He got depressed about it and the docs started him on antidepressants. When asked how he felt he said OK some days but not others... Oh Oh- you're bipolar... here take some of this!!! If I had my way all of these quacks would be in prison!

That's the thing you have to be very cautious using multiple medications especially in the elderly. Who knows how many people die as a result of the side effects - falls seem to be a very common issue in elderly people and polypharmacy is one of the causes.

How well I know, my friend! I barely sleep, listening for cries for help from downstairs. Then I have to pick him up, get him back into bed (then usually mop up pee where goes on the floor). I keep wondering if he wouldn't be better off in a home... except that I know he wouldn't. He has periods of lucidity and near functionality... he would be miserable put away, especially during those times which he would find unbearable.

Thanks for such an in depth post on this tragic story. I had caught it initially at the time but didn't know many of the details.

So sad that no one was able to notice her pain and be there for her.

Sometimes all it takes is one of us to smile, say hi, need help, whatever to make a difference. We need to consider everyone as a neighbor and act as one. Make a difference today!

Yes agreed. In her case it may have been a sudden change. There is no way to be sure though because she was travelling alone. Her parents spoke to her everyday but people with mental illness can sometimes mask how they are.

Now that's one bizarre story!!! The thought of drinking that water, eeeewww!!!!

Yes people were drinking it for weeks. It is horrible.

I recall seeing this on the news or social media. I didn't know all the details as you presented there. That video was disturbing. If she wasn't experiencing anything supernatural and having an psychotic episode I could see her running away and finding a safe place to 'hide'. It is crazy that access to the roof was still so easy after. Spooky post. Not even close to Halloween yet.

Yes and to be honest who knows what she perceived the water tank as - may she didn't even see the water.

yeh. Sound like you have seen these types of psychosis conditions first hand at work but have you ever had any supernatural experiences or believe in it?

Well I don't dismiss them out of hand. I have never had any supernatural experiences but I did suffer hallucinations and delusions when I was very ill with pneumonia (and encephalitis) once. I thought everyone in the hospital was trying to kill me and kept trying to escape.

Oh man, that must have been terrifying. This story got me thinking about a time I stayed in a 'haunted' hotel in Austin. I'm gonna start writing it and post it in a few days. see ya

Yes luckily I remember very little about it beyond little fragments. Cool let me know when you do the post.

Ok. I want you to debunk it. : ) and thanks for the resteem I just saw that. Much appreciated.

NP:)

This is so sad:( breaks my heart seeing that smile on her face in the first picture

Yes it is.

I love this story. They try to make it seem like some murder mystery on some tv shows and youtube videos but I agree.. Had to be some type of mental issue. Just in her behavior. People have done odder things.

Yes definitely. It is sad but this kind of sensationalising ignores the actual issue which could be handled better.

oh man saw this on buzzfeed unsolved and top5s. so weird

Weird but not supernatural.

Quite the conclusion you have there mate. I'm a sucker for these kind of stuff. What do you think of "Lam Elisa" TB test which seems to be connected to this cas somehow?

Coincidences happen. To be honest the connection is incredibly tenuous at best. I'm sure you if you looked at a lot of cases hard enough you would find coincidences.

Interesting, never heard of the case.
People like sensations. They also dislike thinking about mental illness, because it is so... intangible? non-grappable? You cant hide from it behind a filter, cut it away or treat it without seriously messing with yourself.
Two good reasons for it to turn into what it did.

While I agree with most of your conclusion, I have one big disagreement with something you implied. (Maybe you didnt and I misinterpret, which makes the whole argument mute. Sorry for waisting time in that case.) I am also going off-topic here.

While the health/safety issue with not protecting the watersupply is very problamatic, I do not agree with the assumption that the tanks should have to be drownproofed somehow. I am sorry for the poor girls death and her families suffering, but businesses do not exist to prevent people from doing bad/harmful/stupid things.

Favorite example (really off-topic now, no comparison):
If you burn your hand on the hot coffee you just ordered, your an idiot. I you blame the cafe and sue them for not warning you that the hot coffee is indeed hot, your a idiot³. Dont even get me started on the judge that rules you to be right...

Thanks!

While the health/safety issue with not protecting the watersupply is very problamatic, I do not agree with the assumption that the tanks should have to be drownproofed somehow.

It's a tricky issue and I can see your point of view too. I think you can't deathproof the whole world and you can't prevent accidents 100%.

Also this is a very freak sort of incident.

What worries me more is the fact that people could (if they had bad intentions) interfere with (e.g. poison) the water which I don't think is excusable.

What worries me more is the fact that people could (if they had bad intentions) interfere with (e.g. poison) the water which I don't think is excusable.

Yeah, that's quite crazy. Sure, if someone wanted to poison the water, they could always drill a hole, but at least make them work that much... They didnt even have the hatches closed.

That's the thing there could have been bird droppings and all kinds of crap (literally) in there!

There probably are. Well, that's one hotel I'll never be drinking water at ;D

Lol! Bring your own water if you have to stay there!

When we're talking of people on psychiatric medication I think there's no need to look for supernatural explanations. Could be the mental illness or some side-effects of the medication she was on. This is the first thing that came to mind as just a bit earlier I read an article about the side-effects of some antipsychotics prescribed to children.
Yet, as someone that used to be a journalist, I know that the media will try to sell this sad story as something unexplained and supernatural.

Yes sadly supernatural sells better. Also they would want to play down any side effects of medication as it might not play well with certain advertisers.

I've heard of this disappearance before.
Really bewildering as her case is truly uncanny and mystifying.
Will we ever know what happened?
RIP Elisa

Whilst the exact events will never be known I think it is pretty likely this was a mental health issue.

Wow, you really have moved the bar on creating good content @thecryptofiend. I personally had never heard of Elisa Lam or the bizarre way in which she died, but you had me hooked and I had to find out more. I have spent another 40 mins on YouTube researching more.

While there clearly is nothing supernatural surrounding her death, it clearly shows the devastating effects mental health issues can have on people. While we can only speculate to what had happened, the poor girl obviously needed help and unfortunately, still in this day and age, there is never enough help and support for those that suffer from these severe conditions.

You certainly have my creative juices flowing now, so will be researching some topics that pique my interest.

Thanks buddy!

Thank you for your kind words - one thing I forgot to mention is that she was also around the peak age when people start to develop schizophrenia.

So maybe we were looking at untreated early stages of schizophrenia? Poor girl. Such sad circumstances. How do we as a society not learn from these happenings?

Cheers!

Well it can sometimes be hard to spot - sometimes the first episode seems to come out of the blue but right now it is just speculation because there is no way to find out.

Too true!

Many thanks for the resteem! I feel loved!

You should pop in to PALnet on Discord sometime, we are in the process of setting up a Steem Team GB!

thanks for sharing master. no wonder people get psychotic. look at whats happening in the world.store-3b.jpg

Octopus-3.jpg

True. The world is becoming more and more distressing.

Nice :)

Thanks - I think it is not the best description given the subject though!

good post
my friend

Thank you!

welcome

Psychosis is also the term the use when describing someone who is interacting with someone who is there, but others can't see.

If many people experience the same thing, but not a majority of the people... it is just chalked up to psychosis.

I wonder what it was like when people started seeing color.
I wonder what it will be like as more people start experiencing more colors.

That is one point of view. Not mine though!

Great read! Sad story, but a well put together article for sure.

Thank you:)

This was an interesting story. I agree with your assessment. Occam's razor would seem to apply in this instance.

Thanks yes:)

A very sad read, I agree with you whe you say she looks like she is having a episode. She should have had a travel partner . Very sad

Yes definitely.

Hi, this subject matter is close to my heart! Please check out my video I posted a few days ago.

https://steemit.com/film/@feed-me-more/need-steemit-family-s-opinion-warning-dark-disturbing-content

wow
lont~~~~ post ^^;;
thank you for sharing

lont~~~~ post ^^;;

?

Congratulations @thecryptofiend

You took 67 place in my Top 100 of posts