Ok I could not reply to ur original question about Islam there so here is my answer. first of all when a Muslim does something wrong it's not upto another Muslim to judge him, instead are advice to hide his brothers sins, an't that what Jesus P.B.U.Him teached let those without sins cast the first stone. so why must a Muslim condon another Muslims because the sinned so do we but if we hide each other's sins God will hide our own sins. but one must repent to God and God alone. Tell me why do Christians go to a priest or what the call father "bless me for I have sinned" and confess they sin to a man who also sins himself. and not ask God directly to forgive his sins. I thought u have the holly spirit in you and God talks to you. and how can u commit sins since u have the holly spirt in you?