Attention whales, It is time for your action

in steemit •  8 years ago  (edited)


What falls has wings -- Lee Sang

한글 버전은 다음 링크를 참조하세요. (korean version)

http://www.ddengle.com/bitcoinshare/1373422

I compiled few charts together from steemle.com into this one.

This chart summarizes what is happening on the steem network.

While the number of accounts keeps increasing linearly, the number of posts and comments are decreasing every day. The number of posts and comments per user account show a steeper downtrend as you can imagine.


Interestingly enough, the market capitalization of the steem network shows a similar pattern.


Is it just coincidence? 

If most new accounts are not fake accounts for sotta sybil attacks, we need to think more seriously about why this is happening.

To me it is obvious that a lot of new users are easily disappointed after short-term plays. They heard that someone made $10,000 with one single post, and heard about simple travel posts or make-up videos that made tens of thousands of dollars.  Their main motivation to post is money. They believed that if you post like you do on reddit or facebook, then you will get paid hundreds or thousands of dollars through a mysterious wealth redistribution mechanism. While it is very difficult for them to understand where the money comes from, who cares? They are under the impression that if you just write, you get paid. Their assumptions are supported every day on the front trending page.

However most normal and boring people don't have the sexy white bodies that are constantly topping the front page, jaw-dropping stories that make you feel like you just learned a secret, steemit api powered web engines, nor do they create anarcho-capitalist propaganda. They begin to get the impression that there is nothing much they can contribute here.  They feel feel an increasing gap between the rich and poor on steemit. Their voting power has zero meaning here. After already experiencing this sentiment toward the everyday outside world, they begin to feel equally marginalized by the community in steemit. 

You may think, “just let those dumb and uninteresting losers go.” But if that continues to happen, who will remain to read and appreciate that content?

I think the whales' strategy of creating icons of overnight success by concentrating their voting power on a small number of posts is failing. It does not add new value to the system and it destroys the new active user base.

Here are my suggestions to give wings back to the steem network.

Short Term Action Plan

 

  • Stop powering down right now.
  • Stop voting for yourself and other whales.
  • Do not vote on a post if another whale has already voted on it.
  • Do not vote more than 2 times a week for the same author.
  • Spread out your voting power as much as you can.
  • Don't vote based on your political beliefs or your technological preferences.
  • Vote heavily on other blockchain platform and project announcements.
  • If you don't know or are not sure, give(delegate) your voting power to someone with better knowledge and experience.
  • Steemit, Inc needs to host more free giveaway events, contests, and challenges. Bring more active hobbyist and enthusiast groups and communities to the network.

We have already heard so many excuses for powering down such as server costs, hosting fees, dev costs, and the egg-nest story, etc... You guys already cashed out more than enough to cover those expenses for coming months or even years. You could live your life without power down cash outs up until 3 months ago.

The main goal of this short-term plan is to spread out voting power. It is far better to have 100 users to get paid $100 than one user get paid $10,000. We need a lot more of dolphins and minnows who enjoy the system.

Another precautionary suggestion: Let the market price drop. Don’t actively buy-back to maintain a price floor. Let the market price drop low enough to encourage new investors and whales to dive in.

Mid or Long Term Action Plan

 

  • Develop a better reputation system based on true decentralized identity.
  • Separate share ownership and curation power.
  • Curation power should be governed by the reputation system, not by share ownership.
  • Create a revenue stream utilizing the entire steem network power and value.



I am not sure these things currently have any realistic meaning for the steem network and it’s whales, but it is still in beta, isn’t it?

Also don't be afraid of voting on this post. You don't need to agree on everything I suggest for an upvote.

====

For your reference, I previously proposed a steem power rental market to reduce the need to power down.


https://steemit.com/steemit/@atomrigs/proposal-steem-power-rental-market

Even I tried to promote the steem network with my own steem dollars for Pokemon Go community.

https://steemit.com/pokemon/@atomrigs/1st-steemit-pokemon-go-gym-contest-beat-me


#steemit #steem #kr 


Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

I fully agree with you. I told same problem several times. The important thing is understanding what is human. Never push them into only economic motivation. SNS is network to communicate with people. Getting paid is second.
"Weg the dog " is the problem the steemit face

THIS!!. 커뮤니티는 사람냄새가 나야지 돈냄새가 나서는 안된다.!!

  ·  8 years ago (edited)

동의합니다..
그래야 성장하지요..
소아를 만족시키기 위해서 대의를 저버리면 주변부에 머무릅니다.

not necessary bad if there are less posts. Maybe bad quality posters get exhausted and give up ! I read someone saying he has already posted about 500 posts on steemit . Are they all good quality posts ? let me highly doubt it !!! Then good posters will focus on quality and not quantity. Regarding the price dropping, it's not necessary a good thing. new investors are discouraged seeing downtrend without rebound. The main problem is : it is not enough to post 1 good post, you need to get followers, to be known and appreciated, so it is rather a long term personal investment, and not a short term one as new users think reading steemit commercial.

The big guys should really read this post carefully.

I really hope so. I am so pathetic that I am asking whales' upvote while I suggested spreading their votes. How irony is it?

To me, it makes sense that the number of posts should decrease as the price goes down. Why's this?

When the Steem price decreases in USD terms, the amount (in US Dollars) paid out each day also goes down.

The incentive to post content is equivalent to the amount being paid out.

Therefore, as the price gets lower, the incentive to post content also lessens.

Then it is a vicious circle. The incentive is smaller, so less posts, so less network power, so less valuation, so less incentive again. The fundamental thing is money itself should not be the main force to bring users into community. The money factor should be an extra layer, not the base layer.

You could be right. I humbly disagree that it's a vicious circle.

This is well put together. I hope price is low enough to encourage the developers to stop powering down. There is also a difference between powering down and selling steem as powering down does not add selling pressure to the market.

You are spot on about flashy $ that so few people get. One of my first posts made $1650 so I was hooked. Most people aren't that lucky. Now my average post makes $0.10 or $0.15. it would be better for 1000 users to make $2 a post than 1 user make $2000 a post. A social network needs people spending time, so the masses need to have enough $ to feel good about their post but not so much they make money the focus.

Thank you for your comments. Yes the good thing is that price is getting low for new whales.

atomrigs I wholeheartedly agree with most of what you have said and I have been saying for a long time there's a big problem and the chart below says it all . and you have a good short term plan .
Short Term Action Plan

Stop powering down right now.
Stop voting for yourself and other whales.
Do not vote on a post if another whale has already voted on it.
Do not vote more than 2 times a week for the same author.
Spread out your voting power as much as you can.
Don't vote based on your political beliefs or your technological preferences.
Vote heavily on other blockchain platform and project announcements.
If you don't know or are not sure, give(delegate) your voting power to someone with better knowledge and experience.
Steemit, Inc needs to host more free giveaway events, contests, and challenges. Bring more active hobbyist and enthusiast groups and communities to the network.

You have some fantastic ideas here.

Dan and Ned have put a lot of work into this and if they don't wake up and make changes soon they may lose their dream .

Thanks, I like it!

cn 이랑 news 태그는 관계가 없는듯합니다

네 그렇네요. 지웠습니다. cn 은 주요 내용을 번역해볼까 했는데 이미 너무 늦은 것 같네요.

I have said since joining there are too many writers and not enough readers. Most seem to stick with the big earners and ignoring new posts that sre probably better, spread the love on Steemit

Exactly.

Good post.

Very good points. To the top this goes.

I think most accounts are experimental bots..

Even if those tens of thousand accounts are all bots, still the absolute number of posts and comments are decreasing every day.

Great post I agree that whales only voting for other whales will bring this wonderful platform to its knees.

In general, I like the vibe here... and Steemit is still in debug mode.

But nothing has been done to attract professional writers or make deals to co-host content with major sites in the crypto space. This won't happen by magic. Lottery payouts by whale voting may work with college kids, but a sites like Coindesk with 100,000 daily visitors won't play by those rules.

Interesting graphs. I would love to know how tight the correlation is between [posts + replies] and market cap. The shapes are similar, but the X axes are different sizes, so it's hard to tell how closely they move together.

Agree that more are signing up and content is decreasing. Hopefully things will balance somehow and things will turn in a better direction. All we all can do is our best and keep making positive actions & suggestions.

잘보았습니다. 좋은 제안 감사드립니다. 좋은 안목을 지니신분인거 같습니다. 부럽습니다

감사합니다.

Although it's a good post, but why #cn tag? Wanna flag.

  ·  8 years ago (edited)

I planed to translate it into chinese, but I gave up and removed the tag.

Im ok with people posting less. Gives me a better opportunity. I also think all the "blog and get paid" marketing isnt working, because like you said, many new users are dissapointed and leave. Its a great site, but the whales seem to upvote the same people every day which is becoming a turn off. All the posts with featured authors is kind of rediculus too. You shouldnt have to be featured. Anyways good post.

Yes, quality is more important than quanity. However the current voting system does not encourage quality though. Even some whales depend on bots for curating, and someone(?) thinks ASIC kind war among these bots will be the main dynamics for the quality. Wow! I guess google may buy out this project !

This post is very important to us. if this way, steemit will be success.

Thanks for your comments.

Absolutely it's good idea.

상부상조하면서 서로 도와주는것도 중요하지만 이제 막 태동하는 시기에 초기 유저들의 불편한 시각을 잘 정리해주셨네요. 똑같은 글인데 "왜 쟤는 나보다 수십배의 보상을 가져가지?"의 의문으로 시작해서 결국 떠난 사람들이 꽤 많은 것 같습니다. 스티밋이 긍정적 방향으로 발전하길 기원합니다.

We are being invaded by bots folks (someone must be creating Facebook & Reddit accounts fastly) and draining the 3.5$ reward one by one.

You have really thought this through in detail. Thank you. I will follow you,and hope to support a development where steemit becomes more fair,and more diverse.

This post has been linked to from another place on Steem.

About linkback_bot