US or Canadian 'junk' silver? Which do you prefer?

in steemsilvergold •  7 years ago 

A few years back, after buying some silver bullion coins as a numismatic hobby, I got interested in the so-called 'junk' silver coins and stacking.

The pro/positives of such silver, as frequently quoted in many sources online, are

  • there are usually low premiums over silver spot price
  • they are easily recognizable (and no need to show source of the mint)
  • they remain legal tender in the country of issue
  • they are obtainable in divisible quantities (ie. smaller denominations)

Residing in the US, it is very easy to get access to US junk silver coins, but over time, I came to prefer the pre-1967 Canadian silver coins.

Why? Because of consistency and easy calculations (yes, I am lazy in that respect).

Silver Canadian loonie dollars (years 1935-1967 mintage) are 80% silver, and each silver dollar is 0.6 oz of silver. That is, for every 10 Canadian loonie dollars, I know I have 6 oz of silver.

Yes, 1967-1968 Canadian dimes and quarters are some 50% silver only, and others without silver, so I just avoid them to save myself the hassle! So, if I avoid those mintage years, I know that:

10 Canadian half-dollars = 3 oz of silver
10 Canadian quarters = 1.5 oz of silver
10 Canadian dimes = 0.6 oz of silver

Easy-peasy, calculation-wise. Give me any face value of Canadian silver coins, I probably can calculate it in my head, how much silver there is. For example:

4 x $1 loonie dollars = 2.4 oz
5 x half-dollars = 1.5 oz
6 x quarters = 0.9 oz
7 x dimes = 0.42 oz (yes, this is a little trickier)

Meanwhile, US 'junk' silver coins are more diverse and harder to calculate. They range from 35%-90%, such as 35% Jefferson war-time nickels. Then, there are 40% Kennedy (1965-1970) half-dollars but don't confuse them with 90% 1964 Kennedy half-dollars!! But the majority of US junk-silver coins are actually 90% silver.

(Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Junk_silver)

The 90% percentage number is fine.....until you figure out what that means per coin. A $1,000 face value of silver dollars is 715 oz of silver, i.e. 1 single silver-dollar is 0.715 oz.... so, now, go ahead. Try figuring it in your head how much it is if you are looking at a handful of US silver coins.... say,
4 x $1 morgan dollars, or
5 x 1964 Kennedy half-dollars,
6 x Washington quarter, or
7 x mercury dimes.

Well, I just cannot do it in my head.... sorry, I just cannot do the math.

Don't troll me! I do have some as well! Just stating my preference and why....

I have both, but just prefer one over the other. Which do you prefer and why?

p/s: By the way, I am not officially a member of @steemsilvergold / @ssg-community and cannot participate with Stax or Precious, the Silver Mermaid? I am not sure how it works either. But I am not sure whether I qualify, as I don't always post about @steemsilvergold.... anyone willing to nominate and second me to membership?

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

I love the junk too! But i prefer the pre-67 Cad dollar over all for the simple reson of hand-feel:
Size, shape, tone (the audible kind too) and just overall satisfying handfull. The fact that they are a perfect 0.6 of an oz is juat a bonus to me.
Great post!
😎👍

Yeah, the audible 'clink' of the Canadian loonie is very satisfying!