Finding Your Way in the Land of Babel: Writing in a Second Language

in thewritersblock •  7 years ago  (edited)

As a writer, we want nothing more than for our work to be seen, read, appreciated. Right? Right. A lot of us write in English, even if it is not our native language.

When you’re like me and your native language is only spoken by a small population, that severely limits your reach. That is one reason to branch out into English. However, even if nobody were to read what I wrote, I would still write it. So that’s not my most important motivation. No matter how hard I try, I can’t seem to write in Dutch--at least not fiction. It never stops feeling stilted and artificial. That's why I write in English.

That being said, there are some real challenges to writing in a language not your own. I was fortunate enough to learn English at a very young age, but I still feel the differences somehow.


Tama66.jpg

Image courtesy of Tama66 via Pixabay

Whatsitcalledagain?

Vocabulary is not that big of a problem, I think. There are plenty of online dictionaries and thesauruses to be found. Use them to make sure you get your facts straight.

If it looks like a duck, acts like a duck, and smells like a duck...

A word may sound the same as it does in your native language, but have a completely different meaning.

I’ll use my own native language, Dutch, as an example here. Dutch and English are both Germanic languages, and thus, closely related to one another. Some words look and sound very similar. In English, a man would refer to his spouse as his wife. In Dutch, if a man were to call his spouse his wife, he’d end up getting smacked. Hard. A word that is perfectly acceptable in English, has a very derogatory meaning in Dutch.

To make a long story short, I’d choose my words carefully if I were you.

Tomato, tomahto.

Words may have similar meanings, but with a slightly different nuance. Take, for example, transparent and translucent. A transparent object is so clear that it’s almost invisible. A translucent object allows light to pass through it, but it creates distortion and/or diffusion of the light.

Be smart, you must.

You can only get away with sentences like these if you’re small, pointy-eared, green and wrinkled. The rest of us have to work at improving our grammar.

Grammar structures can vary greatly from one language to the next. How to conjugate your verbs, how to treat adjectives…

The best thing to do is practice. Use the language on a daily basis. Preferably in a place that will allow you to get feedback from other English speakers.

There are grammar check services you can use but they are a placeholder. Relying on them will hold you back from learning to do this yourself. Do yourself a favour and figure out the rules.

Classic pitfalls

Do I lay down? Do I lie down?
I lay a blanket on the ground and lie down on it.
In past tense, this becomes: I laid a blanket on the ground and lay down on it.
So, you use lay for objects you lay down. A person can actively lie down. Past tense is where it gets confusing.

There is the place where they’re meeting their maker.
Now, I know this sentence is not the prime example of beautifully flowing prose. But honestly. You try concocting a sentence with there, they’re and their in it. It’s really hard.
There: Points to a place. Where? There.
They’re: They are.
Their: Points to ownership. Whose? Theirs.
You can read more about it in this article, written for the SFT by kick-ass writer and editor @bex-dk.

Punctuation is important. Period.

It helps define the rhythm of your prose--the flow. That being said, you have to remember that punctuation varies depending on the chosen language.

Again, speaking from my own experience here, but Dutch speakers love their commas. We add them wherever we want to insert a breathing pause. I used to drive @bex-dk crazy with my overabundant comma placement.

Another example is the apostrophe. In Dutch, phonetics define the placement of the apostrophe. If the word ends with an open vowel, and pronunciation will change by adding a plural or possessive “s”, an apostrophe will be added. In English, the placement of apostrophes is reserved for a possessive "s."

I imagine other languages might have even bigger differences.

Go with the flow

How do you make your prose feel natural? A phrase that flows in French or German might feel stilted and forced in English or Dutch. That’s why it’s important to write your prose from scratch, in the language you want to end up with.

Writing in your own language and translating to English often doesn’t work very well. The syntax and rhythm of each language is different. We often fall prey to our familiarity with one language and end up forcing the second language into the patterns and rhythms of the original language. The more familiar you are with the piece, the sooner this tends to happen.

When you want to write in English, write in English. Allow your thoughts to flow in English. It helps you form the right patterns and choose the right colloquialisms.

If thinking is hard in English, find people to talk to. Join an online community where English is the language of choice. Talk to people. Practice. It makes perfect, you know?

If you can find an online writers’ community that’s a double win.

Wax on, wax off

This is what it comes down to. Writing is the easy part. Anyone can be a writer. But take that writing and clean it up to your best ability. Polish it until it shines. Perfect it. Find like-minded souls willing to review and critique it for you. Take their feedback and make your work better. This is what we do over at @TheWritersBlock. We help each other improve our drafts until they’re nice and shiny.

It can be intimidating for us, ESL writers, to show the work we’ve agonised over, to native speakers. They’ll find flaws and hiccups, no matter how hard we try. But every comment you receive is a learning experience. Take it with you, and never make that mistake again.

Then, resubmit your draft and do it all over again. Learning to write well has nothing to do with writing ‘til your fingers bleed. Make a choice. Either you write a new piece every day, but you’ll lack the time to learn from them, or you write a draft and you edit, improve and polish.

To everyone who tells me this is impossible: I can assure you it’s not.

I wrote and published my first story here on Steem in early September. Thanks to it, I found my way over to the Fiction workshop at PALnet, which later branched out onto its own Discord server, @TheWritersBlock. I workshopped that story, and edited while I still could. Since starting, I’ve written, workshopped and published all of nine short stories.. Nine. In three months. But each of those stories was workshopped, polished, workshopped again and perfected. Rather than churning out story after story, I approached each story as a lesson. I took my time learning them--sharpening my quill.

And my approach has worked well. If you’re a Steem based Fiction fan, you may have heard of Steemhouse Fiction trail. It’s a curation trail that looks for pieces that are publishing quality. The best Steem has to offer. All curated works are featured on their website, The SFT Library. More than one of my stories have been featured.

If I can do it, so can you.

Now go. Write. Workshop. Make me proud.

Hugs

Tiny

If you would like to read more of my stories, feel free to have a look around on my SteemShelf. Every story I have written so far has found a home there.


The Writer’s Block is a home to writers from every corner of the world, and from every discipline that involves the written word. I consider myself lucky to have found this amazing community. Not only have I found help, support and encouragement there, but I’ve found people who feel the same way I do about writing. I’ve found a second family there. Do you write? Would you love to be a part of a community that can help you learn and improve your writing skill? Our door is always open for kindred spirits. Come and pay us a visit by pointing your pointy thingie right here and clicking.






Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

I've read through this 3 times already and every time got something out of it. Wish there was a "best of" for Steemit. This should be pinned at the top of that list.

Thank you, Andrew. Your opinion means a lot to me.

I'm English and most of the people I know get all of the examples you mentioned wrong every time, especially 'their', 'there' and 'they're'.

Foreign speakers often have a more comprehensive knowledge of grammar because they learned 'by the book'.

Well, I learned before I could read, so it's not really by the book. But I do get what you're saying. Grammar knowledge is only part of it though. You need to familiarise yourself with the flow and feel of each language.

Well done on your success with English, given it's not your first language. Judging from your article you seem to have a better grasp of it than many native English speakers.

And yes, there, they're and their is one way to easily upset some of us. Not to mention to, too and two.

English, what a wonder it is.

Isn't it? But it's languages in general, I think. They grow organically and have a hard time fitting into rules.

This article is absolute total PERFECTION! You, Jasmien, are a true asset to our team of writers and editors on the Block. I hope you can be inspiration to others.... you sure are to me.

That feeling is entirely mutual, Bex. Hugs

  ·  7 years ago (edited)

Somebody give this woman a 500% upvote please!!!

This is exactly what it all boils down to in writing in a different language. I grew up in an English speaking country, currently I am living in an English speaking country, I am a certified ESL teacher even. But still, writing a decent story in English will never be as flowing as it will be in Dutch in the end. (I already see a lot of commas in that last sentence, darn @bex-dk was right again)

For me, the problem is not the grammar, its the lack of vocabulary in the fine nuances. Especially if you are writing stories and articles, these nuances are to me the cherry on top on if a story is pleasant to read or not.

Last Sinterklaas I was trying initially to write an English poem about Steemit, according to the Dutch tradition. It didnt work AT ALL.... I shifted over to Dutch, and the lines came flowing out in seconds.

In the end English will never be my native language, and that is okay.

A nice definition issue in English Dutch and Belgian differences to leave you guys with below

English: poo,--> taking a crap
Dutch: poepen (pronounce poopen) --> taking a crap
Belgian: poepen (pronounce poopen) --> having sex

Owyeah, Im resteeming the crap out of this ;)))

Aaaah yes. That is my favourite misunderstanding right there!!! Thank you so much for your kind comments, Karin. Hugs

This is a great article for a native English writer to read as well! I still sit and wonder about lay and lie at times. I guess it's an unexpected bonus that at my age I don't wander about while wondering.

Depending on where I am, I love wandering and wondering. ;-)

English isn't my first language either. I found it very useful to read a lot of blogs that I connected with and copy their own style, their voice, their speech tone.

Having examples to follow is extremelly useful.
Well Done
Cheers!

Thank you. I hope I can help some people with this article. Not only hand out pointers, but also encouragement. It IS possible.

Well done! I can sympathise. Writing in another language not your native tongue is very difficult. I have 3 languages and am in the process of two others. Sometimes I am not sure of the words and they pop into my mind in another language. Congratulations on your success. I am following you and resteemed your post.

I do that. I often Anglify German words or Frenchify Dutch words... It's annoying when you end up thinking: "Wait... Is this a word or did I just invent it?"

This article is very helpfull and contains lots of good tips. Thank you for taking the time to write this. I am also Dutch, but prefer to write in English. But as I am blogging on a Dutch platform, most of my stuff is written in Dutch. I will resteem your post, so I can read it again later on. Have a good NYE !

Thank you for your kind comment. We are actually starting up a language specific channel on the Writers' Block. Feel free to hop in. The more the merrier.

Good luck with your writing!

thanks, I will have a look.. steemit is still a bit hocus pocus for me ;-)

Upvoted and resteemed. How do you feel about having your posts translated into Hebrew for my community of noobs?

Are they trying to write in English? Or a different second language?

English. Most of them are Hebrew-speakers, but there aren't enough of us on the platform yet to merit much Hebrew content.

Wouldn't reading English be a good place to start practicing then? ;-)

True, that. Hence the resteem. :)

Very nicely written. I especially like the examples, being Dutch myself. I recognise a lot of what you say, and for a very long time I've also exclusively written in English because of the reasons you outline, studying very hard to overcome the hurdles, working on flow, etc.

Until two years ago, when I found a contest to send in something (story, articles, essay, manuscript, whatever) in precisely my own field (philosophy/psychology). And I immediately had a good idea, but not too much time to spend on it before the deadline (about one month). So I thought, let's just try writing it in Dutch. As an experiment, see where it leads me.
I didn't win the competition, but came fourth and would have won 'if creativity were the main criteria'. That was such a boost of confidence! So I continued working on that idea, sent it to a publisher, was rejected, worked on it some more and did my research, and now it will be published (with some addition chapters written in the meantime to make it into a real book) by a Dutch publisher!

Just posting this as a reminder, to never underestimate yourself and your native tongue. Don't close that door completely, you never know what the future might hold.
(And yes, I've also translated the manuscript in English and looking for an English publisher still... I mean, don't close the door to the English language either, right?)

I haven't given up on Dutch but it might be easier for me if I had a peer critique group like The Writer's Block. Want to start one?

Absolutely! If you know how to do it, I don't have those kinds of skills, but would love to be one of the editors/readers/contributors!

Well, I bet I can find a home for us somewhere. Are you on Discord? My name there is theme as here. Feel free to DM me about this.

Great guidance! It can definitely be a struggle for someone whose mother language is different from English to write and show that work to a native speaker or even someone who's also ESL but has a greater knowledge in the language. We know there are phrases that just don't sound good, we know there are words that we're misusing and still, the only way of improving is letting someone to guide us so we can apply that knowledge in our future work, right?

I should add, though, that if all the anxiety of using other language to write wasn't enough, while English has a somewhat easy grammatical construction (at least compared to other languages like German, French and Spanish) it lacks, in my opinion, a defined phonetic structure that often leads to confusions while trying to put some thoughts on paper...

Anyway, I'll take into account your wax on wax off advice in hope that one day writing in English feels almost as natural as writing in my mother language.

Excellent post!

With practice, it will. You got this.

so writing is your passion @tinypaleokitchen yes being dutch and writing in english you are doing a challenging job. All the best for your work and happy new year 2018

My passion, really, is creating. Writing is one of the ways in which I do that.

  ·  7 years ago (edited)

We'll done @tinypaleokitchen, great examples and advice. I often stumble even as a native English speaker. As an native English writer you may want to reference this post too (that's another good one to and too.) No matter what language you write in you still need to practice, practice, practice. Keep it up. Your writing is awesome.

So is yours! Hugs

This post has been voted on from MSP3K courtesy of @thinknzombie from the Minnow Support Project ( @minnowsupport ).

Bots Information:

Join the P.A.L. Discord | Check out MSPSteem | Listen to MSP-Waves

Your post sums all up what I needed in my writing. I like and love to write short stories too, but I know I have grammar lapses and sometimes I cannot pick up the right word/s. I signed up under the discord link you gave. Will they pay a visit to my articles and give me an honest feedback? Thank you. Happy New Year!

Thank you for your kind comment. When you want feedback, you are welcome to participate in our workshops and submit your drafts before posting your articles. ;-)

As ESL writer I am struggling with exactly these problems.
Your text is really helpful and I am thankful for your tips.

Thank you. I'm working on another article that will hopefully be useful in some way. ;-)

Love the Yoda reference 😉

Thank you! I can never resist being punny in my post titles. ;-)

You are a rare gem.... Wish I have such inspiration to write like this

I love love this post. Kudos to you for taking on other languages. You have a talent, very natural. I loved the part about getting slapped for being called a wife. Too funny, I was a wife once. Someone should have slapped me. Ha ha. Joke. Language has a life of it's own in a way. You do well with it. Blessings.

Thank you for your comment. Hope it was useful in someway. ;-)

wonderful writing of babel....nice blog.. thanks for sharing following

@tinypaleokitchen this post was presented at the most recent Pimp Your Post Thursday on the Steemit Ramble Discord. I have written a post to share your featured post. Just stopping back to let you know that you can see your name in lights right here. (Just kidding about the lights :)