"I Live In A World of Facts, Not Lollipop Land", or Fragile Masculinity Invades Yoga Space

in yoga •  8 years ago  (edited)

Poor Landsdowne Herakles is missing his penis.

So I had an interaction today at yoga today that isn't terribly unusual in my day-to-day experience with men who aren't my (awesome) husband but until now has been (blessedly) atypical within my yoga class.

(Though I've had some unusual interactions in yoga for sure, like the woman who informed me she had a gun in her purse and a license to carry it. Okay, that's fine. Carrying a gun to yoga seems...anti-zen? But you do you, babe.)

Anyway, today I came in early like I always do and I was a bit discombobulated. There were two people already there. I was familiar/friendly with one of them, a young woman we'll call Jay. There was a young man there, too, and I'd never seen him before in our class. He was very handsome, very fit, and had an accent. My initial impression was HOT DAYUM. Alas, that fell apart once he started talking. But now I'm jumping ahead. Let's call him Seb for the sake of this story.

In my discombobulated state, I told my pal Jay about  how Starbucks messed up my order and I'd probably end up getting a migraine now because they'd put milk in my coffee instead of soy milk. I followed it all up by saying, "And my husband will say, 'You weren't supposed to go to Starbucks anyway because we're trying to save money.'" 

We all laughed. 

Then Seb said, "Can I ask you a question? For the sake of my future relationships? Is it not okay for your husband to say that? About how you were not supposed to go to Starbucks because you are supposed to be saving money?"

I said, "Of course he can say that. And I can say, 'I know! Mistakes were made! And I'm being punished for my mistake by getting a migraine from the milk.'" I laughed again.

He said, "Ah, I see. Okay."

He then started helping Jay with a headstand, supporting her once she was up. It all started out okay, but eventually he started scolding her and accusing her of slacking when she decided to come down. She explained that she'd done the hard work of getting up, but he scolded her more, again saying she was slacking, and telling her the hard work of a headstand comes from maintaining it, not getting up. 

Jay said, "Thanks, Seb. I get it."

But he didn't let it go. 

Jay then said, "I understand what you're saying, but I don't really appreciate your lack of positivity, Seb, about what I accomplished."

So he started to scold her more about how she needed to do the work to maintain the pose even if she's being supported. She said, "I get it. I understand. Let's try it again"

But the dude would not let it go.

So I butted in. "Seb, you know how earlier you asked me about what you should and shouldn't say to women for the sake of future relationships? Well, when a woman says something like Jay's just said to you, the right response is 'Okay.'"

Welp, that broke his fragile masculinity into tiny pieces apparently, because he went right into the basic script of most men who feel their masculinity is threatened. I mean, it's basically a checklist.

1) The accusation of oppression or reverse discrimination:

He said, "I see how it is with you. You want one of the sexes to be submissive to the other. You don't want to listen to men's voices. Only one sex gets a voice."

I replied reasonably by saying, "No, I'm saying that she heard what you said, she understood, and now's a good time to let it go."

Fragile masculinity can't handle that, though, and so....

2) GASLIGHTING, aka accusations of the woman's lack of reasoning abilities (also known as, 'you're being silly' or 'that's not what happened' or 'you're overreacting') :

He said, and I quote, "Sorry, but I live in a world of facts not lollipop land."

Which, huh? How did that even address what I said or what had happened? But whatever. At that point, I knew what I needed to know about him. I checked out and Jay encouraged him to focus on helping her with her headstand. 

Side effect of unconvering a man's fragile masculinity, though? He went from being DAYUM HOT to UGH GROSS in the span of five minutes. And this is why so many men are really unattractive to me even if they're physically pretty. It takes more than a pretty face and body to get my respect and admiration.

I'm a little bummed that fragile masculinity and its resulting misogyny was present in my yoga class today. As I worked through the class, I realized that a) it's his problem, b) it's sadly symptomatic of too many men in this world. I feel sorry for him and his defensiveness, his fragile masculinity, his assumptions about women, and how ready he was to jump to accusations of 'lollipop land'. 

How sad to not be able to simply say, "I hear you," to a woman. How sad to not be able to step away from his need to be in control and in power to say, "So you understand what I meant? Great. I know next time you'll do even better." How sad to be ready and eager to dismiss what a woman says as being from lollipop land.

Oh well.

The troubles of the world invade even the best yoga classes, I suppose.

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

Great article! I really recognise the type,and I think I have been like that as well when I was younger.
The point I want to make is that I believe so many men are fragile in their masculinity,because masculinity is unnatural. Gender is a social construct,and masculinity and feminity are abstract constructs. Obviously they are based on a biological reality,I´m not denying that. But the biological reality makes up so very little of these constructs.
I´m a queerfeminist,and consider myself genderfluid,but I look like a normal guy,because I don´t work with my appearance. Masculinity is a trap for me though,and I wish I could get away from it, and be gender neutral.

But when you try to act outside of gender expectations , you are oftem met with incomprehension, ridicule,scepticism,and the breakdown of communication,especially in intimate encounters.

So, sadly I have not gotten too far out of the sinkhole of masculinity.

Thanks for your thoughtful response! I consider myself genderqueer as well, though I present as entirely female because, meh, who has time for dealing with all of that? Also I feel like my external presentation is so incredibly secondary to my internal feelings of gender. It's hard to explain.

I hear you about recognizing the type. I have lived for years with a man who respects me as a human being, who takes what I say seriously, who argues with me respectfully, and sees me as a full person, and never doubts his own manhood. So it's always a jarring experience to run into a man who operates from a place of fragile masculinity. It happens fairly regularly because men are absolutely terrified of what it might mean if they let this guise (or, as you put it, trap) slip.

I love that you call masculinity (and, I'm assuming, femininity?) a trap. It is, isn't it? It traps men and women and children and it stymies their growth as full people. Thanks for talking with me. I appreciate it. Good luck to you on escaping that sinkhole of masculinity. So many expectations! Such a mire!

Thank you! Yes to clarify, I think feminity is a trap as well. But I believe that the female gender role is subject to oppression more from a societal point of view,in terms of structural oppression. I believe,and this is just my subjective belief,that it is easier to be true to yourself being(or being perceived as) female.
But just after I wrote that,I find many counterexamples,making me want to take it back..
Maybe the biggest issue is male gendered people having problems expressing their emotions,and I certainly do myself.
I was "performing" the role of a woman in Second Life,and it felt quickly very natural,also to think of my " body" as a female one. And I really loved being a woman,although it was makebelief somehow. It felt oddly real. Sometimes I think that I will swith sex in the future,if we have insane nanotech,and it would be more trivial. But I´m still not trans..
I guess I´m just weird!
Oh by the way,read this awesome article on the topic of genderfluid!
https://steemit.com/howto/@derptard/how-to-effectively-repair-gender-fluid-leaks

Interesting that crying sex discrimination was his first response. Was there anything leading up to this that would have contributed to the male/female dynamic or competition in your mind? I mean for him (as a male, or hell, as a female for that matter) to accuse you of sex discrimination out of the blue seems...odd. I could think of lots of things to say as a smart ass comeback to you (if I was so inclined), but THAT would never even cross my mind!

Anyway, dude has issues. We all do. But some of us are humble enough to acknowledge and work on them and other's ego's are so fragile that they deny and hide them. I can forgive a lot if I see that the person is trying to work on his stuff. But I don't have time for people who don't.

Anyway, this was VERY good to know. Thanks for sharing. Xoxo.

As far as I recollect there was zero lead up aside from the conversation about Starbucks. It seemed entirely out of the blue to me. Even his tone about the Starbucks seemed oddly challenging, though that isn't obvious in my write up here. Maybe I had stepped into a conversation I knew nothing about when I showed up. He came across like he had a point to prove and maybe it wasn't to me.

A very telling post by @leta-blake. She is absolutely right: a man trying to peddle autistic "social justice" logic and pose like the victim around women is in for a loser's game with no upsides. Don't be like poor brainwashed Seb.

Sexism is sexy. "Fragile masculinity" and equalism are disgusting abominations.